Thanks, Carolyn, for sending that along. I think we can all sympathize with the poor guy.
We last left Ana and Chedward on the open sea. On a hilarious boat. (Yes, that's the boat picture Jaycie sent me and I lost and lamented through the entire last goddamn chapter. Isn't it magnificent?). Ana and Christian have just had the most pure, true-loviest, not in any way abusive and/or creepy sex that she wasn't allowed to pee for, and now she's gone to the bathroom and found something... amiss.
No, she's not peeing blood from a UTI, as you all gleefully speculated in the last recap's comments:
I gaze in horror at the red marks all over my breasts. Hickeys! I have hickeys! I am married to one of the most respected businessmen in the United States, and he's given me goddamn hickeys.So, yeah, she's covered in hickeys. I don't see what being married to a respected businessman has to do with it, other than Ana needing to remind us at every turn that she's married a rich husband and it's such a fucking hardship. Also, how is this guy a respected businessman, exactly? From everything we've seen of his company, he seems to run it with his dick. Ex-Domme wants a hair salon? Better buy it for her. New girlfriend has a job with a male boss? Not on my watch, pal, I'm buying the company. And then we'll take the company jet on our honeymoon, naturally! How is this jerk even successful, let alone respected? He's the CEO of a company that doesn't even have a board of directors, and he runs the place like a fifth grader's lemonade stand.
How did I not feel him doing this to me? I flush. The fact is I know exactly why - Mr. Orgasmic was using his fine-motor sexing skills on me.What does that even mean? And also, bullshit. How do you not feel someone sucking on you hard enough to give you a hickey, a bunch of times, all over your body? This is first person POV here, and the only time she mentions sucking in the last sex scene is when he's trying to make her come from playing with her tits. Plus, she was blindfolded, so the only things she could really describe to us were what she heard and what she felt. I'm so not buying any of this.
My subconcious peers over her half-moon specs and tuts disapprovingly, while my inner goddess slumbers on her chaise longue, out for the count.
I sincerely hope that bitch is dead. I hope Ana's subconscious bludgeoned her to death with a better book than this one while Ana was busy having orgasms.
Now, let's move on to the really fucking troubling part:
I gape at my reflection. My wrists have red welts around them from the handcuffs. No doubt they'll bruise. I examine my ankles - more welts. Holy hell, I look like I've been in some sort of accident. I gaze at myself, trying to absorb how I look.So, she's taken aback by how fucking beat up she is after sex with Chedward, when in the last chapter he was like, "I don't want to hurt you, you're my wife, not my sub, I'm not going to cause you pain, it's just going to be intense." Now she's covered with hickeys (and you know what? Hickey is just another word for bruise. They're the same thing, just one is caused by canoodling and the other by violent trauma. Both are sore.) and her arms and legs are all marked up from being handcuffed. So, of course this is the moment when Ana realizes that she's made a huge mistake, that Christian will never change, and that she needs to get out before this possessive assholery escalates.
Nope, she talks about how skinny she is, instead:
My body is so different these days. It's changed subtly since I've known him... I've become leaner and fitter, and my hair is glossy and well cut. My nails are manicured, my feet pedicured, my eyebrows threaded and beautifully shaped. For the first time in my life, I'm well groomed - except for these hideous love bites."Love" bites, whatever. The important thing is for the reader to know that, abusive tendencies aside, fucking Christian Grey is like having an in-home stylist and a Bowflex. By the way, those last two excerpts? They're in the same paragraph. It's not like I cut out some part in the middle where she comes to grips with how awful it is that he did this to her. It's literally, "I have bruises everywhere from sex, wow, look how great I look." That's Ana's cognitive follow-through: "I'm skinny and hot, so that makes everything okay."
No, that stunning leap of reasoning happens in the next paragraph:
I don't want to think about grooming at the moment.(But you did.)
I'm too mad. How dare he mark me like this, like some teenager. In the short time we've been together, he's never given me hickeys. I look like hell. I know why he's done this. Damn control freak. Right! My subconscious folds her arms beneath her small bosom - he's gone too far this time.EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS IS DISAPPOINTING AND WRONG. Ana's reaction hits all the crucial points on a 50 Shades bingo card. She's talking about the short time they've been together while on their honeymoon. She's just gone on at length about how hot she is, then claims to look like hell. Her subconscious objects, but ultimately it won't count because she has small titties.
Ana sits down to brush her hair, because when you're angry, ladies, nothing calms you down like a good hair brushing, am I right? Christian calls to her to see if she's okay. She's not okay:
I ignore him. Am I okay? No, I am not okay. After what he's done to me, I doubt I'll be able to wear a swimsuit, let alone one of my ridiculously expensive bikinis for the rest of our honeymoon.I guess she "got used to it" then, huh?
I seethe as fury spikes through me. I can behave like an adolescent, too!Yeah, that will definitely help things, you should go do that.
Ana goes into the bedroom and throws a hairbrush at Christian, then runs up on deck.
I need some space to calm down. It's dark and the air is balmy. The warm breeze carries the smell of the Mediterranean and the scent of jasmine and bougainvillea from the shore. The Fair Lady glides effortlessly through the calm cobalt sea as I rest my elbows on the wooden railing, gazing at the distant shore where tiny lights wink and twinkle.
Juuuuuuuust sayin'.
"Christian, you have to stop unilaterally trying to bring me to heel. You made your point on the beach. Very effectively as I recall."
He shrugs minutely. "Well, you won't take your top off again," he murmurs petulantly.
"Look at me!" I pull down my camisole to reveal the top of my breasts. Christian gazes at me, his eyes not leaving my face, his expression wary and uncertain. He's not used to seeing me this mad. Can't he see what he's done? Can't he see how ridiculous he is? I want to shout at him, but I refrain - I don't want to push him too far. Heaven knows what he'd do.A lot of people have left comments on my recap posts saying, "How can people not see that this is abuse?" Well, frankly, it's because they're willfully stupid. I'm not saying that every person who reads this book or likes it is stupid. I'm saying that the people out there who are defending this book and saying it doesn't depict an abusive relationship are fucking stupid. There's no other way to describe them. It's like if you showed someone a picture of a duck, but they insisted it was a chicken, even after you explained all the ways that it's, for real now, a fucking duck. The women who read this book and think Christian's behavior makes him desirable? They want to be stupid. Yes, our society tells us that everything a rich man does is right, but at this point in our cultural evolution there are enough resources out there to educate people that the only reason anyone would want to defend this piece of shit book and its piece of shit hero against allegations of abuse is that it's just more comfortable to be fucking ignorant. That excerpt above? That's the picture of the duck that millions of really fucking stupid women insist is a chicken, because it's more fun. No fucking wonder abused women and rape victims get blamed for the crimes perpetrated against them. It's more fun if a privileged group (and yes, I'm blatantly stating that women who have not faced the realities of abuse and rape are a privileged group, if that's a problem, oh fucking well) can cordone off a DMZ around their shallow, vapid little word view and shoot down any possible challenge to their outdated perceptions of the world before anything can get close enough to make them think for themselves for two seconds.
I realize that I'm coming off hostile here, but really, is there any other way to be at this point? When this piece of shit is the best selling ROMANCE of all time? When this relationship is the relationship that publishers are trying to sell to women as being the be all and end all, and we should all be sad about our marriages and how our husbands treat us with respect instead of as property? That's it. After this chapter, I'm not pulling punches.
If you want to be in a relationship with Christian Grey, you're fucking stupid.
Moving on.
Christian tells Ana that he gets it, and says he has a lot to learn. Dude, you're almost thirty, if you haven't learned that disfiguring another person isn't okay, you're probably not smart enough to figure it out.
Dr. Flynn's words come back to me... Emotionally, Christian is an adolescent, Ana. He bypassed that phase in his life totally. He's channeled all his energies into succeeding in the business world, and he has beyond all expectations. His emotional world has to play catch up.Bullshit. Even adolescents are capable of understanding that hitting women, disfiguring them as punishment, etc. is wrong. And if he's so amazing and adaptable that he's been able to overcome this difficulty in order to become a success at business, why hasn't he also been able to overcome it in personal relationships? The fact that he's intelligent enough to recognize that he has to behave a certain way to be successful at business shows that he's able to do the work. He's just not willing to, because it doesn't interest him the way business does.
But Ana's a fucking idiot, so she thinks this explains everything, and in response to Christian's assertion that he has a lot to learn, this happens:
My heart thaws a little.
