Turns out, no. Because there never was any brain tumor. It was a big misunderstanding and, in the most likely scenario, just came down to a tired doctor saying "Pituitary" instead of "Thyroid," which is where the mass actually is.
That's some pretty great news, right? That I don't have a brain tumor? Well, hold onto your socks, because I'm about to blow them off. I went out to dinner with some family at a local pizza place, and suddenly there is this woman there, and she's waving to me to come closer. And I'm thinking, "Whaaaat?" So I went over to her and she said, "I had to come back in to tell you that I'm sorry for being so mean to you in school." Yup, on the same day I found out that I do NOT have a brain tumor, I ran into a girl who picked on me quite a lot in middle school, and she apologized for being mean.
So, of course I bought a lottery ticket. Because holy damn, guys, what an incredible day.
And that's why the recap didn't get finished, because I was celebrating the fact that I'm not going to die or get brain surgery or get really tall.
Well, here we are, at the second to last chapter of 50 Shades Darker. Which means the author will be wrapping up all the plot points and subplots and putting a button on the whole kit and caboodle, so that the arc of the individual book fits like a puzzle piece in the greater whole of the series.
Pfff, I'm not serious. What, are you new here?
When last we saw Christian and Ana, they were going to the playroom, because they're at that phase of their relationship where sex as a birthday present is still a thing. There is definitely an expiration date on that whole shebang, by the way. And when you breeze past it and don't notice. Awwwwwkward. You do not want to be standing in line at Best Buy naked under you trenchcoat, hoping you're buying the right Call of Duty, is all I'm going to say.
Christian asks Ana if there's anything she doesn't want to do, which is weird, because in the last chapter she told him what she didn't want to do. But he has to ask her now, so she can say that she doesn't want him to take photos of her, and that can be brought up later. He doesn't take it as a hint that she's seen his photos, though, so we can go right into the sex scene.
Placing the gift box on the chest of drawers, he takes out the iPod, switches it on, then waves at the music center on the wall so that the smoked glass doors glide silently open.Because he's a Jedi. And raise your hand if your iPod has a switch to turn it on. No, not the lock at the top. I mean, a switch that makes the music go. It's a button. It's always been a button.
He presses some buttons, and the sound of a subway train echoes around the room. he turns it down so that the slow, hypnotic electronic beat that follows becomes ambient. A woman starts to sing, I don't know who she is but her voice is soft yet rasping and the beat is measured, deliberate... erotic. Oh my. It's music to make love to.Let me tell you, nothing gets me hotter than the sound of a subway commute. Someone figure out what this song is. I couldn't figure it out from the 50 Shades of Grey playlists on Spotify and also I lost interest and wandered away and started listening to Iggy Pop instead.
Christian turns to face me as I stand in the middle of the room, my heart pounding, my blood singing in my veins, pulsing - or so it feels - in time to the music's seductive beat.No... it's really pulsing. Or should be. Otherwise you'd be dead, Ana, and if that were the case I imagined a lot more confetti and party hats would be littering my office. I like that her blood is actually singing, that part is fine, but her blood only feels like it could be pulsing. The metaphor would be fine if she'd just swapped them around. But hey, I'm talking like someone actually cared about the product here.
Christian asks if the reason they're in the playroom is because she thinks he wants to be there. Isn't that how birthdays work? You give someone something they want, or do something nice that would benefit them? What would the point be if he didn't want to be in there? She specifies that she wants to be in the playroom, too, and once they have that good and settled, he tells her to strip.
My inner goddess is stripped and standing in line, ready and waiting and begging me to play catch-up.Standing in a line? With who? The other characters Ana has rattling around in her head?
She's only wearing her robe and a nightgown, so getting undressed is pretty easy, and then Christian takes his silver tie from the cover of the first book and ties it around her neck:
He places the tie around my neck, and slowly but dexterously ties it in what I assume is a fine Windsor knot. As he tightens the knot, his fingers brush the base of my throat and electricity shoots through me, making me gasp. He leaves the wide end of the tie long, long enough so the tip skims my pubic hair.What she's not telling you is that she's wearing the tie like a goddamned Snuggie because she's so thin.
"You look mighty fine now, Miss Steele," he says and bends to kiss my gently on my lips.
Mighty fine, indeed.
Christian is all "'What shall we do with you now?'" and there's some kissing which is obviously super hot, and then we get the following description, which continues to perplex me:
When he pulls away, he's panting too and gazing down at me, his eyes molten gray;That's all we need from that sentence. Here's what bothers me about the descriptions of Christian's eyes "blazing" and being "molten." They're gray. Gray is a cool color, not a warm one. I guess "molten gray like melted pencil lead" might work, but still, blazing, etc. just doesn't seem like it belongs with gray. But maybe that's the kind of thing a person who can't even correctly describe fire does with words these days.
Christian braids Ana's hair and reminds us how beautiful it is, and then tells her she just has to ask him to stop and he will. At this point, Ana still believes that, after every time he has failed to stop doing something she's asked him to.
"Anastasia, these objects." He holds up the butt plug. "This is a size too big. As an anal virgin, you don't want to start with this. We want to start with this." He holds up his pinkie finger, and I gasp, shocked. Fingers... there? He smirks at me, and the unpleasant thought of anal fisting mentioned in the contract comes to mind.What a weird leap in reasoning. Did vaginal fisting come to mind when he fingered your v all those times? And why is it that a butt plug is no big whoop, but sticking a finger in your pooper is shocking?
The nipple clamps she selected are also too hardcore, so he gets some pretty ones with dangly jewels for her to wear.
I blink up at him, wide-eyed. Christian, my sexual mentor. He knows so much more about all of this than I do. I'll never catch up. I frown. He knows more than me about most things... except cooking.Just in case you're wondering why that ham-fisted reference to Ana's skill in the kitchen has been clumsily stuffed into the middle of a sex scene, I assure you, it comes up in a few pages.
Ana asks Christian if he's going to tell her what he's going to do to her, and he reminds her that this isn't like before:
"I'm your lover, Anastasia, not your Dom. I love to hear your laugh and your girlish giggle. I like you relaxed and happy, like you are in Jose's photos. That's the girl that fell into my office. That's the girl I fell in love with."There's a lot going on here, but I think I have it sorted out:
- Doms don't love their subs.
- Lovers like it when their partners enjoy themselves, Doms don't.
- Christian wants Ana to be happy, like she is with Jose, so Ana should go fuck Jose
- This entire book is bullshit.
And it only gets worse from there:
"But having said all that, I also like to do rude things to you, Miss Steele, and my alter ego knows a trick or two. So, do as you're told and turn around." His eyes glint wickedly, and the joy moves sharply south, seizing me tightly and gripping every sinew below my waist."Then homegirl needs to stretch, because she doesn't want to blow her Achilles while they're fucking. Seriously, sinews? The connective tissue that keeps your muscles attached to your bones? How is that erotic in any way? And remember before, when we talked about Britishisms? "Rude" doesn't mean to Americans what it means to Brits, at least in this sense. When he says, "'I also like to do rude things to you,'" he could mean he's just not going to hold the elevator door when he can clearly see she's trying to catch it. Americans don't use "rude" to mean raunchy or racy, the way it's used there.
Ana notices that Christian has taken all the canes out of the room. So, phew, I guess that means he's been cured by the power of love, or something. Christian asks her kneel on a table.
Oh, okay. What does he have in mind? My inner goddess can't wait to find out - she's already scissor-kicked onto the table and is watching him in adoration.Your inner goddess scissor-kicked a table? What? I'm trying to get a mental picture of how one scissor-kicks onto something. Is anyone out there a martial arts expert? Seriously, we need help over here.
Christian gets out some leather cuffs:
His proximity is intoxicating. This man is going to be my husband. Can one lust after one's husband like this? I don't remember reading about that anywhere.Then it must not be possible, Ana, because you're so fucking well-read. But thanks for reinforcing the myth that sex after marriage is a chore to be endured, not a healthy, vital part of the relationship to be enjoyed. Everything about this book is just sadness and spaghetti left in a strainer in the sink to harden.
I can't resist him, and I run my parted lips along his jaw, feeling the stubble, a heady combination of prickly and soft, under my tongue. He stills and closes his eyes. His breathing falters and he pulls back.
"Stop. Or this will be over far quicker than either of us wants," he warns.He seems to say this a lot. I think he might have a problem.
This one is dedicated to Christian "over before it started" Grey.
Christian cuffs Ana's upper arms and covers her eyes.
"I don't want to ruin my favorite tie," he murmurs. It slowly unravels as he undoes it.So... it's ruined?
His hand flexes over my neck, and it's slick with sweet-smelling oil so his hand glides smoothly down my throat, across my clavicle, and up to my shoulder, his fingers kneading gently as they go. Oh, I'm getting a massage. Not what I expected.
He places his other hand on my other shoulder and begins another slow teasing journey across my clavicle.Clavicle is one of those "stand out" words that you can't repeat too often in a single scene. In two consecutive paragraphs? Definitely not.
"And soon you'll be my wife to have and to hold," he whispers.
Oh my.
"To love and to cherish."
Jeez.
"With my body, I will worship you."Those are going to be really touching wedding vows. I just wish she could work "Holy crap!" in there somewhere. "I, Anastasia Rose Steele, HOLY CRAP!, pledge my troth and my inner goddess, etc. nipple clamps and stuff. Jeez, I'm flushing!" I now pronounce you dumb and dumber.