"We both do." I sigh and cautiously raise my hand, placing it over his heart.What do you think you need to learn, Ana? Besides "how to not get beat up by your abusive asshole husband?"
"I've just learned that you've a good arm and a good aim, Mrs. Grey. I would never have figured that, but then I constantly underestimate you. You always surprise me."So, Christian compliments her, and the fight is over. She immediately responds with something about Ray teaching her how to shoot, and they tease each a little bit, then she falls into his arms and:
"Am I forgiven?"
"Am I?"
I feel his smile. "Yes," he answers.
"Ditto."
We stand holding each other, my pique forgotten. He does smell good, adolescent or not. How can I resist him?I would say that I hope you both get cancer, but that would be grossly unfair to cancer. Cancer shouldn't have to put up with your bullshit. In this case, I'm Team Cancer.
Christian asks Ana if she's hungry
"Yes. Famished. All the... er... activity has given me an appetite. But I'm not dressed for dinner." I'm sure my sweatpants and camisole would be frowned upon in the dining room.WTF is this shit, Downton Boatsby?
Except I can't decide who I hate more, Ana or When Irish Eyes Are Whining.
After a section break, they're already on dessert, and thank God we don't have to actually sit through them having dinner because I don't know if I could handle "willful anorexia as an act of defiance against my abusive husband" fun times after all that other bullshit. Ana asks Christian why he braids her hair when they're going to have sex, and he says it's because he doesn't want her hair to catch on anything. Then he has a dramatically visible painful memory, but Ana urges him to ignore his emotional pain and move on to what's the most important - which is obviously her - and she asks him if he loves her despite her "disobedience." Remember, "disobedience" in this case is sunbathing topless on a beach where everyone else is sunbathing topless. Christian tells her he loves her because of her disobedience... so... does he want her to run around topless or what? Don't worry, Ana can't figure it out, either:
I crack my spoon through the burned sugar crust of my dessert and shake my head. Will I ever understand this man? Hmm - this creme brulee is delicious.Lack of accent marks on the creme brulee are my fault. I love how this line seems to indicate that Ana is moving from Anorexia Nervosa straight on to Bulimia town. She's actually eating, and she's turning her lack of control over her love life into an intense concentration on food. That's going to be healthy in the long run.
There's another section break, which is a damn shame, because I would rather hear about Ana eating creme brulee than Ana interacting with Chedward, but oh well. She asks him why she wasn't allowed to pee earlier, and he tells her exactly what all you guys said in the comments, that it makes the orgasm more intense. You know, so does edging, and there's less chance you're going to get peed on by mistake.
Pictured: A dramatic reenactment of what happens when you do the pee thing after two pregnancies.
A slinky, cheesy melody starts. Is this a Latin rhythm?Latin music = cheesy?
"You dance so well," I say. "It's like I can dance."
He gives me a sphinxlike smile but says nothing, and I wonder if it's because he's thinking of her... Mrs. Robinson, the woman who taught him how to dance - and how to fuck. She hasn't crossed my mind for a while.Yeah, for like, 46 whole pages so far. That's a personal best.
Christian has not mentioned her since his birthday, and as far as I'm aware, their business relationship is over. Reluctantly, though, I have to admit - she was some teacher.I think we previous established that this is a woman who took sexual advantage of a teenager who was clearly emotionally troubled. But yeah, thank god she taught your husband to fuck, because it probably didn't screw him up to be preyed upon by a sexual predator.
"Come to bed with me?" he whispers, and it's a heartfelt plea that tugs at my heart.Good job, copy editor, you're definitely earning your keep.
Ana wakes up the next morning:
I marvel at what it is like to go to bed with two different men - angry Christian and sweet let-me-make-it-up-to-you-in-any-way-I-can Christian.That's not going to bed with two different men. That's going to bed with one man and his personality disorder.
Ana finds Christian shaving:
I love watching him shave. He pulls up his chin and shaves beneath it, taking long, deliberate strokes, and I find myself unconsciously mirroring his actions. Pulling my upper lip down just as he does, to shave his philtrum. He turns and smirks at me, one half of his face still covered in shaving soap."
"Enjoying the show?" he asks.
I would like it better if it were this show.
Christian asks Ana if he should shave her "again," which means it's flashback time. Apparently, at the beginning of their honeymoon, Ana tried to shave her beaver and of course it becomes this whole big controversy about whether he likes it or not, etc. Of course he likes it, it was in his rules at the beginning of the first book, but anyway, she missed a spot, so he decides he's going to shave her:
"Christian! You are not shaving me!"
He tilts his head to one side. "Why ever not?"
I flush... isn't it obvious? "Because... It's just too..."
"Intimate?" he whispers. "Ana, I crave intimacy with you - you know that. Besides, after some of the things we've done, don't get all squeamish on me now. And I know this part of your body better than you do."
I gape at him. Of all the arrogant... true, he does - but still. "It's just wrong!" My voice is prissy and whiny.Thank god, I thought I had been imagining her voice all wrong during the last two books. Fuck this guy, seriously? He knows her body better than she does? Fuck her, too, then. It's her body. She's in it all day, she knows it best, no matter how many women Christian Grey has beaten before.
And try to imagine an American man saying, "Why ever not?" Did you do it? Did he sound old? Because I can't imagine an American man under seventy saying, "Why ever not?" It's just not how like, 99% of young American men talk. They'd be like, "Why not?" or "Huh?"
Christian tells Ana that shaving a woman turns him on, so of course, she decides she's got to do it. Because it doesn't matter what turns her on, or what she's comfortable with. The end goal is to please Christian Grey, He Who Must Be Pleased Above All Other Things. Ana makes a crack about how "kinky" it is, probably because she's never, ever looked at the internet even once in her whole life.
So, then Christian shaves her and is just starting to finger her when we hit the paragraph break. Back in the bathroom, Chedward is still shaving his face, and Ana is embarrassed about him shaving her that one time we just heard about, and THESE ARE THE PROBLEMS THESE PEOPLE HAVE.
Get your mind around that. In a world of crashing economies, record joblessness, women dying from gang rapes and denied abortions, children being murdered by drone strikes, the problems these idiots face? "Is letting my husband shave my beev too kinky?"
"Hey, I'm just teasing. Isn't that what husbands who are hopelessly in love with their wives do?"OTHER THINGS HUSBANDS WHO ARE HOPELESSLY IN LOVE WITH THEIR WIVES DO:
- Not disfigure her in a jealous rage.
- Not publicly shame their wives for sunbathing topless.
- Allows her to shop wherever she wants and buy what she wants to wear.
- Gets along with her friends.
- Refrains from incessantly calling his mother a crack whore after constantly telling his wife how much she looks like her.
- Does not buy her job.
- Does not seek to isolate her from her family.
- Does not follow her across the country when she needs space.
These are just a few, but it's a good jumping off point for you, Chedward.
Ana decides that since he shaved her bush, she should finish shaving his face:
Holy shit, he's going to let me shave him. Tentatively I slide my hand into the damp hair at his forehead, gripping tightly to hold him still. He clenches his eyes closed and parts his lips as he inhales. Very gently, I stroke his razor up from his neck to his chin, revealing a path of skin beneath the lather. Christian exhales.
I couldn't find a picture of a more abusive fuck getting shaved by his wife, so I'll settle for this one of Mister, who is about the same level on the asshole scale as Christian Grey.
Christian wants to take Ana ashore and buy some art, since they can't go to the beach because he's insane with jealousy:
"I know nothing about art, Christian."Except for the part where she totally did, in the last two books. In fact, the first time she meets Christian, in the very first book, they talk about the art hanging in his office. She told us all about the styles of paintings in Christian's apartment. One of her very best friends is an artist, and she and Christian went to his gallery opening together, where Ana told us all about the composition of the various photographs. A part of me thinks this is just inconsistency on the author's part, another, meaner part of me thinks it's intentional, to show that Ana doesn't need to actually know anything as long as she has a man to form her opinions for her.
Christian tells her he wants to buy art for their new house, the plans for which they just saw a few days ago. You know, the plans for the house Ana asked him not to build, in favor of keeping the house they bought?
Oh, the architect. He had to remind me of her... Gia Matteo, a friend of Elliot's who worked on Christian's place in Aspen. During our meetings, she'd been all over Christian like a rash.We've officially reached the inner circle of hell, folks. Ana doesn't even need other women around to hate them anymore, she can do it via satellite.
How can I tell him that I don't like Gia? My dislike is irrational. I don't want to come across as a jealous wife.But you are a jealous wife. And you were a jealous girlfriend. In fact, the only difference between you and Christian in terms of possessiveness is the fact that he's aggressive about his jealousy and you're passive about it. And no, it's not irrational to dislike a woman who is really trying to break up your marriage, but since Ana isn't the most reliable narrator when it comes to this kind of stuff (after all, she thinks her relationship with Christian is romantic and that he is desirable), I have to wonder if all these women really are into him, or she's just imagining they are because she's a freaking lunatic.
"You're not still mad about what I did yesterday?" He sighs and nuzzles his face between my breasts.No, you fool, how could she be? You graced her with the touch of your magnificent penis, it's impossible that she might still be angry over you maliciously marking her body as a sign of ownership.
Christian takes Ana to Saint-Paul-De-Vence, a Medieval French city:
We pass a tree-covered square where three old men, one wearing a traditional beret in spite of the heat, are playing boules. It's quite crowded with tourists, but I feel comfortable tucked under Christian's arm.God, I fucking hate it when I'm trying to be a tourist and there are too many tourists around. I'm just trying to watch these old men be stereotypically French for my amusement.
In the first gallery, Christian gazes distractedly at the erotic photographs in front of us, sucking gently on the arm of his aviator specs. They are the work of Florence D'elle - naked women in various poses.Those sound like some amazing sunglasses.
"Not quite what I had in mind," I mumble disapprovingly."Good heavens, this art is full of naked people!" I absolutely love that Ana is jealous of naked women in photographs now. Is this like the Weeping Angels? A photographic representation of a naked woman actually becomes a naked woman, and if you blink she tackle-fucks your husband? This marriage has a rock solid foundation, y'all.
"Me neither," Christian says, grinning down at me. He takes my hand, and we stroll to the next artist. Idly, I wonder if I should let him take photos of me.Who, the next artist? Have we totally given up on subject/verb agreement here? Is it too hard? Also, LOL at the idea that if Christian wants nude artwork, she has to be the nude. Maybe Jose can photograph that. Of course, this is all because she feels the need to play keep up with the other subs that he photographed.
They find some paintings they like, and they discuss how much they cost and how Ana needs to get use to spending tons of money on stuff, because lord knows it's practically sinful to have money and not throw it around. The best possible thing rich people can do with their money is, you know, let it trickle down.
After lunch, Ana and Christian are having coffee and talking again about why he braids her hair. You guess right if you speculated that it would have to do with his mother:
"The crack whore used to let me play with her hair, I think. I don't know if it's a memory or a dream."
Whoa! His birth mom.
He gazes at me, his expression unreadable. My heart leaps into my mouth. What do I say when he says things like this?I would go with, "Stop calling your mother a whore."
Ana tells him she thinks he loved his mother, and he goes all mute and catatonic for a minute, then decides it's time to go:
I exhale, relieved, and shrug. "I am just glad you're still speaking to me."
"You know I don't like talking about all that shit. It's done. Finished," he says quietly.Um, you're the one who brought it up this time, Chedward, so suck it.
No, Christian, it isn't. The thought saddens me, and for the first time I wonder if it will ever be finished. He'll always be Fifty Shades... my Fifty Shades. Do I want him to change? No, not really - only insofar as I want him to feel loved. Peeking up at him, I take a moment to admire his captivating beauty... and he's mine.I would say, "maybe you should have thought of all of this before you got married," but it's clear that marriage, and ownership of Christian, was her end goal, no matter how fucked up he is. You know, because he's pretty.
He gives me that look, down his nose, half amused, half wary, wholly sexy, then tucks me under his arm, and we make our way through the tourists toward the spot where Philippe/Gaston has parked the roomy Mercedes.There's really no better vehicle for a Medieval walled city with roads designed for horse and foot traffic than a car as wide as a Mercedes. Good thinking, Chedward.
In the car, Christian looks at the bruises on Ana's wrists, and she reassures him that she's fine, he didn't really hurt her, then immediately tells us about the expensive watch he bought her in London, and how romantic that is. Priorities, ladies. A man can do whatever he wants to you, so long as he buys you expensive jewelry. It's not prostitution, it's just the way things should be.
After a paragraph break, Chedward buys Ana more jewelry, a platinum bracelet that costs 30,000 euros. Remember those starving children he's so worried about?
"There, that's better," he murmurs.
"Better," I whisper, gazing into his luminous gray eyes, conscious that the stick-thin sales assistant is staring at us with a jealous and disapproving look.Ana is going to make fun of someone for being too skinny?
I'm tired as fuck of "skinny" or "thin" being used as characterization shorthand for "evil bitch." Especially when so much of the last two books concentrated on how Ana can't/doesn't eat and how she's so thin every man wants to fuck her while simultaneously feeding her cookies for her own good. Plus, Ana, you moron, that sales assistant just sold a 30k bracelet. I'm sure she's not disapproving. She's probably not even paying attention to you. It might just be that she gets a disapproving look on her face when she's doing the mental math to calculate her commission.
Christian has bought the bracelet, by the way, because he wants to cover up the bruise on her other wrist. I suppose when he gives her a black eye, he'll buy her an eyepatch covered in Swarovski crystals, and all will be forgiven.
But when he says he needs to buy the bracelet, she says:
"No, Christian, you don't. You've given me so much already. A magical honeymoon, London, Paris, the Cote D'Azur... and you. I'm a very lucky girl,"Yeah, you've given her so much. Like hickeys all over her body out of anger, and bruises she didn't ask for on her ankles and wrists because you're not a very good Dom. You've given her a beating with a belt, a good thorough stalking, all your emotional baggage, and a free ride to your hotel room when she was passed out drunk and couldn't say no. You've given her so much. What you haven't given her is like, respect, personal agency, a healthy relationship, aftercare, the freedom to do simple stuff like have her own bank account and job, etc. Just little shit no one really cares about anyway.
I'm so glad someone is out there, training women to value the things that are really important. Like money, and letting rich men do whatever they want to women without any consequences.
Back in the car, Christian looks at Ana's ankles, and the bruises he left there.
"Doesn't hurt," I murmur. He glances at me and his expression is sad, his mouth a thin line.He's probably thinking that he has to spend another 60,000 euros to cover those bruises, and wondering if it wouldn't just be cheaper to dump your body overboard once you're back on the boat. But good on you for trying to make your abuser feel bad for abusing you.
"I didn't expect to feel like I do looking at these marks," he says.
Oh! Reticent once minute and forthcoming the next? How... Fifty! How can I keep up with him?
"How do you feel?"
Bleak eyes gaze at me. "Uncomfortable," he murmurs.
Oh no.Yeah, what a fucking shame that he feels bad for, at best, being an irresponsible Dom, at worst, being an abusive fuckwad who should have his balls smashed in a vise.
Ana tells him that aside from the hickeys, she liked everything else. Except, when she was first examining the marks on her body, she didn't like the bruises left by the handcuffs. But I guess if it makes Chedward feel bad, she should just get over it and let him use cuffs that hurt her even if she doesn't like it, because pleasing him is really the end goal.
Ana tells him the sex was mind-blowing:
He shifts in his seat. "Mind-blowing?" My inner goddess looks up, startled, from her Jackie Collins.Get it? Women who don't like sex are all nerdy prudes with small tits who read Dickens and lead bleak, horrible existences, and women who do like sex only read Jackie Collins, because it's impossible to be smart enough to read literary fiction when you like sex. The best part of this is that a) Jackie Collins writes a much better book than E.L. James does, and b) E.L. just subtly insulted her readers by being dismissive of genre fiction. Which wouldn't be the first time, since she blatantly used the Twihards to get famous and now shits on them every chance she gets.
E.L. James is a bad person, is what I'm saying here.
Christian gets a phone call, which sounds not great:
"Anyone injured? Damage? I see... When?" Christian glances at his watch again, then runs his fingers through his hair. "No. Not the fire department or the police. Not yet anyway."So, there was a fire at Christian's office. As established in the last two books, Christian won't call the police for any reason. Not even if his ex-girlfriend breaks into Ana's apartment and holds her hostage at gunpoint. Now, there's a fire in the server room at his office, and he doesn't want to involve the fire department or the police? Exactly what is this guy doing, that he's so afraid of the police coming anywhere near him?