"Mrs. Grey," he whispers as his palm works against me.So... probably no chance of keeping her own name, then?
My mouth is already open from panting. I open wider, and he slips a large cool metal object between my lips. Shaped like an oversized baby's pacifier, it has small grooves or carvings, what feels like a chain at the end. It's big.
You summoned me, master?
He takes the "pacifier" out of her mouth. Why does she know what a butt plug is by sight, but not by feel? Also, thank GOD we know he buys knew toys for every sub. Because otherwise, ew.
He's reoiled his hands. They glide around to my backside.
I gasp. What's he going to do?He's going to dive into your ass, Ana.
"I'm going to put this inside you," he murmurs. "Not here." His fingers trail between my buttocks, spreading oil. "But here." He moves his fingers around and around, in and out, hitting the front wall of my vagina. I moan and my restrained nipples swell.Not here, but here. We have to be very specific.
Honestly, I couldn't tell whose fingers were where when I first read this scene, because of the author's stubborn refusal to use words to distinguish one anatomical part from another. And it just gets more confusing:
Christian removes his fingers and slides the object into me. He cups my face and kisses me, his mouth invading mine, and I hear a very faint click. Instantly the plug inside me starts to vibrate - down there! I gasp. The feeling is extraordinary - beyond anything I've felt before.Nothing says "totally sexually naive" like a heroine who is surprised to learn that vibrators exist. By the way, the plug is in her vagina. I had to go back and reread several times to get that even though he put his hand between her buttcheeks before, he's not diving into her ass. He put the vibrating plug in her cooch. You know, not there, but there.
"So beautiful," he murmurs and suddenly he gently pushes an anointed finger inside me... there! Into my backside.At least she lets us know which there there is this time. Why is it every time I read any other hero say something like, "So beautiful" in a sex scene, I think, "Oh man, that's hot, he's telling her she's beautiful," but if Chedward does it I'm like, "Now assign her a monetary value!" It always seems like he's congratulating himself when he compliments Ana.
So, he fingers her booty and she comes like crazy and all the adjectives you've come to expect are in there. Then he uncuffs her and takes the mask off and she says:
"I think you're trying to kill me," I mutter.She has this mind-blowing orgasm, which is, by the way, the most selfish birthday present I've ever heard of anyone giving - "For your birthday, you may drive me to heights of pleasure I have never before experienced, you're welcome," - and then she complains about it!
"Death by orgasm." He smirks. "There are worse ways to go," he says but then frowns ever so slightly as an unpleasant thought crosses his mind. It distresses me. I reach up and caress his face.
"You can kill me like this anytime," I whisper.I will just assume the handcuffs on the cover of book three allude to the fact that he will murder Ana in a snuff video and get caught by the FBI.
"I want to make love to you," he says, gazing down at me, his gray eyes burning with bright, loving sincerity. Softly in the background, a familiar voice starts to sing "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face." And his lips find mine.
Anybody else seen this one?
This is so blatantly fucking ripped off. First of all, I highly doubt that a twenty-something kinky sex pervert is going to pick Roberta Flack to fuck to. Second, that song was already used in a famous sex scene, in Clint Eastwood's Play Misty For Me. Well, she's already ripped off the piano scene from Pretty Woman almost shot for shot, why not this, too? It's a grand tradition, really. Before this book came out I had a theory that the meadow scenes in Twilight were "inspired" by the sex scene in Play Misty For Me, so I don't know why I'm surprised. Go watch it, if you don't believe me.
As I tighten around him, finding my release once more, Christian unravels in my arms, his head thrown back as he calls out my name. He clasps me tightly to his chest as we sit nose to nose in the middle of his vast bed, me astride him. And in this moment - this moment of joy with this man to this music - the intensity of my experience this morning in here with him and all that has occurred during the past week overwhelms me anew, not just physically but emotionally. I am completely overcome with all these feelings. I am so deeply in love with him. For the first time I'm offered a glimmer of understanding as to how he feels about my safety.Aaaand there it is. There had to be a reason for her to go into the playroom again, right? Now we have it. Ana's character arc - which is really more like a wavy line with a lot of disconnected bits at this point - had to take her back to the playroom so she could realize that Christian only wants what's best for her, when he's not wanting to beat the shit out of her. So, it's okay for him to keep her in a virtual prison and isolate her from friends and family, because he really does care. Good thing he faked a helicopter accident to teach her that lesson.
So many sides of Christian - his sweet, gentle persona and his rugged, I-can-do-what-I-fucking-well-like-to-you-and-you'll-come-like-a-train Dominant side - his fifty shades - all of him. All spectacular. All mine.Stand back ladies, he's taken.
Do trains orgasm? Or do trains just really get Ana off? Before, she thought the sound of a subway train was good to fuck to, and now she's comparing her orgasms to the kinds of orgasms trains have. Maybe Christian was working the wrong angle, trying to impress her with his helicopter.
And I'm aware we don't know each other well, and we have a mountain of issues to overcome, but I know for each other, we will - and we'll have a lifetime to do it.Yeah, so just start marrying guys you don't know real well, ladies. Especially if they're controlling and maybe one time beat the shit out of you with a belt until you broke up with them. All that stuff can get worked out later.
He kisses me gently as Roberta Flack finishes her song.That song is only like four minutes long, guys. This is not really recommending Christian Grey as the sex god he's supposed to be.
There is a section break, and then:
We have talked and talked and talked, sitting upright together on the bed in the playroom, me in his lap, our legs curled around each other. The red satin sheet is draped around us like a royal cocoon, and I have no idea how much time has passed. Christian is laughing at my impersonation of Kate during the photo shoot at the Heathman.
"To think it could have been her who came to interview me. Thank the Lord for the common cold," he murmurs and kisses my nose.
"I believe she had the flu, Christian," I scold him,I'm glad E.L. skipped all the boring part where the two of them actually talked and maybe worked out some of the relationship problems that might have given a reader reason to pause over the whole engagement thing, and just skipped right ahead to bashing Kate again. Because who wants to listen to character development and other pointless shit like that, when we can just prove how much the hero loves the heroine by having a scene where they make fun of one of the heroine's friends?
Chedward doesn't, however, thank the Lord for influenza, because that's what ended up getting him turned into a tortured vampire in the first place.
The constant reminders that Christian likes Ana better than Kate are something I would expect out of a fanfic written by a sixteen-year-old. The fact that this is the work of a grown woman makes me die inside.
They talk about how Christian got rid of the canes, and what else he can get rid of. He doesn't need that stuff anymore because he's been cured with the power of love. Then Ana lists off the things she loves about him, and she says he's compassionate, and I spit my coffee directly into the book. Nothing says compassion like beating a woman with a belt and then wondering why she's so upset with you. Then there is implied sex, and then she decides she's going to cook for him, since it's his birthday, and for what seems like the first time ever, they mention being hungry without tacking on, "but not for food." I wept with joy, dear reader. Actual, salty tears of joy.
After a paragraph break, we FINALLY get a little Taylor action:
Christian is in his study on the phone. Taylor is with him, looking serious but casual in jeans and a tight black t-shirt.I'm biting my lip, Taylor.
Ana is making poached salmon and baby potatoes, and she asks Taylor how his daughter is (because a couple chapters ago he mentioned something was wrong with her). Now, please brace yourselves, dear reader. Because your lovely image of Taylor is about to be shattered:
"Yes, thanks. My ex-wife thought she had appendicitis, but she was overreacting as usual." Taylor rolls his eyes, surprising me. "Sophie's fine, though she has a nasty stomach bug."
How could this .gif actually come in handy TWICE for the same book?
Seriously, Taylor? You're going to complain that your ex-wife is TOO CAUTIOUS ABOUT YOUR CHILD'S HEALTH. I bet it really interrupted your super important schedule of licking Christian Grey's balls on command. Fuck you, Taylor. I trusted you. I thought you were different.
But, as with every female character, either on-stage or off, Taylor's ex-wife needs to be denigrated. Because women (who aren't Ana) are all universally terrible people. We're not supposed to be thinking, "Taylor is kind of a dick here for thinking his ex-wife is too careful when it comes to the life of their child," we're supposed to be thinking, "Ugh, stupid Taylor's ex-wife. Women are gross. It's too bad they can't all be Ana."
I flush... will I ever get used to Taylor calling me Ma'am? It makes me feel so old, at least thirty.
I wish I had more middle fingers.
Kate texts Ana to say she's looking forward to a long conversation when they see each other that night, and it's a good thing she doesn't want it right then, because Ana literally responds with two words and a couple asterisks: "*Same here*" Then she goes on to send a multi-subject email to Christian, who, as you may remember, is in the other freaking room. And not just one. Oh no, they have a an exchange via email. The word "loquacious" comes up. Kate has been gone for weeks, Ana has allegedly missed her terribly, she gets two words. Christian is in the other room, he gets a state of his union with Ana address. Then there is a section break.
I've made a watercress, cilantro, and sour cream dip to accompany the salmon, and I've set the breakfast bar.I've stolen Mrs. Jone's job.
Ana goes into Christian's home office to tell him his lunch is ready. And Christian repays this gesture how?
"That dress is very short," he adds.
"You like it?" I give him a quick twirl. It's one of Caroline Acton's purchases. A soft turquoise sundress, probably more suitable for the beach, but it's such a lovely day on so many levels. He frowns and my face falls.