Christian tells Ana that they're not sure if it's arson yet, but they decide to head back to the boat, and Ana wonders what more could possibly happen. The awesome part of that is, I really don't give a fuck what happens to them, as long as it's something tragic and violent, and then the chapter is over.
This is the worst fucking chapter in the world. I was so consumed in anger I had to step away from continuing with the bad food analysis at this point. Could not see straight.
ReplyDeleteSpoiler alert: her sudden interest in food isn't tied to her having a healthy perspective on life, she's pregnant so duh of course she likes to eat!, people make fun of her for being moody and then Christian makes jokes about her being fat before they find out about the pregnancy.
Does he not then beat the crap out of her because the birth control HE chose and forced on her failed?
DeleteYeah. They get into a practical fist fight because she "forgot" to keep up with her birth control because she is a child.
DeleteIt's all Chedward's fault. He forgot to order her back to the dr.
DeleteOh lord. So the instance of Ana actually getting angry about legitimately angrifying behavior and standing up for herself (even if ineffectively and just for a second) will be dismissed as "moody because pregnant"? Aw hell.
DeleteYikes, I was halfway through Book 3 for writing down all the negative food references (book 1 here: http://iam.yellingontheinternet.com/2012/12/31/problems-with-food-in-50-shades-book-1/), and somewhere along the way where he forced her to use his last name, I had to take a break. (The fat comment was before she knew she was pregnant, it was all LOL you can't walk, let's talk the elevator, gee you are moody too.) Glad I have that to look forward to.
DeleteIf he gets her an eye patch, oh I hope against hope he gets Ana a parrot for her shoulder.
ReplyDeleteShe already has the pirate lingo down from back in chapter 8 of the first book.
DeleteIt would be hilarious how well James constructed this narrative of abuse and spousal violence if it wasn't packaged as the Bestest Romance of All Time. She took the stalkerish tendencies of Twilight et al and blew them out of proportion with this weird pseudo-D/s thing that's built solely around Chedward being rich and handsome. Seriously, there are no other traits that come to mind when I think of the character because Ana doesn't care about anything else. He's rich and he's good looking, so whatever he does is totally fine.
ReplyDeleteEven his deep dark past is just another ticked box on the roster of the Perfect Male Hero. Doesn't serve any other purpose except to excuse his completely inexcusable behavior and throw the burden of responsibility for making the relationship work onto Ana. Abusive Chedward is perfect just the way he is.
(Re: this would be a great book about abuse and spousal violence if it weren't for the fact that we're supposed to find this romantic)
DeleteI know, right? I mean, how can a sentence like this:
"I marvel at what it is like to go to bed with two different men - angry Christian and sweet let-me-make-it-up-to-you-in-any-way-I-can Christian"
...be read any other way than a textbook example of an abuser? "He hurts me and then he is super-sweet/buys me things in order to make up for it, rinse, repeat" is a downright chillingly accurate description of typical abuser behavior. How does EL James write this and not realize what she is writing? How can readers read this and not realize what they are looking at?
I can't believe this book. I can't believe any of them, but this one so far is the worst. You know, this series wouldn't be half as horrible if there were some character DEVELOPMENT! Characters are supposed to evolve and generally become better people, but these two are exactly the same horrible people they were from the first book.
ReplyDeleteOr plot development! I mean there is no plot thread running through the series... it's just random events all pieced together.
DeleteOh, and I was so hoping that the shaving scene would turn in the direction of Sweeney Todd.
ReplyDelete"God, I fucking hate it when I'm trying to be a tourist and there are too many tourists around. I'm just trying to watch these old men be stereotypically French for my amusement."
ReplyDeleteI feel like every post you write is my favorite, but I think this one really wins.
He could buy her Stuart Weitzman shoes to cover those ankle bruises.
ReplyDeleteHe could just get her a bruka and have done with it. The no one can look upon what is hiis. Wait. Is Christian really Taliban? These books could mean something else entirely if he is.
DeleteTrue! He acts like one!
DeleteWait, wait, wait. There was a fire at an office building, and the person who saw it called their vacationing boss BEFORE calling the fire department? Who the hell DOES that?
ReplyDelete"After this chapter, I'm not pulling punches."
You were pulling punches before? What have we unleashed?!
I want to know how he gets insurance to cover damges if he doesn't file a police report.
DeleteI want to know how he gets his insurance to cover damages without filing a police report.
Delete"That's not going to bed with two different men. That's going to bed with one man and his personality disorder." This. LOL
ReplyDeleteAlso, when she gives out to him for leaving the hickeys all over her and he just shrugs and says "well you won't take your top off now" I wanted to reach into the book and slap Christian in the face for being so obnoxious. OMG
Word, though I think I wanted to punch him repeatedly for that rather than just one slap.
DeleteThis chapter is infuriating. This whole thing is like a train wreck that I just can't look away from and I keep thinking "It can't possibly get worse." and it always does, it somehow always gets worse.
I couldn't finish it after that because my abuse experience dealt with exactly that. He left hickeys to mark what he had done. It hurts me to see people find this romantic.
DeleteThese chapters are fucking long... good on you for forcing your way through their bullshit to bring us the salient and hilarious points. I really dig the old French guy wearing the "traditional beret", although I would have liked to hear about a non-traditional one as well.
ReplyDeleteI bet that sales associate is blond.
Swarovski? No, that eye patch will be diamond-studded.
ReplyDelete(I was also thinking Sweeney Todd during the shaving scene)
My first thought actually was The Color Purple. I half expected Kate to burst in to tell Ana the blade wasn't sharp enough.
DeleteMuch bigger fish to fry in this chapter, but I note that "specs", used at least twice, is not remotely a piece of American slang.
ReplyDeleteI'm left wondering once again how E.L. lives with herself. Not even as an author who wrote something terrible, because we all do that at some point. But for the terrible advice these books give young people. Makes me sick to think of anyone reading these and enjoying how "romantic" Christian is, but especially so for young, impressionable kids. Not even just girls, because if a boy finds out that girls like this shit and starts doing it to see what happens, that's awful too.
ReplyDeleteWhy didn't she think of that?
I am a writer querying a manuscript right now. The terrible messages sent in 50 Shades and Twilight were the catalyst that sent me nose-diving into finally writing. My hope is that, if I can get it published, that it might undo some of the damage caused by the popularity of these books and the pressure on women and teens (50 Shades has a high teenage readership) to like them, or at least fake it. So far one of my beta readers took my manuscript to heart and acknowledged her relationship was abusive. She got out and is now in therapy and is much happier.
DeleteMy heart literally aches knowing that so many women and teens have come to idealize the Chedward characters because it's fashionable, and I get nauseated every time I hear someone say more men need to be like them. No. We've already got a population where a quarter of women are victims of sexual assault and a third victims of domestic abuse. We don't need to encourage more men perpetrating these horrible crimes. (Some women have gone as far as divorcing good men for not being more like Christian.) Our sons and young men don't need to be told that the way to get a woman is to hurt her! Yet this is what they're hearing.
My main bad buy acts like Christian in a lot of ways, though with one change that, according to my betas, makes him more vile than Christian. He doesn't have sex with my female lead, and manages to be worse. Tricky accomplishment. He is not seen as desirable. My male lead is the polar opposite. He's not perfect by any means, but makes a genuine effort to correct his faults. My female lead actually develops as a person and ends up opening a can of whoop-ass. None of my betas saw the ending coming, but cheered for it when it happened.
An abuser as the bad guy? A caring, loving man as the good guy? A woman who ultimately saves herself, saves the good guy, gets even with the bad guy, and goes on to have her very own career without influence even from the good guy? Sadly there seems to be no demand in the book-buying world for such nonsense. A fan fic of 50 Shades is being released in March. That crap gets an agent. My manuscript hasn't.
I just don't understand. I've tried, but can't. Why is abuse now seen as romantic? The "he loves her so much he can't control himself" doesn't hold up.
Your story sounds so interesting and intriguing, I'm sure I'd be one of the first to read it if/when it gets published... and then show it to any girl who (heaven forbid) worships 50 Shades.
DeleteAnonymous, I have a very basic website up right now (still on free hosting until I figure out if I'll keep with that particular company before shelling out a couple hundred a year). alysbcohen.wix.com/alysbcohen When I've decided, the doman will be alysbcohen.com and will point to wherever I have my site. Right now the working title is Sacred Blood, and yes, it's got supernatural elements. Not only is the way to edge in the market to use a few of the same plot devices that have proven successful, but the revenge Juliette gets can not work if everyone is human. The criminal element is removed when talking about non-human beings the world isn't supposed to know exist.