"You look fantastic in it, Ana. I just don't want anyone else to see you like that."Christian is going to make one more call before lunch. Turns out, it's to Ana's dad. Remember when she told him not to call and ask for her hand, because that whole thing is old fashioned? I think you know why Ray is on the phone. Cause and effect, folks. She wore a dress Christian didn't approve of, so he's going to call her father and tell him that she's gone and got engaged, whether she wants him to or not.
Ana talks to her dad, who thinks it's not so great that she's going to marry a dude that she just met. Thank god she has a strong role model in her life who can talk some sense into her:
"Annie... I know he's all kinds of rich and eligible, but marriage? It's such a big step. You're sure?"
"He's my happily ever after," I whisper.
"Whoa," Ray says after a moment, his tone softer.
"He's everything."
"Annie, Annie, Annie. You're such a headstrong young woman. I hope to God you know what you're doing. Hand me back to him, will you?""I think you're making a huge mistake, and as your father, I - what? Oh, you're going to use a cliche platitude to express why this is a good idea? Then by the rules set forth by the council of rarely-seen book dads, I hereby declare this bridge open!" Way to save the fucking day, Ray. You're as useless as Charlie. Probably more so, because at least Charlie was trying to correct that thinking while Bella was still technically a child.
Christian talks to Ray more, only after smirking at Ana because isn't it funny how he's dictating her life even when she doesn't want him to?
"I have your stepfather's begrudging blessing," he says proudly, so proudly, in fact, that it makes me giggle, and he grins at me. He's acting like he's just negotiated a major new merger or acquisition, which I suppose on one level, he has.Gosh, Ana, when you put it like that, it sounds like you're some piece of property he just owns. I'm sure that's not what the author meant to convey, considering how forward-thinking and female-positive this entire thing is.
Then they eat lunch, and this happens:
"Ana?" He interrupts my thoughts. "Why did you ask me not to take your photo?" His question startles me all the more because his voice is deceptively soft.
Oh... shit. The photos. I stare down at my empty plate, twisting my fingers in my lap. What can I say? I'd promised myself not to mention that I'd found his version of Penthouse Pets.It's just Penthouse, Ana. The girls in the magazine are the pets. The title of the magazine isn't Penthouse Pets.
"Ana," he snaps. "What is it?" He makes me jump, and his voice commands me to look at him. When did I think he didn't intimidate me?
"I found your photos," I whisper.
His eyes widen in shock. "you've been in the safe?" he asks, incredulous.Whoa, Bluebeard much, Chedward? What's in the safe, that you're so worried about her getting in there? Besides the severed and preserved heads of the other subs, I mean.
Christian tells Ana that the photos were supposed to be in the safe, and explains that he's not keeping them for the reason she thinks:
"This is going to sound cold, but - they're an insurance policy," he whispers, steeling himself for my response.
"Insurance policy?"
"Against exposure."
The penny drops and rattles uncomfortably around and around in my empty head.Yes, it's probably quite uncomfortable to have something in there if you're not used to it.
Ana is as skeeved out by the idea of keeping pictures for blackmailing old sex partners as I am, but don't worry, she gets over it fast:
"Do they know? The girls... the subs?"
He frowns. "Of course they know."
Oh, well, that's something. He reaches out, grabbing me and pulling me to him.No, it really isn't something, you twit. Because you were going to be a sub. There wasn't anything about those photos in the contract. No where in the NDA did it say, "I will take pictures of you in sexual situations so that you have to do whatever I tell you to." Ana, you stupid, stupid, stupid person, he would have done the same thing to you.
Christian believes Leila got the pictures out of his safe. How? I'm going to warn you now, do not read the following excerpt while drinking anything, eating anything, smoking, don't do anything you could choke or spit or burn yourself with reading Christian's following explanation:
He shrugs. "It wouldn't surprise me. It's a very long combination, and I use it so rarely. It's the one number I have written down and haven't changed."Emphasis mine. Okay, so Christian has these pictures of his subs in compromising, "you will never be President of the United States," type situations. Where does he keep them? In his safe, the combination to which he has written down, clearly in a place where just anyone could find it. The guy with the security team who does "sweeps" of every location he visits like they're the goddamned secret service, and he has not only an unlocked filing cabinet full of everyone's personal data, but he has a safe with a combination that is too hard to remember, so he just keeps it written down where someone can easily access it.
We have been told over and over that this man is intelligent. That means this book is a fucking liar.
Christian says he'll shred the photos, and Ana decides she's going to back a chocolate cake for Christian for his birthday. So, if you're having trouble following along, the chapter thus far has gone:
- "Your dress is too short! I will punish you by calling your father and asking for your hand."
- "You kept sexually explicit photos of your ex-lovers as potential blackmail material! I will make you a cake!"
She also calls her mother to tell her she's getting married, and it doesn't go great:
"You're not pregnant, are you, Ana?" she whispers in horror.
"No no no, nothing like that." Disappointment slices through my heart, and I'm saddened that she would think that of me. But then I remember with an ever-sinking feeling that she was pregnant when she married my father.You know what? Fuck you, Ana. "'saddened that she would think that of me?'" Like it's some horrible thing to think that a woman might get pregnant from regular sexual intercourse? Like you don't want to be thought of as the kind of slut who gets pregnant, because only bad girls get pregnant, and good girls' bodies have "ways to try to shut that whole thing down?"
E.L. James, you have gotten on my last fucking nerve. SEX, which your heroine has in abundance, causes PREGNANCY. It's not something to be saddened about. It's biology. I got pregnant with my son before I got married. What does that make me? I'm serious, E.L. James, if you are out there and you ever see this, I DEMAND you explain to me why Ana should be "saddened" that her mom thinks she got pregnant. Look me in the fucking eye and try to claim that what you wrote there doesn't put down women who get pregnant outside of marriage, which, by the by, isn't the prerequisite to bearing a goddamned baby. Sperm. meeting. Egg. is how babies happen and guess what? Your airhead hypocrite insecure misogyny spewing heroine has been having PLENTY of sex. Take your massive lack of writing skill, build an island with it, and take all your little slut-shaming groupies there with you. Leave the rest of the world out of it, because we don't want your landslide of outdated notions further burying us here.
Ana gets off the phone with her mom and thinks that she doesn't want a big wedding, so lets all look forward the huge wedding Chedward will ultimately force her to have, and which she will love and think, "I was so wrong," about because Chedward knows best.
Christian's kitchen is a dream to work in. For a man who knows nothing about cooking, he seems to have everything. I suspect Mrs. Jones loves to cook, too.I suspect it's her job.
Ana needs to go pick up some ingredients for baking the cake, and Christian asks her to change out of the short dress before leaving the house. Ana asks him if he would object to her wearing the dress at the beach, and he says no, so she tells him to pretend they're at the beach and leaves. So, good for Ana, right? Until she gets in the elevator and decides that her skirt is too short, and he's completely right, but at least she doesn't go change.
I stare at my receipt from the ATM: $51,689.16. That's $50,000 too much! Anastasia, you're going to have to learn to be rich, too, if you say yes. And so it begins.He did it again. Hey, E.L. here's something you might not know. If you wire $50,000.00 into someone's American bank account, and they usually only have about $1,000 in there, the FBI could investigate them for terrorism. Seriously. When you get a bank account in the US, you have to sign a little waiver thing saying you're not going to use the account to take funds from terrorist organizations and drug dealers. Our government can monitor our accounts to see if that's happening. I believe they have the authority to investigate any deposit over $10k, but I could be wrong. Suddenly, Christian Grey - who is doing a lot of stuff with technology in other countries - puts $50k in your bank account, and you're both going to be investigated. Not to mention the tax nightmare of someone just handing you that $50k in unearned income. Guess what, you're going to have to pay taxes on that, Anastasia Rose Steele. Hope you guys don't break up before April.
Ana's more worried about her dress and the fallout from disobeying Christian, though:
I head straight to the kitchen when I arrive back, and I can't help feeling a frisson of alarm. Christian is still in his study. Jeez, that's most of the afternoon. I decide my best option is to face him and see how much damage I've done.Remember, this is the damage she's done by wearing a dress she chose that he did not like. So we're all on the same page as to how silly/creepy this "fight" is going to be.
"Hi," I whisper. He says nothing, and my heart free-falls into my stomach, Gingerly I walk into his study and around his desk to where he's sitting. He still says nothing, his eyes never leaving mine. I stand in front of him, feeling fifty shades of foolish.I used to love it when movies/books/shows referenced the title in them. But not like this. This is like if John McClane had looked over the side of the building after Hans fell to his death and said, "Looks like he just died... hard," and then winked directly into the camera.
"I'm back. Are you mad at me?"
He sighs, reaches out for my hand, and pulls me into his lap, wrapping his arms around me. He buries his nose in my hair.
"yes," he says.
"I'm sorry. I don't know what came over me." I curl up in his lap, inhaling his heavenly Christian smell, feeling safe regardless of the fact that he's mad.I'm sorry, I don't know what came over me for wearing whatever I damn well please on the body that belongs to me and not you, honey. I won't do it again.
It's okay, though, because Christian isn't super mad. He actually likes the dress, because it means he can fuck Ana in the desk chair. So, I guess she's allowed to wear whatever she likes provided it makes her vagina easy to access.
After the sex, Ana gives Christian his birthday cake:
And I laugh with relief... he likes it.Well, thank god, because the suspense was killing me.
Then there is a section break, and Ana and Christian have just arrived at Christian's parents house for his birthday party.
Before we can set foot in the living room, Kate comes barreling down the hallway toward the two of us. She looks furious.Kate forces Christian and Ana into the dining room.
"What the fuck is this?" she hisses and waves a piece of paper at me. Completely at a loss, I take it from her and scan it quickly. My mouth dries. Holy shit. It's my e-mail response to Christian, discussing the contract.Thank god! Someone is going to finally see how fucked up this entire relationship is and get Ana into some counseling!
Or probably not. And that's the end of the chapter.
I worldwide bey al Of mt money test the sono ve pura in is "Damb I Wish I Was Your Lover" by Sophie B. hawaiana, whig Malesia me Dad bevande i fu kung love They sono.
ReplyDeleteI was just going crazy, checking your blog like, every 30 minutes! Well, I love you too much to be mad at you for the delay, ‘coz you’re just awesome! Btw, Congrats on your lottery!
ReplyDeleteI’m supposed to be studying right now, and this:
No... it's really pulsing. Or should be. Otherwise you'd be dead, Ana, and if that were the case I imagined a lot more confetti and party hats would be littering my office. I like that her blood is actually singing, that part is fine, but her blood only feels like it could be pulsing. The metaphor would be fine if she'd just swapped them around. But hey, I'm talking like someone actually cared about the product here.
It got me laughing so damn hard, today it made me realise how lucky I’m to have room really isolated from the rest of my house.
I believe the "or so it feels" is in reference to the idea that her blood is pulsing *in time to the music*. Of course, the author should have moved the "or so it feels" to the end of the sentence to avoid that misunderstanding, but at least it makes a smidge more sense if you interpret it that way.
Deleteyes, but i don't think it should be the readers job to adjust a little phrase here and a couple of words there to make some sense. Are you listening EL James??? THAT IS THE JOB OF THE WRITER!!! I wrote better stuff than this shit when I was fourteen. My ten-year old sister writes stuff which is more sensible than this!
DeleteYes, but it isn’t the job of the reader to adjust a phrase here and there to make some sense. That is the author’s job. Are u listening EL James?? I wrote better stuff when I was fourteen. Hell, my ten-year old sister’s stories make more sense than this piece of shit.
DeleteYes, but it isn’t the job of the reader to adjust a phrase here and there to make some sense. That is the author’s job. Are u listening EL James?? I wrote better stuff when I was fourteen. Hell, my ten-year old sister’s stories make more sense than this piece of shit.
Delete""I, Anastasia Rose Steele, HOLY CRAP!, pledge my troth and my inner goddess, etc. nipple clamps and stuff. Jeez, I'm flushing!""
ReplyDeleteI just died. Seriously
So somehow my phone got switched to a different language on that last comment. My apologies. What I meant to say is this:
ReplyDeleteI would bet all of my money the song he puts on is "Damn I Wish I Was Your Lover" by Sophie B. Hawkins. Which is terrible because I really fucking love that song.
I worked with a woman who would burst out singing that song at odd intervals and we had to ask her to stop because we'd all jump a foot when this piercing "Damn!" would erupt from nowhere.
DeleteOmg, Andrea! That's f*cking hilarious!
DeleteVery glad you don't have a brain tumor.
ReplyDeleteOut of every chapter you have recapped so far, I think this is the most dismal. I'm disgusted by the messages (I think she may have insulted EVERYBODY, all at once, that she's insulted one by one so far) and the terrible writing. Boo, I say to E.L. James. BOOOOOOOOOO.
PS: I think first commenter Alexis may have been typing from a drunk iPhone, but I think she's right about the song.
Oh, she explained. Sorry, Alexis!
DeleteYour "drunk iPhone" assessment was entirely correct, though! I have no idea how to delete my own comments--at least not from my phone because Blogger sucks on mobile--so I shall forever look like I was posting drunk comments at noon on a Wednesday. Could be worse.
DeleteOh please don't delete it. In combination with the explanatory email, it's surrealist comedy gold. I read the first comment, went "gwuh?" and then "okay, spambots have found this blog", and then you explained it and it was magical!
DeleteI thought she was Malaysian.
DeleteHis proximity is intoxicating. This man is going to be my husband. Can one lust after one's husband like this? I don't remember reading about that anywhere.
ReplyDeleteThis sends me into fits of "EFF YOU TOO!" and makes me want to start guessing about EL's marriage. I hate her for reducing me to this. HATE.
Also: extra middle fingers because fuck these characters.
Deletehttp://i.imgur.com/mYpKF.jpg
I'm really starting to question her personal life as well...
DeleteI think each subsequent recap is going to make me more excited for "The Boss." I really, REALLY want to read some erotica that isn't a) abusive, b) badly written, and c) NOT EVEN REMOTELY SEXY. I had better sex than that when I was 17, for chrissake, and we all know what teenage boys are like.
ReplyDeleteSo yeah. Fix it, Jen! Save us from this tripe!
Incidentally, any man who thinks he can tell me what to wear is going to find himself glued into a Strawberry Shortcake costume and stranded in a public place.
Ha, WOW. That is all I have to say is WOW. I think this chapter is 50 shades of fucked up.
ReplyDeleteCongrats on not having a brain tumour! They should make cards that say that.
ReplyDeleteQuestion: he fingers her ass with his pinky, right, and then they "make love" (which he can do now that he has been fixed by love)? So does he wash his hands? Is there a section break during which it is possible he washed his hands before the lovemaking? Or did he straight-up rub his ass-finger all over her body during sex? Because that's unhygienic, yo. And would smell bad.
Relatedly, I actually think Ana being fine with buttplugs, but shocked by the idea of a finger in her bum, is not entirely odd. Given that she is still new to anal stuff and likely working on overcoming shame and squick and worry about being dirty "there" (hah!), the idea of any "ick" getting on any part her lover's body could be more worrying than the idea of it getting on an inanimate object.
DeleteI'm now picturing him *intentionally* rubbing the ass-finger on her. Just that pinky. While she writhes in ecstasy. And it's hilarious.
Delete@lucy: and even imagining that makes me gag.
DeleteOh, this was a masterful piece of writing. Funny, pointed, and with a pow! FUCK YOU EL JAMES right when it needed to happen.
ReplyDeleteJust clapping over here. And wiping tea off my laptop because I did not heed your warnings.
I snapped in a circle for you during your amazing "fuck you" rant. I read that shit out loud and giggled like a small child. I love you.
ReplyDeleteMe too! I read it twice in a row. Awesome.
DeleteThis whole chapter is so rage worthy that I have to focus on something ridiculous that's been bugging this entire time: the fact that every character constantly whispers things. Why isn't this book also constantly filled with characters saying "What? I can't hear you, what?"
ReplyDeleteCongrats on your kick ass day! I'm glad the tumor was a false alarm. :)
"What? Ican't hear you, what?"
DeleteI fell out of my bed. But its a superb idea. Might make the shit readable.Just a little bit.
Actually, what would happen with the $50,000 deposit (and the $25,000 check for her car) is the bank would file a form informing the government (because it is a deposit $10,000 or over), and it's doubtful that anybody would look twice at it, because it wouldn't fit the profile for either money laundering or terrorism.
ReplyDeleteHowever, unless they married by the end of the year, it would count against Christian's gift tax allowance, because it is way over the amount you can legally gift someone (who isn't your spouse) without ending up having to pay gift tax on it. Gift tax is meant to keep people from getting out from under estate tax by "giving" the money to their heirs. Ana would not be liable for taxes (you're never liable for taxes on a genuine gift), and Christian's estate would end up paying the gift tax after he died.
They got engaged after, what, two months? If it's any month other than December I'm guessing they can manage to rush it in. ;)
DeleteSo his plan is to marry her, kill her, and then get the money back. It's a money laundering scheme!!
DeleteI didn't think it was possible to be so entirely sexist in one chapter, but hats off to E. L. frickin James. I just really wanted to let my head fall onto my desk and hit it so hard so I could get amnesia so I could forget that this book ever existed. I just do not have words for the amount of rage this induces. REALLY HER DRESS IS TOO SHORT? If Christian Grey was real and I could murder him...
ReplyDeleteI can't understand how you can take that as anything other than a completely controlling douchewad abuser. Not to mention from a fiction writing angle, completely contrived drama. Wasn't he the one that fit the bill and had all of these clothes bought for her in the first place?
As for the whole Kate finding Anna's e-mail thing I bet I can tell you right now how this is going to play out. Let's see if my predictions come true. I'm almost willing to go read the final chapter of 50 Shades Darker just to see after I post this.
1. Kate is going to be characterized as a complete bitch for breaking into Anna's e-mail. (Which of course Anna always thinks of her as a bitch anyway even though they're -OMG BFFS or something- which is SO BELIEVABLE.)
2. The content of said e-mail is going to be completely undermined by the fact that Kate has ~betrayed~ Anna's trust by breaking into her e-mail.
3. If Christian becomes involved in this scene legal action will be threatened.
4. In characterizing Christian as an abuser this will be the final nail in the Anna/Kate trusting relationship effectively cutting Anna off from all of her friends who think that this is a bad, bad idea, because obviously since Kate broke into her e-mail Anna will be right in thinking that Christian is really the only person who ~wuvs and trusts her~ unlike Kate who is the bitchiest of jealous bitches and obviously wants to break them up because she is a jealous hater of some kind and not legitimately concerned. Which I'm sure will come up if Anna and Christian talk about this.