DeleteI could always use a few more beta readers to double-check for plot holes or things that need more clarification, and because her situation is a delicate one at first, it could help to have more people read at least those passages to make sure that, from the perspective of someone who's been there, that they're not overly triggering nor too mellow, and from the perspective of someone fortunate enough to not have been, that they understand and can feel her fear. My intention isn't to traumatize, but to enable readers to feel her situation and then her elation at getting out. She will also continue to deal with what happened afterward. Too often books with this topic end with the character never having issues once they leave.
Also the cast is diverse. Interracial marriage, variety of sexualities (chastity, promiscuity, homosexuality), differing religious viewpoints...and none of this is considered bad. It's real life. What the bad guy does is awful, of course. No consent. I'm wondering who will say Juliette consented to being beaten because she stayed with the bad guy when offered another place to stay. Those who don't understand are really lucky not to understand emotional and mental abuse that goes along with physical and sexual abuse.
There's a contact page on that site, or you can shoot me an e-mail at alysbcohen@gmail.com
(Not to the fish lady: I hope this isn't coming across as being off-topic and trying to hijack your page. I just think we can all agree that the sheer bullshit in books like 50 Shades and the abuse portrayed as romance needs to end, and that our impressionable members of society need something else to see as ideal, and the less-impressionable need different material over which to fantasize. Twilight and 50 Shades are the catalyst that resulted in me finally writing again. The message in my manuscript, actually the first in a planned trilogy in which the second is in first-draft mode, is an important one.)
Not at all, I mean, it's on topic. It's not like you're going, "CHECK OUT MY BOOK ON WHY HORSES ARE AWESOME." Which, BTW, would still be okay, because it's a hell of a sales pitch.
DeleteSad but true. When I was more actively in the fan fiction community and wrote more, I noticed that the ones that had a non-nonsensical and lots of bad grammar were the ones that got a lot of hits and/or praise, whereas the ones that were better written hardly got any attention. So, long story short, sadly the people want to read crap, even though there are a million much better stories/writers out there.
DeleteI have a horrid picture in my head of a thin shaved woman, her torso covered in bruises. This is not ok.
ReplyDeleteI've got a friend right now commenting on my Facebook status about this insisting that it was all consensual. Problem is Ana was stuck on a boat, liquored up knowing that he was going to hurt her, and went along with what she thought would cause her the least pain. His intention wasn't in being passionate, but rather marking her and making sure she had to wear more than what she had been, even though he bought everything she owned. Preaching to the choir, I know.
DeleteConsensual or not, marking or striking in anger or to prove a point is a sign of a poor Dom and that's all there is to it. Fuck this series and Jen you are one tough girl to keep on reading this crap and giving us recaps which, I have to admit, are beginning to be painful to read NOT because of your style which is delectable, but for the subject you are criticizing.
DeleteNow to wait for January 13 So I can read the Boss which will be good I have no doubt.
There are so many rage inducing scenes in this chapter, but this one (although minor in comparison to the abuse) really annoyed me:
ReplyDelete""I know nothing about art, Christian." Except for the part where she totally did, in the last two books. In fact, the first time she meets Christian, in the very first book, they talk about the art hanging in his office."
I think it's because that first conversation about art is supposedly what made Christian think she was "so bright". Why did it have to be art? Why couldn't they be furniture shopping for the new house so Ana could claim to not know anything about sofas instead of art which she was previously SO SMART about?
When she says she was tucked under his arm (twice) was anyone else picturing the jock in Sixteen Candles carrying the girl out of the locker room under his arm when Sam goes to talk to Jake and wusses out? I can even hear the music in my head.
ReplyDeleteYES!! Well, not really, because I've never seen sixteen candles (I know, it's on my list) but I found the clip on YouTube and that is EXACTLY what I was picturing and it was driving me up a tree.
DeleteI must say...this was one of your best recaps yet! When I notice you've posted a new recap, my day/week gets a whole lot better! Sometimes it's the only thing that puts a smile on my face, so thank you for enduring these books!
ReplyDeletehappen me the same this just made my week and weekend!
DeleteI friggin' love your recaps, they make my day.
ReplyDeleteHave you seen this video btw? A girl quickly summarising the first book and it's hilarious! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoHk1JpsPP4
Man, I get "The Boss" before heading in to the doctor's office, and come home from class to find this!
ReplyDeleteNeedless to say, holy fucking shit. I think this book has gone so far deep into "What Not To Do" territory that it's looped back around.
(Question - are we allowed to talk about Chapter 1, like review it, or should we wait until it's properly published first?)
Absolutely, tell everyone in the world. I mean, don't like, give them the whole thing, but you're totally allowed to talk about it because word of mouth is how we're gonna rock this thing.
DeleteNah, I didn't give 'em the whole thing. I mean, I talked it up and down and highlighted a couple of my favorite parts (without quoting), but they'll still be waiting five days like everyone else for the real deal.
DeleteI can at least promise that I am verbose and persistent.
Excellent recap, by the way. I'm amazed you can still find words. Because there are none. *He bought her diamond watches to hide the bruises he put on her wrists.* *She can't stand to even have naked pictures of another woman in the house.* What the almighty fuck?
I have to say I've never actually felt pain from a hickey.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I laughed quite hard (well, suppressed it because I'm at work) at this recap. Well done!
I love your voice. These recap posts have been so good, but this is by far the best written, possibly because it's the most horrifying subject matter.
ReplyDeleteYour recaps are always amazing. I loved your comment about naked artwork being like the Weeping Angels!
ReplyDeleteAlthough, I will say that it is possible to have dozens of tiny (but visible) hickey-bruises without having any idea. I bruise really easily and that happened a couple times before I had to put a no-nibbling clause into my sex life.
Of course, feeling/not feeling the hickeys aside, when it happened to me, the guys were usually as stunned as I was at the connect-the-dots hickeys I had: Christian did this deliberately, as PUNISHMENT no less, which is so far beyond horrible.
DeleteWow. There are no words for how much I hate this book and also this author. I messaged her on Twitter to ask if she'd be willing to discuss the fact that Christian can be described as abusive and that the books have triggered abuse survivors, such as myself, by romanticising it. Her response was to block me. She did the same to a small, UK-based domestic abuse awareness group when they asked - politely - for a comment. I really, really want people to call her out for her decision to write the story of an abusive man trying to gain total control and ownership of an inexperienced woman (she's a stupid bitch, but still...), long before the inevitable film comes out. It really is disgusting that this is being labelled as "romance." It's at best irresponsible, at worst potentially dangerous and deeply offensive to women who've escaped that sort of relationship.
ReplyDeleteWhat do you expect from someone who literally talks shit about her fans and gets pissed off when "her" characters are stolen, sorry, I mean, used, for fan fiction other write?
DeleteFrankly, she sounds like a greedy, first class witch to me! I for one read all sorts of fiction books except mysteries and sci-fi.
DeleteJackie Collins DOES write better books! I've read 10 or 6 at various points in my reading life.
Sorry E.L. your book is promoting abusive relationships and you should be BIG enough to TAKE this VALID form of criticism.
Yes Jackie Collins is far from classic literature, but then E.L., neither are your books!
P.S. Can anyone who HAS read Jackie Collins imagine ANY of her female heroines putting up with the BS Christian puts ANA through?
DeleteEspecially Lucky Santangelo?
Lucky would have had his balls in a vice two books ago, then found a way to take over his company.
Deletei can imagine them smacking erica upside the head with her own books, especially with the "special editions" about to be released.
DeleteBrilliant! Then Lucky would cook his cajones with fine fava beans and FORCE him to eat them! AT KNIFEPOINT!
DeleteTo be perfectly honest, though Ana is incredibly annoying as a character, very stupid, flat, and self-centered, it's not fair to put it on her. Christian is an abuser. Many very intelligent women have been in abusive relationships. The next person to tell me that I'm so smart, why did I stay in an abusive relationship, will be punched, at least in my head. Many abusers start slow so that the victim doesn't realize it's even happening. In Ana's case, Christian recognized someone who was insecure. She was so nervous she tripped in his office. So he pounced on that, and knew how to do some smooth talking. Rather than back away when he found out she was a virgin who had never even masturbated, Christian pushed forward and didn't give her time or space to think. Almost immediately he created a sense of obligation in her by giving her expensive gifts and crowding her space. She couldn't say no if she wanted to. This sort of thing is even harder for victims if it's their first relationship because there's nothing to compare it to. But even when there is, the mental manipulation that happens can result in even the brightest, strongest women falling victim.