5. Anna is totally right to marry Christian because their "true wuv" outshines any other relationship that Anna could ever conceivably have.
Could we just have a moment of silence for Kate, because she is a good friend who should be giving Anna an intervention? I'd much rather be reading about her as she seems to have her shit together.
Well I sneaked a peek, and I'm disappointed a little (a lot) that I'm kind of off. However, in Twilight style fashion -OMG HUGE BUILD-UP- that is diffused in like five seconds. The hilarious confrontation that follows though... ooooh man. This book guys. This book. I can't wait to see the next recap.
DeleteI think you're going to be totally right in those predictions. Which is, in itself, hugely depressing. But then this whole book is one massive shit fest, so why WOULDN'T it end in a genuine attempt at helping a woman in a clearly abusive relationship, only for her act of friendship to be used against her by the author as a way of showcasing just how wonderful the TRUE LOVE between Christian and Ana really is?! I could weep. Ugh.
DeleteAh balls, I so thought you'd be right! It still bugs me that Kate makes an effort to show her friend how fucked up this whole thing is and it still doesn't result in no third book, though. :P
DeleteThreesome, yes? Have not read the book. Do not want to read the book. Too lazy to search now... but curious nonetheless. Threesome, right?
DeleteAnd thank you for your awesomeness Jen. Love your style.
I was SO SURE! However she didn't actually break into anyone's email so that diffused that, but she did rifle through someone's jacket pockets and found it. Christian and Anna are both angry at her, they're both like "wtf are you doing?", and then they ask if she'd told anyone and once it's clear she hasn't Anna is like, "I'm getting married SHHH we'll talk later." The whole, "OMG you're getting married?!?!?!" pretty much shuts up Kate and the promise to talk about the e-mail later when Anna and Christian both assure her that everything is "OK," yeeeah. BUT. I realize the only reason it didn't go that way is because it's not the final confrontational thing that happens in the book. I think if Kate finding the e-mail had been the final plot hurdle of the book it would have been, but as you will see next week that won't be the case. So in a sense some of predictions come true sorta, just by other means and without Christian threatening legal action against Kate. I really jonesing for that. Ultimate proof. And then SUPER MYSTEROUS CLIFFHANGER WHAT WILL HAPPEN NEXT? Oh man, makes me laugh.
DeleteI was panicking wondering where the recap was yesterday but I'm very glad at least it was late because you had a good day rather than a bad. Anyway brilliant as usual. And I would actually like it if "he died, hard." with a wink was in Die Hard because that would be hilarious. Also the whole "your skirt is too short" thing was creepy as that is textbook abusive behaviour. Haven't seen chris Hansen around here in a while. I'm really, really looking forward to The Boss and I don't even read romance/erotica.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I was utterly frozen in shock at that "your dress is too short, other people must never see your body" part. The abuser subtext (really, just plain text in many places) has been bad all along, but that was just unbelievably blatant and horrifying.
DeleteAlmost as bad was the "relief because he likes the cake" thing. If you're find yourself exhaling in relief because phew, your partner likes the gift you just gave them, now you can stop being terrified about what might happen if they don't like it... get out of the relationship as quickly as can safely be done. Get help and get out.
The music is "Jive Talkin'" by the BeeGees. Or whatever.
ReplyDeleteI recently watched an episode of "the Sopranos" and the wife Carmilla invested $9900 into 4 different accounts, because the bank will notify the FBI if the deposit is over $10g.. I can only assume the writers of the Sopranos know more about US banking than EL James... I'm also lost at the fact that her inner goddess "scissor kicked" herself onto the table!??! I have a hard time picturing that... couldnt she have just said something like "her inner goddess was bent over the table with her ass in the air awaiting him" too explicite for this book perhaps?
ReplyDeleteIf they were at the same bank, that won't work, because the bank is supposed to keep an eye out for such obvious attempts to circumvent the reporting requirements, and make a report anyway. But I'm usually willing to give people a pass on stuff if it looked like they were at least trying to do their research.
DeleteWhen I read the Taylor thing, I never even noticed the denigration of his ex-wife...
ReplyDeleteAll I read was that Taylor was standing next to Christian and he ROLLED HIS EYES... and then my mind just kind of went from there... lol
Just wondering if the whole "and I'm saddened that she would think that of me" isn't about Ana thinking her mom would think she would get married to a guy just because she got pregnant. Like, "I am not going to marry a guy just because I am pregnant with his baby, why would my mom think I would do that? She should know I'd only marry someone I truly love and respect."
ReplyDeleteStill, a weird way to express this... yeah. Stupid book, nothing in it makes sense.
I dunno. That would've made sense if she'd ended her thought with something to that effect. But she followed up with "Oh no, I just remembered MY mom was pregnant when she married my dad...how terrible." And that totally removes any chance that Ana was worried her mum thought they were getting married just because she was pregnant.
DeleteThat's how I read it too, but I doubt EL James has the skill to convey such a complex sentiment.
DeleteLet's consider the entire passage, shall we?
Delete"Disappointment slices through my heart, and I'm saddened that she would think that of me. But then I remember with an ever-sinking feeling that she [Ana's mother] was pregnant when she married my father."
What Ana actually meant was, "I am not going to marry a guy just because I am pregnant with his baby---I'm better than YOU! (Oops, did I say that out loud?)"
Which makes her a holier-than-thou jerk.
Okay, you KNOW romance is being written wrong when it makes the "relationship" in Play Misty For Me look sane. Also, try to give Taylor a teeny bit of credit- It's not *his* fault he was written by EL James!
ReplyDeleteThat's what I'm taking it as: bad writing on EL's part. Just trying to shoehorn in more anti-women bullshit wherever she can fit it. It is NOT a testament of Taylor's character. I love his casual look, too. I hope his jeans were "hanging off his hips in THAT WAY."
DeleteI'm one of those people who loves romantic stories but cannot actually read 99% of romances because the heroes suck so bad. As someone who has been sexually desired and wooed by hot, charismatic, assholes, I really don't see where the attraction is. "Chiseled Features" and a "Rock Hard" chest stay impressive for about a week, tops.
ReplyDeleteI think most romance writers (and especially EL James) need to meet my co-worker. She gushes about her boyfriend in the most glowing terms. She refers to him as "Tall, dark and Dangerous" and "Romance Studmuffin." He is tall and dark, but he is also twice the size the surgeon general would recommend and balding pretty obviously. He works as a stock clerk at a grocery store because all his energy goes into failed garage bands. (He is nearly 50) He currently thinks that he is the reincarnation of John Lennon and tries to look like him and the effect is sort of frightening.
Now he's not a bad person, but romance writers need to know that when they write an asshole for a hero - that's the overall reaction. It doesn't matter how many times they tell us he's hot. It doesn't matter if they say he's loving. They are like my co-worker trying to tell us that he is perfection personified while the rest of the world looks on like Makayla Maroney.
Assholes are not sexually attractive. They do not stay charming. And they do not warm our souls. I keep hearing lamentations on various author's blogs about how the "masses" just are dumbing down and not reading their books. Well, with crap like this being published, why would I? I can read an Ibsen play faster and they're slightly more romantic.
I am very much looking forward to your feminist romance.
I cracked up and laughed out loud for a good long time over that "Your Ass, Not Something You Can Dive Into" picture. Nicely done!
ReplyDeleteI've been looking forward to your recap of this chapter because there is just so much good stuff in here (and by good, I mean awful). I especially liked the part where they talk and talk for hours and it's so wonderful, and yet the example of their "witty banter" is "Thank god for the common cold." "Actually I believe she had the flu, Christian!" LAUGHS ALL AROUND, YOU GUYS! Ana is so clever! These two are going to have years of happiness with riveting conversation like that.
And the short dress (which he bought her) issue with her apologizing for it (when she gets back from the store where she was buying shit to make HIM a goddamn birthday cake). Is there really any doubt in anyone's mind that this guy is an abuser? This is a nice bit of foreshadowing for the next book, though. It gets worse, people.
a) No tumor is very good news. I was like a thresher shark and this blog, the USS Indianapolis.
ReplyDeleteb) Ana is hornswaggled into Chedward's web because his pages don't stick together when she rubs him against her snail trail. Those literary heroes she worships just didn't stand a chance against Mr. Creepster McDouchebaggery.
1- Every time Christian says "you look mighty fine" I imagine him as a toothless gold prospector from like 1910.
ReplyDelete2- I'm choosing to believe that Taylor would not have said that thing about his ex-wife. Maybe Ana imagined it. He's too sexy in those jeans and tight shirt for him to be a jackass. Also why did he and his wife divorce?
3- I Mean, it's not really as if they CAN have a huge wedding. At least not one where the sides are remotely evenly matched. She knows, like, 5 other people in the world. Kate, Jose, Ray, Mom & husband. That's about it, right?
4- I tweeted you this earlier, but maybe the song is "Urban Train" by Tïesto & Kirsty Hawkshaw? It's electronic, female vocals, and there's probably a mix with subway sounds. Plus, I feel like it was somewhat popular in the UK, so maybe. I hope not though.
Your number one reminds me of the conversation I was having with my friend. She said, "Does she (E. L. James) really think that's how we talk?" Then I said it reminded me of Gone With the Wind, and then I wondered if Gone With the Wind was something else we could add to the list of things she has most like ripped off from other stuff.