DeleteWhere Ana loses my sympathy though is that she had a way out. Many victims, myself included, have nowhere to go, often no money of our own, nowhere to live, and have been isolated from everyone we know. But Ana had a rich friend whose parents were supporting by paying her living expenses, and that friend happened to be dating Christian's brother. But this doesn't make it her fault.
Victims are already blamed enough when abuse and rape happens. Don't perpetrate the victim-blaming.
P.S. I am dying to read The Boss; I keep hearing amazing things from people lucky enough to have had a sneaky peek! :D
ReplyDelete"The best possible thing rich people can do with their money is, you know, let it trickle down."
ReplyDeleteIn my manuscript (in the querying tenches right now), I've got a rich guy who keeps staff he doesn't need exactly because of this. He states that it does no one any good to keep money in a figurative silo and out of circulation when he's already set.
"...the stick-thin sales assistant is staring at us with a jealous and disapproving look."
Or maybe she's looking disapproving because she doesn't like the bruises that shouldn't be on Ana's wrists. But these days, considering how many women want their husbands to be like Christian going as far as divorcing good men for not turning abusive, maybe someone out there really is jealous of the outward signs of abuse on another woman.
"Which wouldn't be the first time, since she blatantly used the Twihards to get famous and now shits on them every chance she gets."
This is one of the many things that angers me about the author. How dare she insult those who made her famous? I guess her fans are indeed gluttons for some form of abuse. So many of them make excuses for her behavior and then whine about why more men aren't like Christian. A third of women have suffered domestic abuse. A quarter have been sexually assaulted. California just determined that one rape law doesn't cover unmarried women (if someone impersonates your boyfriend in the dark when you're drunk and has sex with you, it's not rape - a conviction was just overturned about that exact situation). We've got enough men acting like Christian and not the legal condonation of at least one kind of RAPE.
I didn't even think of that. she probably looks disapproving because he is blatantly buying her jewelry because he beat her. duh
DeleteAna should go out in a bikini - top optional - hickeys and all.
ReplyDeleteFuckin' A! And with a black sharpie write "My husdand marked his territory". Let the paps get that pic!
DeleteThis is exactly what I was thinking. I would go out topless, hickeys and all, for the rest of the trip because fuck him.
DeleteI hate that now, legitimate masochists who are in relationships with legitimate sadists will be looked at as either victims of abuse or trying to imitate this aberration of a book.
DeleteAlso: Natalie Wood. I shouldn't have laughed... But I kinda did.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteSecond.
DeleteSo as a man who has only read about 60 pages of the first book. the rest coming from things like this. i now see if i want a shit load of women to fancy me. all i need to do is let my arsehole side out. you know that part of me i try to keep inside. away from the rest of the world. the shame here is that alot of the bad things in this book does show up on my darker side. as a man tho i know i must do my best not to act like a monster. even when givin reason to let it out. my hats off to you ladies for shining a light on this subject. ps mrs james blocks everyone lol cause shes a fucking twat. mr gray seems to have some kinda bi-poler thing going on and i would know about that trust me. anyway keep up the good work. remember even cillit would not bang her lol. ps sorry about any spelling mistakes or that not much of a writer.
ReplyDeleteYou sound a like a decent man. I think many people, maybe most, have a side that would sometimes love to lash out. But what separate the decent from the evil are is the willing to contain their desires for the safety of others and because it's just plain wrong to cause pain to someone who hasn't been able to consent (exception, of course, being self defense - no one would say Ana was wrong if she finally started hitting him back so she could escape). The decent will control themselves while the evil will indulge with little or no care as to whose genuinely hurt. Within the BDSM community, willing consent and care (before, during, and after) are vital, and those who don't care are kicked out.
DeleteSo as a man who has only read about 60 pages of the first book. the rest coming from things like this. i now see if i want a shit load of women to fancy me. all i need to do is let my arsehole side out. you know that part of me i try to keep inside. away from the rest of the world. the shame here is that alot of the bad things in this book does show up on my darker side. as a man tho i know i must do my best not to act like a monster. even when givin reason to let it out. my hats off to you ladies for shining a light on this subject. ps mrs james blocks everyone lol cause shes a fucking twat. mr gray seems to have some kinda bi-poler thing going on and i would know about that trust me. anyway keep up the good work. remember even cillit would not bang her lol. ps sorry about any spelling mistakes or that not much of a writer.
ReplyDeleteSo as a man who has only read about 60 pages of the first book. the rest coming from things like this. i now see if i want a shit load of women to fancy me. all i need to do is let my arsehole side out. you know that part of me i try to keep inside. away from the rest of the world. the shame here is that alot of the bad things in this book does show up on my darker side. as a man tho i know i must do my best not to act like a monster. even when givin reason to let it out. my hats off to you ladies for shining a light on this subject. ps mrs james blocks everyone lol cause shes a fucking twat. mr gray seems to have some kinda bi-poler thing going on and i would know about that trust me. anyway keep up the good work. remember even cillit would not bang her lol. ps sorry about any spelling mistakes or that not much of a writer.
ReplyDeleteI can recall times when I woke up surprised to see many strange hickeys and bruises... but that was because alcohol was involved. And I did know they were happening I just didn't take any action to stop them. Anna's just an idiot.
ReplyDeletei woke up to a NOSE HICKEY once because he thought it was hilarious to irritate me while we were making out.
Deleteugh. i bruise fairly easily; luckily i had some concealer for my purple nose. and we broke up a little after. gah, it still makes me mad.
I always think, "It can't get worse. This has to be the worst part" ... E.L. James, you've proven me wrong again. It's one thing to put in a request to your spouse to keep her top on, but manipulate her with anger and then by bruising her all over... what the fucking fuck? How is this romantic at all? I am so tired and jet lagged right now that I can't even so I'm just going to go with your tried and true method... This fucking guy.
ReplyDelete1. I was feeling horrible and depressed due to my jobless state, UNTIL I read this recap. It gave me the chance to be angry about something that isn't my fault, and also to laugh at your commentary. Your rant was epic, true, and hilarious.
ReplyDelete2. When Ana was about to shave Chedward, The Color Purple was the first thing that popped into my mind, then you referenced it!
In Conclusion, thank you for posting. I really needed this.
"Is this like the Weeping Angels? A photographic representation of a naked woman actually becomes a naked woman, and if you blink she tackle-fucks your husband? This marriage has a rock solid foundation, y'all."
ReplyDeleteOh god I laughed so hard I choked.
As for Ana shaving Christian... yeah, good idea, way to risk cutting his face up. Not that I'd feel bad for Christian, but still. My aunt once had to help my cousin shave her legs because she had injured herself, and she ended up cutting my cousin so badly that she never ever used a razor again. Cutting yourself while shaving can always happen, and it's even more likely to happen if you're shaving someone else.
And I am so sick of everything Christian does having something to do with his trauma. If Ana actually "healed" him, nothing would be left. His eyes would probably magically turn brown because there's no need for them to be gray anymore.
I may be a weirdo, but I shave my husband's face/neck all of the time. I do a much better job than he, mostly because I am better at straight lines. :P
DeleteThe secret is invest in good razors, four blades minimum. You literally have to be trying to cut someone to do it with those.
Jenny, a small side note here: This embedded comment box system has known issues. With certain browsers, such as Safari, there is a known issue where a comment won't post, but the post count will go up. I've been dealing with it for months, and finally got that answer. It's been trying to comment, and couldn't. So I installed Chrome just for your site. Just bringing this up in case any of your other readers have been having the same issue. Google suggest having the comment box be the pop-out style.
ReplyDeleteSo, if it's dark and lights are twinkling when Ana goes outside to be mad, how can Christian see her bruises when she pulls down her top?
ReplyDeleteI saw that the screenwriter is hoping for an NC-17 rating on the film. Because they are "going there." Apparently Ana's coy inability to say what she's referring to has affected Kelly Marcel.
So, the abuse and bad grammar of this chapter had led me right into the arms of Tolkein. I've been listening to the audio books of "The Lord of the Rings".