DeleteAlso I agree wholeheartedly with two. Let's pretend that didn't happen. :(
She'll probably have a Kardashian wedding, except without the divorce five seconds later.
To be fair to EL (and I REALLY hate to be fair to EL "-_-) I've watched a shed load of US films and tv shows that have us saying and doing things that are entirely un-British. These characters are also usually speaking with a super posh RP accent that no one really uses.
DeleteSo... yeah...
EL really should be able to do better regarding your phrases/common expressions though. It's not like we don't get ninety percent of your tv shows over here anyway. She could do most of her research just by turning on the television "-_-
Thirding (fourthing?) the idea that the Taylor/appendicitis thing did not happen. I refuse to accept it. I shall never be canon. Taylor's awesomeness cannot be sullied.
DeleteI can't deny that happens, and it's especially noticeable once you start watching a lot of British TV. My mind's blanking on a blatant example, but I'm sure there is one that will jump out at me five seconds after I post this, haha.
DeleteEven if James didn't watch a lot of US TV I feel like that's something the editor would catch or should have caught, and it's a minor thing to change in the grand scheme of things so why not change it? I mean Harry Potter is set in England and the US publisher completely took out all of the British-isms (which I find lamentable). It's not even that no one in the contemporary US would use that phrase, but I'd expect to hear it in something like True Blood not 50 Shades if you know what I mean (unless Christian is secretly from Louisiana). If the whole thing was better written overall I'd forgive it if it slipped in. It would be nice characterization to show that we're not all coffee junkies and US football fanatics (lol), but after all of the jarring scenes with her inner goddess and all of the "holy crap/*insert holy whatever here*" and everything else it just pops out as something else that is extremely noticeable.
However, if it's supposed to evoke the image of Rhett Butler I could see that. He is kind of a jerk a lot and Scarlett well... she has her issues.
Yeah, I definitely can see some Britishisms slipping by the author or just not knowing that it's not something we'd say in the US. I get that it's hard to pay attention to speaking patterns and then altering them to a different dialect. But the simple fact that she's choosing to set her story here, you'd think she'd be like "Yeah, I'm gonna need to key into how they speak over there." I mean, she's researched all this other ridiculous stuff, but something as paramount as dialogue, which makes up a huge portion of the book, she's pretty much neglected. If you're willing to set a story somewhere outside of your scope, you have to be willing to put in the research (which goes for many aspects of the story, really). At least they're not ending their emails/texts with "Ana x" & "Christian x" (or are they? I'm assuming Jen would have mentioned that).
DeleteI'm glad so many are willing to ignore this ridiculous assault on Taylor's character. Stay strong, ladies. He will be avenged! Hopefully...
She knows Elizabeth, her boss, that black woman in the reception (Claire?), the Claytons aaand uhm.. Troy who sold them the car? Did Elizabeth ever get a surname? If she did, I have *NO* idea what it is. Or what is Roach's first name.
DeleteThe hard spaghetti line made my day. Thank you very much.
ReplyDeletePretty sure it was a Klymaxx song...
ReplyDeleteWow, so many things to comment about in this update!
ReplyDeleteI) So glad you don't have a brain tumour!
II) That swimmer pic was perfect. Ironically, he had a great ass.
III) The blackmail left me speechless. He could have outright raped them and used those pictures (and his social status and expensive lawyers) to completely destroy any attempt to report him. I have no idea how a writer that is so unaware and untalented as EL James can write such convincingly creepy characters. She honestly should ditch romance and go straight for horror. She wouldn't need to change a thing!
IV) The pregnancy thing. Wow. Just wow. I don't even. What the fuck. Seriously. The lack of empathy and the metric tonnes of judgemental bullshit in EL James's writing leave me utterly appalled. Thank you, Jen, for such an eloquent rant. You put my feelings into words with impeccable precision.
V) The dress thing. What. Is that actually a thing. A thing serious adults are seriously squabbling about. Is this even real.
HOORAY for you having a great day and not having a brain tumor and middle school bullies actually growing up to do the right thing and apologizing! YAY!!! I am grateful that, in light of major stuff like that happening, you still have the generosity to bestow recap goodies on us, unpaid and out of the goodness of your heart. Being a bit late is nothing. If I had had this kind of news after two years (!) of living with the thought of having a brain tumor, I'd blow the whole week off.
ReplyDeleteOn the topic of the recap:
"for what seems like the first time ever, they mention being hungry without tacking on, 'but not for food.' "
Oh. my. gawd. Maybe... maybe, through the Power of Luuurve, Ana has cured Chedward of BSDM... and Chedward has cured Ana of her anorexia?!
O.O
Also, I find it ironic that Ana's Power of Lurve cures Chedward selectively of his BDSM kinkiness (potentially totally fine and something to be enjoyed consensually), but leaves his controlling, abusive behavior (definitely a bad thing) intact. It would be creepy enough if the author portrayed the abusiveness/controlling to grow out of his childhood trauma/brokenness (reasonable) and then have Ana fix it by loving him healthy (not reasonable at all), but to have her fix him... by leaving all the actually dysfunctional stuff in place and only "healing" the eeevil kinkyness? ::headshake::
Why do the sex scenes in this book have to be so goddamnn melodramatic every chapter? No, they can't just have fun and enjoy themselves, it has to be overwrought with Narm, especially in this chapter with Christian reciting his version of the marriage vows. I think I was fighting the urge to throw up on myself :P
ReplyDeleteOh, and it makes you feel old to be called 'Mam,' 'at least thirty,' hey Ana? Gee, I'm 25 now, most of my friends are 24 and my eldest friend is gonna be 27 next month, better get ready for The Home... XD
And how can Christian be this 'AHMUUUUUZING' lover when he's always telling Ana she's gonna 'unman' him or fighting the urge to blow his load? The actual sex only seems to last a few sentences anyway in these books, and the way Christian is a nouveau-riche dumbshit with his helicopter and mass of overpriced possessions and gauche Red Room and art gallery house tells me he overcompensates for a lot in his life... XD
You know, I never got that bullshit about children being born out of wedlock, either, so I don't get Ana's puritanical attitude. Why does God care whether someone does, what's gonna happen? Doesn't he have bigger things to worry about? E.L. James, I think your prejudice is showing again...
Great recap! :D
Something else I forgot to mention: "You look fantastic in it, Ana. I just don't want anyone else to see you like that."
DeleteOf course, by Christian's logic, if Ana's wearing a short skirt in public, any man in her vicinity would be unable to help themselves and would just have to fuck her right then and there, and how could she possible resist? >.<
...God, why couldn't Christian have died in that helicopter crash, or at least get stabbed by Taylor or Mrs Jones or something? *dreams*
Thanks for another brilliant update and I'm so pleased that the news about your health is good.
DeleteNow, on to Fifty Shades of Plagiarism. Perhaps I'm reading too much into this but I think that there is a definate touch of another fictional vampire (whom I also loathe as much as Chedward in his various incarnations) in this chapter. The hair brushing and braiding before sex? The "that dress is sexy and you can wear it for me but not out of the house" controlling attitude? Did E L James spend the time between Twilight re-reads reading the Sookie Stackhouse novels because this chapter seriously set off my 'Bill Compton is a Creepy Fucking Douchebag' radar all over again.
Oh yeah and as far as the music goes I cannot imagine Chedward fucking to any Roberta Flack song. "Smack My Bitch Up" by The Prodigy seems much more his style.
Hurray for no brain tumor! Hurray for childhood antagonist acting like an adult. Clapped wildly and loudly for rant! (Please feel free to use my middle fingers)
ReplyDeleteKate finds letter
Ana tell idiot boy
Idiot boy kills Ana & Kate so his secret won't get out.
Taylor druggs Idiot Boy & has anal sex with him before killing him due to Idiot Boy killing Kate.
EL James gets a piano dropped on her by the coyote and the Roadrunner gives us a "Keep Keep" ....end scene.
I honestly can't comprehend how anyone read this book and thought it romantic. The first one, maybe, but 50 Shades of Darker and, particularly this chapter, is deplorable. The first one was bad, but the abuse in this is so amped up and obvious.
ReplyDeleteIgnoring that, I actually think Kate finding out about the sex contract would have been an interesting subplot. It would have tied in completely with Ana and Christian's relationship (making it perfect since that's all E.L. James focuses on) and would have added interesting tension. But, given that this is the penultimate chapter and they get married in the next book, I'm guessing that they explain things to Kate and everything's just howdy doody. And even if it's not, they obviously don't give a shit about Kate, so it wouldn't really matter.
I know it's been mentioned before, but I also find it infuriating how there's this constant "I'm so glad Kate didn't show up at my office" dialogue happening. It adds an uncomfortable undertone for me, because he's not saying "I'm glad we met." He's saying "I'm glad I met you before I met Kate." Which is...creepy. Very, very creepy.
When I read this, "Christian turns to face me as I stand in the middle of the room, my heart pounding, my blood singing in my veins, pulsing - or so it feels - in time to the music's seductive beat.
ReplyDeleteNo... it's really pulsing. Or should be. Otherwise you'd be dead, Ana, and if that were the case I imagined a lot more confetti and party hats would be littering my office. I like that her blood is actually singing, that part is fine, but her blood only feels like it could be pulsing. The metaphor would be fine if she'd just swapped them around. But hey, I'm talking like someone actually cared about the product here..."
The only thing that came to mind was Dick Cheney and his LVAD (and consequent lack of pulse)....let me tell you, that sex scene was way more entertaining when it was between Chedward and Cheney in my mind... lol
3 issues with this chapter:
ReplyDelete1. Ana and Christian have at least a 5-year age gap. While not a big deal for normal people, what is Ana going to do when Christian hits 30 and she's still a spry 25? How will she cope with being married to such an old man?
2. I don't understand how sex photos with one of the world's most famous and rich men can be used as an insurance policy for Christian. Don't a lot of people try to make serious bank on sex photos and tapes with famous people? Especially the kind of people who might seek to get into a kinky relationship with a billionare in the first place? I bet kinky sex photos with billionares would get you famous fast.
3. Um, she made lunch, then went to the store, then baked the cake, and now they're going to a birthday party? Did Ana buy pilsbury cake mix and pre-made icing? Because cakes from scratch take a while to make. About half a day at least if you are trying to make your cake look half-way decent.
As to you're #3, even a box cake takes time. 15 minutes to mix and pre pans etc, an hour to bake and at least 1 hour better if two before you can ice it. Have you ever tried to ice a hot cake. It does NOT work, and there's no way Chedward would approve of the crumbly mess. ELJ canIt even take the 30 seconds it would take to read the back of a box for directions. I do't know why I'm suprised, but it does seem the pointless research she would have indulged in.
DeleteYou're #2, the fame of an entire family rests on a sex tape. You know I'm right, Kardashians. Let's not pretend any of you actually DESERVE the fame and fortune you have. Mephestophiles will be along soon. Sorry Kardashian based PTSD. Anyway, the photos would only work against him, I've spent far too much time thinking about this and I can find no situation in which they would work for him.
Yes, exactly, he makes his subs sign a non-disclosure agreement and is constantly bitching at Ana every time she says something via email that might give away his oh-so-scandalous sex life, and he is planning on showing these pictures to the world if what? They tell the world about his oh-so-scandalous sex life? If Ana had thought about this excuse for even two seconds (assuming she's as smart as everyone keeps telling us she is), she would have seen this for the bullshit it was.
DeleteI typed anastasia steele in Google to see what came. This was the most troubling:
ReplyDeletehttp://au.ibtimes.com/articles/355147/20120622/fifty-shades-grey-anastasia-steele-emma-roberts.htm#.ULcN2uQ048s
Pretty sure this is the worst chapter so far, out of both books. I can't wait to see if anything in book three can top this.
ReplyDeleteIn Taylor's defense, maybe his ex is his ex because she was one of those paranoid, over-reactive ladies that would get scared of any little thing that might happen to her daughter to the point of over-protectiveness, that Taylor had reason to feel annoyed. Because the over-reaction may not only cause him to experience a bad day, but also the daughter, if the mom went "OMG, you have appendicitis!!!!"
ReplyDeleteAnyway, god, this book just gets worse and worse, really, how can people miss the "Your dress is too short, take it off" Later, "Shit, I went out with that dress he explicitly told me not to wear and I'm AFRAID to face him because he's probably pissed." That's control-freakedness slapping you in the face.
About authors complaining about people not reading their stuff, it's sad but true. I noticed that when I used to write fanfiction, I am not saying I am a great writer, but I think I am at least descent, but I never got many hits/reviews, yet the ones that were horribly written and boring, got the most raving reviews, and sometimes I would get reviews asking me about things that I had covered in the story. People don't really read anymore, sadly.
Jennifer, I'm so happy for you regarding your health!! Congrats!! You have a lot of readers that care about you (myself, for sure, included).
ReplyDeleteI have to admit something I haven't told anyone else when discussing these "books". I've grown to actually HATE E.L.James. Not just for how shitty, misogynistic, creepy,...ugh anything negative to describe these "stories", but for how rich and famous she has gotten from them. A seven figure book deal- FOR THESE?!?!?
In the beginning I just disliked her plagarising, unoriginal and badly written "books". Why did it turn into such a negative emotion? At the start of this STUPID phenomenon, she seemed to know just how bad of a writer she truly is and seemed truly humble that people liked them. Since then I've read subsequent interviews and news about her and her ego has evolved to the size of her psychotic leading mans'. Threatening others who fan fic her "characters", saying HER storylines can't be topped...she absolutely disgusts me now.
Add to that the "message" she sends out in these crap "books" and I just lose hope. Women actually love them and these flat as boards characters. I can't wrap my head around it! You've gotten death threats for informing people what the hell they're ACTUALLY reading! Your fuck you to E.L. James made my day today. I thank you for that.
If this crap does get turned into movies, I hope they bomb. I truly do. Hoping for that might be as wasteful as hating this "author" but oh well.
Oh! I couldn't post this earlier as I was on my phone. But re: your 'can trains orgasm?' thing, some people definitely like to think they do. Here's Topless Robot's hilarious commentary on a piece of ridiculous Thomas the Tank Engine erotic fan fiction. Rule 34 and all that, I guess.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.toplessrobot.com/2012/03/fan_fiction_friday_thomas_the_tank_engine_in_tensi.php
'She has this mind-blowing orgasm, which is, by the way, the most selfish birthday present I've ever heard of anyone giving - "For your birthday, you may drive me to heights of pleasure I have never before experienced, you're welcome,"...'
ReplyDeleteThe protagonist of my not-Fifty Shades is also a selfish lover, but at least I recognise that it's a character flaw, borne from a career where Ms. Hand was pretty much her only available sexual partner, and one that causes friction once she's in a relationship. Fifty Shades just seems to revel in the selfishness of both Ana and Christian.
Thank you, THANK YOU, for the whole pregnant before marriage part. I too was pregnant with my son when my husband and I decided to get married and I really resent the implication that we got married because I was pregnant. Like marriage is a punishment for pregnancy. Guess what? This is America. I had options. I didn't have to have a baby from that pregnancy if it wasn't with someone I was planning on spending the rest of my life with anyway.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I thought the exact same thing you did before I read your reaction, which was please call me EL James and explain why I should be ashamed of myself. Really. Hope you're ready for some pretty fucking open dialogue.
Also about the taylor ex wife thing, if it had been "oh my wife overreacted my daughter had just run five miles and had a cramp' it'd be one thing. But assuming appendicitis when your kid has what sounds like a really intense stomach virus is not crazy. Hopefully it was just a cover he came up with on the spot to not tell her his daughter was kidnapped to blackmail christian. That would be better than losing my love for taylor!
ReplyDeleteOf course we know taylor would be busy getting all Taken on us if that were the case
Yay for life going right! I have a friend who, whenever he meets someone who remembers him from summer camp, asks if he owes them an apology. He says they say yes about ten percent of the time. He's a pretty great guy now.
ReplyDelete(I'm just the opposite - I was so socially unaware in middle school that I have to asks my husband who was attempting to bully me.)
Silly me for thinking Chedward might have taken sexy pictures because sexy pictures are fun to take. (Obviously such pictures should have been returned or destroyed, but keeping them is *still* less problematic than planning blackmail from the beginning.) By the way, were they Polaroids? If not, and given James' lack of familiarity with modern technology, do you think he has a film developer who makes house calls? Or maybe Taylor does it. I can see him being good in a darkroom.
Also, whats is his deal about secrecy? Getting outed might be embarrassing, but after the first flurry of headlines people would shrug and get on with life. And he doesn't even have a board of directors to consider firing him.
Also, why would you want to spend your life with someone so unpredictable you can't be sure how they'll react to a birthday cake? Terrible plan.
Also also, how long has his birthday been so far? Does he get two for being rich?
Let me get this straight. If his exes come out and declare that they were in a BDSM relationship with Christian Gray, his fiendish plan is to release evidence supporting their allegations?
ReplyDeleteThat is a shrewd businessman, indeed.
It's the MAD doctrine. The idea isn't to actually use the deterrent, it's to make the other side aware of just how painful it will be for them to make the first move.
Delete"E.L. James, you have gotten on my last fucking nerve. SEX, which your heroine has in abundance, causes PREGNANCY. It's not something to be saddened about. It's biology. I got pregnant with my son before I got married. What does that make me? I'm serious, E.L. James, if you are out there and you ever see this, I DEMAND you explain to me why Ana should be "saddened" that her mom thinks she got pregnant. Look me in the fucking eye and try to claim that what you wrote there doesn't put down women who get pregnant outside of marriage, which, by the by, isn't the prerequisite to bearing a goddamned baby. Sperm. meeting. Egg. is how babies happen and guess what? Your airhead hypocrite insecure misogyny spewing heroine has been having PLENTY of sex. Take your massive lack of writing skill, build an island with it, and take all your little slut-shaming groupies there with you. Leave the rest of the world out of it, because we don't want your landslide of outdated notions further burying us here."
ReplyDeleteI Love you. Thanks so much for this.
There's a short ELJ interview on the BBC website at the moment with their literary correspondent, who obviously hasn't read the books. His question of 'Are these characters based on people you know'? was answered with an embarrassed 'I'm not going to tell you that one,' before an eventual 'there are traits of people that I know in there.' Wait, she seems to have forgotten all about Twilight, and Pretty Woman, and every other book or film she's ripped off - what a surprise. When asked about the process - 'it spilled out of me, I had no idea where it was going, what was happening, no outline, I just went for it.' That explains so much, why subplots go nowhere, why important conversations are glossed over for the next slab of sex. She looked embarrassed to be there, most of the time, and so she bloody well should be.