ReplyDeleteAfter getting completely pissed off by the idiocy of FSF, I lay back and let someone tell a really GREAT story. Then I dream about Elijah Woods. Sweet, sweet Elijah Woods. Who is NOT young enough to be my son.
Don't judge me.
No one has commented on the top picture. I bet he's at the part where Christian pulls the tampon out. Cause his face is saying " White people are messed up. That shit ain't right." I think that cause that is the exact face one of my coworkers made when she read that part. And those words are a direct quote.
ReplyDeletewhat i dont like the most about these books it´s how desperate ana looks for "save" christian and actually belive it! my god... she cannot save him...this is the typical excuse in abusive relationships...my god these caracters should change their names into rihanna and chris brown! lol sorry the grammar and miss spelling...english not my mother language!...GOOD JOB!! LOVE U JEN!
ReplyDeleteThis just in:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.usatoday.com/story/life/books/2013/01/09/eljames-fifty-shades-of-grey-now-out-in-hardcover/1820465/
"For the first time, E.L. James' blockbuster novels — now available as e-books and paperbacks — will be published as hardcovers, ready to take a prideful, permanent place on fans' bookshelves. And just in time for Valentine's Day."
and
"There is also the author's signature, "Laters Baby, E.L. James X," embossed in silver on the book itself beneath the trademark Grey jackets featuring, respectively, the tie, the mask and the handcuffs."
And just to show how much everyone's losing touch with reality, the BEST way to make younger people want to read:
"There also is a discreet warning on the back guaranteed to keep little eyes from prying: "EROTIC ROMANCE: Mature Audience.""
Romance. Bull shitl
I think I threw up a little.
Deletethe shaving thing. I don't know how anyone can sit through and read that section. it so utterly mundane, how is it even worthy of putting in a book, its not even sexy. I mean what are they're going to do now? brush each others teeth cause its a real turn on? is Christian going to invent some weird breathing apparatus so he can breathe for her? Where is the line? these books are just pathetic.
ReplyDeleteThis book is so full of sadness and fail it is almost unbelievable.
ReplyDeleteI have to admit though, I am looking forward to your no longer pulling punches. There's just so much bullshit.
I can imagine two kinds of young American men saying "Why ever not?". The first is saying it sarcastically to mock someone. The second is a pretentious douchebag.
ReplyDeleteI love the reviews but I sometimes struggle to read them because of all the triggers the source material contains. I had shivers reading this one and actually had to walk away and have a cigarette to calm my nerves before I could continue.
ReplyDeleteI get so damn frustrated with Christian being held up as the greatest of romantic heroes because after being in a relationship with one of his real life counterparts (although thankfully one without the Grey finances to mega-stalk) I can categorically state, promise or swear on however many stacks of religious books you want to come up with that there is no love to one of these relationships, there is no romance and no growth as an individual or a partnership. What you do get is self doubt, self loathing, fear of *everything* and a whole lot of emotional and physical pain.
My own CG was very big on hickeys too and I had to constantly try and prevent him giving them to me (he even tried when I was asleep!). He saw it as a way of marking his turf, of making it clear to anyone and everyone that I was his property and as such had been branded like a steer. He *wanted* the hickeys to be in places where they were visible to all though funnily enough he didn't seem to have the same attitude to all the other marks he left on my body. Go figure!
Thankfully I'm out of there now and recently engaged to a truly wonderful man who would rather cut of his own lips than 'brand' me or break his own fingers than leave bruises on me from our sexy-times. I'd like to say that I wish there could be the same outcome for Ana but in all honesty I can't. Congratulations EL James! You have successfully created a heroine who is so monumentally unlikeable that even domestic violence survivors such as myself cannot find it in our hearts to want her out of the cycle of co-dependent abuse. So go on Ana, enjoy your platinum bracelet and fancy watch and try not to think about how they'll look on you in your coffin after your dick of a husband has finally gone that step too far...
That was the best use of Grumpy Cat ever.
ReplyDeleteI really, really hope that when the movie(probably -s) comes out it portrays the source material faithfully. Maybe some of the people thinking it's "SO ROMANTIC" while reading it and making pictures in their heads (and skipping over the less pleasant parts subconsciously) will have a different idea when it's on-screen...it would represent a horror thriller type thing instead of the biggest romance ever.
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking American Psycho. Too bad Christian Bale is too old to play Chedward.
This is perfect. My movie adaptation involves the two leads both as over 40, and everyone's gender reversed. Christian Bale would be PERFECT as Ana.
DeleteSo. They both have hard limits about HER body. How does that work?!
ReplyDeleteAll of this boat and sex talk keeps reminding me of the "implications" scene from It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZ1lc6KASWg
"The whole purpose of buying the boat in the first place is to get the ladies nice and tipsy top-side, so we can take them to a nice comfortable place below deck and...you know...they can't refuse. Because of the implication."
Me too! I wonder if Christian does hew pretty closely to the D.E.N.N.I.S. system, well, all except the S.
DeleteHahaha! The whole time I was reading this part, I let seeing Chedward as Dennis going on about "implications".
DeleteThis chapter really made me wonder: If this had been written by a man, would the abuse be so much more evidence to the audience who is currently supporting this series? Does that make sense? I just keep thinking about that.
ReplyDeleteAlso, interesting on EL James' twitter, she responds to EVERYONE who has something positive to day but happens to ignore anything else. Hmm.
It makes me wonder if the book had been written by a man would it have even been published.
DeleteI don't twitter, but it might be worth joining to post a satirical lauding of the books, whilst oversharing about the vissitudes of a genuinely abusive relationship.
DeleteNot sure if you watch The Soup, but last night they had a clip of an insane moron on the Bachelor. http://www.thesouptv.com/clips in case that doesn't link to the right video the clip is titled "50 Shades of Crazy"
ReplyDeleteShe is the exact type of woman you describe that is WILLFULLY STUPID. She wants a relationship with Christian Grey and is fucking stupid.
What do you think these same people who defend this book series would say if a man wrote these books? I feel like the abuse would be so much more apparent to them, and I don't know what it means or says about our society is abuse can be overlooked and glorified if it comes from a woman's imagination.
ReplyDelete"If you want a relationship with Christian Grey, you're fucking stupid."
ReplyDeleteExhibit A:
The Soup: Fifty Shades of Crazy http://www.thesouptv.com/clips/video/the-soup-fifty-shades-of-crazy/200562#.UO8S1cJItY4.twitter via @thesoup
I just... I can't....
"[...] the stick-thin sales assistant is staring at us with a jealous and disapproving look."
ReplyDeleteNo, Ana. That look was disgust and horror, because she noticed that your husband is buying you a 30,000 euro bracelet in order to cover up the bruises on your wrist.
I had to go and find a pirated version of this book to read. (Normally, I would not use those, but I REFUSE to give E.L. money or ratings). I just couldn't believe the book cold be as poorly written and horrible as you were making it out to be. OMG! The book is SO MUCH WORSE! How did this get famous? How are women into this? I have No words. Thank you, Jen, for letting me borrow yours (with proper credit of course) to explain the horror of this series.
ReplyDeleteI was going to point out the Soup clip, but a couple people already did, so I won't clog the comments anymore. Instead, I will implore you to use the Grumpy Cat graphic every time. Great blog as always!
ReplyDeleteHow are you even reading these books without wanting to chew your own head off just to get away from them? I thought book one was bad enough but this is simply gross - don't know what's more nauseating actually, the abuse or the relentless la-la-la-we're-so-rich money porn.
ReplyDeleteYou must have a cast iron stomach, Ms. Trout. I'm impressed.
By the way, this might cheer you up - it's a little thing a friend of mine wrote after a conversation on Twitter about what it would be like if Shakespeare had written Fifty Shades of Grey. He went all iambic and everything. It was great.
http://gominokouhai.dreamwidth.org/289122.html
Has anyone seen this?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.salon.com/2013/01/11/alisa_valdes_anti_feminist_romance_not_so_romantic/
It's Christian and Ana if they existed in real life. And I warn you all, the last line will make you hulk-smash-y.
Watch Buffy stake Edward. It will make you feel better about this horrible book.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZwM3GvaTRM
look I get that the bruises are from the twilight books, like directly from, but this is done all wrong. at least Edward bruised whatsherface after she begged for a year to be boned. and it was his literally supernatural strength that caused it. and he felt like shit after. and it was a fucking vampire book.
ReplyDeleteYou are a goddess in my book for recapping this horrid book. *bows to you* :p
ReplyDeleteWas I the only one who saw EL James on Katie Couric's show? EL came off as defensive and uncomfortable as hell. She got pissed when some guys told her that if any normal guy acted like Christian they would have gotten a restraining order put against them.
If you haven't seen it, here it is for your snarking pleasure
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M2-hiK3rghQ
preach It! Let them piss her off! The fact that this Fraud has even been published is unbelievable and sad!
DeleteLike I said, she sounds like a greedy leech who STOLE another person's writing and then WHINES when she is called out on it! Well tough luck E.L.! PAYBACK IS A BITCH, EH?
Was I the only one who saw EL James on Katie Couric's show last week? She came off defensive as hell on her precious Chedward being attacked.
ReplyDeleteA relationship expert nearly jizzed herself saying how great the book is for couples relationships.
Here is the link to youtube for your snarking pleasure:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M2-hiK3rghQ
"My body is so different these days. It's changed subtly since I've known him... I've become leaner and fitter, and my hair is glossy and well cut. My nails are manicured, my feet pedicured, my eyebrows threaded and beautifully shaped. For the first time in my life, I'm well groomed - except for these hideous love bites."
ReplyDeleteOh yes, and I'm walked every day, wormed regularly and given all the correct vaccinations. This reads like those letters that puppies write to their breeders when they get to their new homes.
"I realize that I'm coming off hostile here, but really, is there any other way to be at this point? When this piece of shit is the best selling ROMANCE of all time? When this relationship is the relationship that publishers are trying to sell to women as being the be all and end all, and we should all be sad about our marriages and how our husbands treat us with respect instead of as property? That's it. After this chapter, I'm not pulling punches."
ReplyDelete*STANDING OVATION*
"I crack my spoon through the burned sugar crust of my dessert. . ."
ReplyDeleteCreme brulee does not have a hard burnt sugar crust to crack through. It has the consistancy of flan. It is fancy French flan.
Erm, yeah, it kind of does. "Creme brulee" is french for "burnt sugar". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creme_brulee
DeleteYou're probably thinking of creme caramel.
So, I didn't read the first 2 but after feeling like "it can't get worse, right?" about 546546 times, I sought out a pirated version of the 3rd book online. (The ONLY book I have ever gotten illegally. I will not give her my money. I'm sorry)
ReplyDeleteUh... all it fucking DOES is get worse. If I thought I could stomach it again, I'd go back to make a tally of sentences similar to "yada yada yada but I can't say/do that because I don't even want to think about what he'd do" ... there are numerous times where she says that she is AFRAID of her husband. Not afraid that he'd be mad... but like... AFRAID OF HIM AND HIS ACTIONS TOWARDS HER. Even at the very end where it's supposed to be like riding off into the fucking sunset... In that chapter there was something like "Sometimes I'm afraid of my husband." Seriously. And I don't think it's a secret that Ana gets preggers. I mean, duh, Bella did so she has to. And I literally threw my kindle down and had to walk away when Christian was TELLING HER HOW TO HAVE HER BABY. oh my god.
Our babysitter is 18. I think of her looking at this and thinking "gee hope my college boyfriend is JUST like this." I want to cry. Can someone start a college course about abuse and misogyny in modern fiction or some shit and basically just rip this apart?
I'm an incoherent rambling mess but I can't help it. I feel something NEEDS to be done about this book. I HATE it. It's so horrible.
I loved that first picture so much that I went looking for the original source and found this awesome compilation of pictures called "People Caught Reading Fifty Shades of Grey in Public" - enjoy!
ReplyDeletehttp://loljam.com/post/1246/
That was hilarious!
Delete"Exactly what is this guy doing, that he's so afraid of the police coming anywhere near him?"
ReplyDeleteMy mind went "child porn. child porn. child porn." because I too am a bag person.
Every time the inner goddess is mentioned, I see this and hear the Flipper song.
ReplyDeleteEvery. Time.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ugC18AYIUTg
I'm behind. This is the first 50 recap I've read, Jenny. I know. Bad, bad, bad. So. Everyone with low self-esteem needs to have a Chedward in their lives - to give their life meaning and fulfillment. *coughbullshitcough* Abuse, thinly veiled as a dom/sub relationship is OK, too. *bzzzt* wrong answer. This was the WORST book I read this summer, and the worst series-end I've ever read. Trust me. I've read a LOT of series, in their entirety.
ReplyDeleteThe train-wreck that was the 50 Shades series simply doesn't portray anything in a realistic manner. I kind-of expect the Volturi Dom Squad to pop out of a cab somewhere in the city and rip off Ana's head because she hasn't signed a contract with Christian.
Too horrified to think. I need a blanket. And a shower.
ReplyDeleteHow can this happen. What did women do to you, EL James. Were they mean to you. They don't deserve this, EL James. How can you have so little empathy, how can you be so heartless with your fellow women.
Shellshocked. Just shellshocked.
So I read this hilarious webcomic called Oglaf (VERY NSFW, so careful about clicking the following link) and this was the latest update:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.oglaf.com/media/comic/goddessextraction.jpg
I'd just finished reading your recaps when I checked the comic and I just couldn't stop laughing at all the little ways this reminded me of 50SoG. The 'goddess' thing, the condescending/mansplaining dude, the bad purple prose... Plus, the punchline to the comic is now my headcanon as to why Ana is so thin, nay, *~svelte~*
I hope it makes you laugh as much as you've made me laugh with your amazing recaps.
--C
I know you're probably sick of people sending you all things related to this awful series, but I found this: http://50shadesofredpen.tumblr.com/
ReplyDeleteYou didn't provide any amusing links at the beginning of this recap, so I figured I'd try to contribute something. I love your commentary, though. It's kept me from falling asleep in class several times. My sister just said that she wants to read this series, and I've been trying to talk her out of it. I keep debating if I should send her a link to your blog, but idk if she'd actually read it. She's the sort of person that immediately closes the page when she sees more than a couple sentences, but maybe if I tell her it's about 50 Shades of Grey, she'll read it anyway...
For anyone who is a fan of Lou Rawls, the song You'll Never Find is the one Ana is referring to. You know, with the " cheezy" melody.
ReplyDeleteDid anyone else rage blackout?
I often wonder while reading your recaps if E.L. didn't actually mean for these books to be about an abusive relationship and then the readers spoke and she just went along because she was getting filthy rich instead of being all, "Hey, no guys, it's not a romance novel. It's a twilight fanatic centered around an abusive relationship." It can't actually be this bad can it? Or am I giving E.L. too much credit?
ReplyDeleteI have such a headache from reading this recap that I can't even begin to understand how you're getting through this abomination of a book for us without your brain exploding into bloody bits, Jen. Seriously, humanity has reached a new low.
ReplyDeleteAnd can I just express how much I loath those moronic "inner goddess" cheerleader descriptions littered everywhere? E.L. has forever ruined the term for me as I can no longer read/hear those two words together in any context without rolling my eyes in rage. That goddamn inner goddess schtick is not only adds absolutely nothing to the scenes but they actually disrupt the tone. I don't understand the logic of writing a sexy scene and then throw those inner goddess cartwheels right in the middle of it. I just can't take this book seriously. I just... I can't.
Oh and btw, "Christian has bought the bracelet, by the way, because he wants to cover up the bruise on her other wrist. I suppose when he gives her a black eye, he'll buy her an eyepatch covered in Swarovski crystals, and all will be forgiven." -- all jokes aside, given the way this book has been "progressing", this situation would be totally befitting.
I know this has been said multiple times already but thank you SO much for going through this heinous excuse of a book so that we don't have you. You're my hero.
This series. This freaking series.
ReplyDeleteThese books offend me as a woman, a feminist, and a domme.
The hickey thing COULD have been sexy if it was executed as part of an ACTUAL BDSM relationship. I leave hickeys on my boyfriend that no one but him can see so he can feel special, but NEVER in anger.
"It's like if you showed someone a picture of a duck, but they insisted it was a chicken, even after you explained all the ways that it's, for real now, a fucking duck."
ReplyDeleteUm, did anyone else think of the cutaway scene in family guy with the stubborn mule who doesn't think Kevin Bacon was in footloose? That's now how I imagine fans of this book.
Me: 50 shades is about an abusive relationship
Them:"No! No! NO! NO! HEE HAW! HEE HAW!"