ReplyDeleteAs someone who was told flippantly by one doctor that I either had one horrible condition or a brain tumor, was given a referral to get tested for which one I had but then had the insurance deny it, paid in full to get tested because I was kind of interested in knowing how many months I had to live (my aunt's sister died a slow death from brain tumors, so this was in no way an abstract fear -- I knew exactly what it would be like if I had one), and then after months of waiting was told that I had NEITHER condition, that there was a third possibility that was annoying, but not even remotely life-threatening and something the first doctor SHOULD HAVE MENTIONED...
ReplyDeleteI feel your elation at being tumor-free. Congratulations.
Also, excellent post, as usual. :)
"I flush... will I ever get used to Taylor calling me Ma'am? It makes me feel so old, at least thirty."
ReplyDeleteI refuse to believe that this was not, in fact, written by a sixteen year old girl.
Too true. After a woman has been spanked, whipped with a belt, thwacked on the clit with a riding crop and enjoyed arse play with a man she has only known a matter of weeks then the only flushing she should be reasonably expected to do is when she's been to the toilet (which is exactly where FSOG belongs).
DeleteI'm glad that ass diving picture could be used more than once, none of it would have been possible without your inspiration. I am glad you don't have a brain tumor. This entry was especially hilarious, I'm sure the people around me thought I was a crazy person who just randomly laughs. Oh well, it was so worth it.
ReplyDeleteI'm with a lot of you; I'm just going to pretend like the whole Taylor thing was a misunderstanding. Why? Well, because I like him and I want to be able to like SOMEONE in this horrendous trilogy. I'm going to assume that his ex-wife is a huge hypochondriac who blows every illness way out of proportion. I've known plenty of people like that and I'm sure I've rolled my eyes when talking about them. The great thing is that we don't know much about Taylor's life so I can make up whatever background story I want!
ReplyDeleteOk so one time I was having sex with a much older, richer man and we did some mildly bondagey things. Ok "one time" should really say "for 3 years" but whatever. Anyway, one night I was bent over a chair with my hands tied behind my back, a vibrator "down there," and him in my ass. At one point I was like "this is starting to hurt" so I TOLD HIM THAT and he said "ok" and STOPPED. And then he told me to suck his dick and I said, "gross, go wash it first because I'm not getting e-coli." AND HE DID. My point here is that I was otherwise submissive to him, and not in a position to physically object if he didn't listen, but we had enough trust and respect for each other (not just me for him since he was, oh jeez, a rich guy) that it was never an issue. I was reminded of that particular night because you didn't mention Chedward washing his butt-covered pinky and ew, but then I just got angrier and angrier thinking about the overarching differences between reality and what EL James wants to portray and god I hate this book so much. Arg.
ReplyDeleteOh, and I didn't say this yesterday because I was raging, but congrats on not having a brain tumor! And it's really nice of that girl to apologize. That sounds like a really brilliant day. Oh, and the dumb and dumber comment made my sides hurt (even though it also made me picture Christian and Ana on a scooter driving through Aspen and Ana peeing her pants. Also, I'm voting of Jeff Daniels and Jim Carrey to be cast in 50 Shades of Grey.)
ReplyDeleteSo anyone seen this yet??
ReplyDeletehttp://movies.msn.com/movies/article.aspx?news=777456
They made a porno of this shit and guess who's suing?
Yep, apparently it's exactly the same as the book, names and all, which makes it theft...but the completely horrible kind that E. L. James would never consider.
Is it just me, or was that sex scene incredibly tame for being the first time back in the playroom?
ReplyDeleteRe scissor kick: I assumed EL James was referring to the kick used by highjumpers to get over the bar. You could also use that to get up onto a high surface without having to clamber. Well, you could if you were fit and flexible.
#1 Crush (Garbage) just shuffled on my iPod... could that be "the mystery song"?
ReplyDeleteAnd Jen, please, please, please review the 50shades porn. Please? You have such a way with sarcasm and your observations are always a pleasure to read.
Also: I want a Bride of the Wolf movie dammit (or Infernal Devices. Whichever.)
Two things:
ReplyDelete1) I don't buy the whole "this butt plug is too big". The first time I had anal anything, was full on anal sex. Granted my boyfriend at the time was a bit on the small side, but he was bigger than most anal plugs I've used since. I know there are some a big as Shaq's dick, but somehow I don't think Ana would grab that frightening monster.
2) I'm a big fan of post WWI mysteries and have just finished reading All of Dorothy L. Sayers stories. I've been watching Lord Peter Wimsey movies and the characters are lending together for me in a very disturbing way. Lord Peter is a very rich ginger peer of the realm (Christian), Harriet is a darkhaired slender girl who's a bit socially akward (Ana) and there's Bunter Peter's valet can and does do everything for Peter ( Taylor). Now everytime I read a sex scene in these books or recaps, Christian is wearing a monocle and saying shit like "frabjous day, kaloo kalay. I just came what." And I expect Taylor to come in and say "Will there be anything else, my lord?" My head is a very scary place to be.
God! Did anyone see this: http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/authors/profiles/article/54948-e-l-james-named-pw-s-publishing-person-of-the-year.html?utm_source=Publishers+Weekly%27s+PW+Daily&utm_campaign=6658ff1402-UA-15906914-1&utm_medium=email
ReplyDeleteI just... I quit.
To learn about narcissism, it's always good to go to a qualified source (haha!)
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zgQrllDie10
I think that Sam Vaknin describes this relationship quite well in his exposition of narcissists in relationship....
"E.L. James, you have gotten on my last fucking nerve. SEX, which your heroine has in abundance, causes PREGNANCY. It's not something to be saddened about. It's biology. I got pregnant with my son before I got married. What does that make me? I'm serious, E.L. James, if you are out there and you ever see this, I DEMAND you explain to me why Ana should be "saddened" that her mom thinks she got pregnant. Look me in the fucking eye and try to claim that what you wrote there doesn't put down women who get pregnant outside of marriage, which, by the by, isn't the prerequisite to bearing a goddamned baby. Sperm. meeting. Egg. is how babies happen and guess what? Your airhead hypocrite insecure misogyny spewing heroine has been having PLENTY of sex. Take your massive lack of writing skill, build an island with it, and take all your little slut-shaming groupies there with you. Leave the rest of the world out of it, because we don't want your landslide of outdated notions further burying us here."
ReplyDeleteAMEN
*giggling*
ReplyDeleteI you think Christian is sexist HERE, wait till the third book. Because yes, it can get worse, as implausible as it may seem.
Whew, after two weeks of reading your recaps, starting with the first book, I am finally up to date. So many times I didn't know whether to laugh or to cry (but thanks to your fantastic sense of humour, Jen, usually the first won). I found this blog when I searched the internet after I came across a copy of FSOG in a second-hand bookstore. I leafed trough it, wanting to know what all the fuss was about, and of course, I skipped right through to the first sex scene, which I have to say I didn't find THAT awful (although granted, my brain may be befuddled from lack of sex. Even a picture of a bare-chested Robert Pattinson gets me hard these days. Ouch.) The rest of the writing though, even on skimming through, seemed to be so awful, and the whole setup so far-fetched, that I wanted to do some research before even spending $ 10 on a second-hand copy. And THANK THE UNIVERSE I found this blog. The rest is history, as they say...
ReplyDeleteOne realisation that crept up on me though, while reading through the subsequent blog posts, is the following. (However hard to admit it is, because like the rest of you, I have a genuine desire to put E.L. James's head through a wall at this point.) But rather than being angry at her, shouldn't we be thankful that her awful writings lay bare all these fundamental underlying problems in our society? The monstrosity (calling it 'book' does it too much honour, IMHO) is popular for a reason. And maybe we have to search our own conscience here too. Although no one in their right mind would want to (and should) identify with Ana, how many of you have stayed for too long in a dysfunctional relationship JUST BECAUSE THE SEX WAS MIND-BLOWING?? I, for one, have. Thank god it wasn't as dysfunctional as the shit these two like to call a relationship, but still. (And true, from the recaps the sex sounds pretty repetitive to me, but hey, she hasn't got anything to compare it with.)
Anyway, what I want to say is that yes, although it shouldn't and maybe many people will deny it, great stuff in the bedroom DOES I believe for the majority of women make up for a lot of shitty stuff elsewhere. And I think that's one of the underlying problems that the popularity of this series brings to light.
Just throwing my pebble on the beach... Thanks Jen, for this awesome ride, and saving so many of us. And great to hear you are safe and sound.
http://imgur.com/gallery/D0Azh This belongs here I think? :)
ReplyDeleteJen, I absolutely LOVE these recaps and as a music nut I knew exactly what song she was describing. It "The City Never Sleeps" by the Eurythmics, which of course was used in 9 1/2 Weeks.
ReplyDeleteUgh, sorry for the grammar and typos.
DeleteAbout the pregnancy thing:
ReplyDelete1) Shocked because she didn't think Ana wanted to be pregnant and is expressing empathy for what happened?
2) Feeling pity because she didn't think Ana would feel she had to get married just because she was pregnant?
- Nah, I am probably waaaaay too generous here.
I'm sitting here trying to figure out how the doctor mistook your thyroid for your pituitary.... the pituitary gland is in your brain, the thyroid gland is in your throat. Where the hell did he go to med school? Either way, I'm very happy you don't have a brain tumor. The world would be a lot suckier place if you weren't in it.
ReplyDeletePS: I just snorted chili through my nose. It fucking hurts. All your fault.