Go To These Places!

Thursday, June 21, 2012

50 Shades of Grey Chapter 24 recap or "Bonus post because I can't count!"

You're getting a bonus post today, because I'm incapable of counting. I thought, "I'll write the recaps one a day, keeping a day ahead, and working in this fashion the last recap will post on the first day of my vacation, and I will be done!" Except math. So, here's a post to catch me back up to my brilliant plan.
Christian stands in a steel-barred cage. Wearing his soft, ripped jeans, his chest and feet are mouthwateringly naked, and he's staring at me. His private-joke smile etched on his beautiful face and his eyes a molten grey. In his hands he holds a bowl of strawberries.
Because an apple would be too obvious.
He ambles with athletic grace to the front of the cage, gazing intently at me. Holding up a plump ripe strawberry, he extends his hand through the bars.
"Eat," he says, his tongue caressing the front of his palate as he enunciates the 't'.
Jeez, even in her dreams he's obsessed with her eating. She wants to go to him and eat the damn strawberry, but something holds her back, and he keeps telling her to eat, because that's just how things work with him, and then the real Christian is waking her up.

It is literally the middle of the night, and Christian is all dressed in black. He tells Ana he wants to "chase the dawn" with her, which sounds like drug talk if I ever heard it. Ana asks if she can take a shower before they go out. Of course she can't!
"If you have a shower, I'll want one with you, and you and I know what will happen then - the day will just go. Come."
Or, and here is an novel thought, you could control your own desires for a second and let Ana take a damn shower, since she's been bleeding all over herself and the hotel sheets all night long. Christian has laid out a fresh pair of his own Ralph Lauren underpants for Ana:
 I shake my head at his lar-gesse, and I frown as a scene from Tess crosses my mind: the strawberry scene. It evokes my dream. To hell with Dr. Flynn - Freud would have a field day - and then he'd probably expire trying to deal with Fifty Shades.
Freud and I have that in common. Don't you just love it when an author not only weaves a particular motif though a book, but also makes the text scream in your face, "THIS IS A REFERENCE TO A LITERARY CLASSIC LOOK HOW SMART I AM!" when you read it? I particularly enjoy that.

When Ana is done doing her bathroom things, she comes out to find Christian eating breakfast. And of course, he wants her to eat, too:
"Eat," he says.
Holy Moses... my dream. I gape at him, thinking about his tongue on his palate. Hmm, his expert tongue.
I don't think we can attribute him telling her to eat specifically to her dream. More likely, we can attribute dream-Chedward telling her to eat to real-Chedward constantly doing so whenever they're in the presence of any kind of food.
It really is too early for me. How to handle this?
"I'm not hungry because it's too early in the morning." That should work, right? Oh, wait, no, it won't work, because your boyfriend is a sociopath.
"I'll have some tea. Can I take a croissant for later?" He eyes me suspiciously, and I smile very sweetly.
 "Don't rain on my parade, Anastasia," he warns softly.
Ana teases him about spanking, and then she gets all swoony because Christian has Twinings Breakfast Tea on the table, which means he really cares. Would pointing out that Twinings is a popular brand for hotels to carry destroy the romantic fantasy here? After non-breakfast, Christian takes Ana outside, where a valet is waiting with a soft-top convertible, and Christian says, "'You know, sometimes it's great being me.'"
This guy. This fucking guy.

In the car, they listen to some La Traviata, but Ana doesn't want to listen to music about a "'doomed courtesan,'" so Christian invites her to scroll through his iPod to find something she likes better. Every time they talk about music, Christian makes me think that he's one of those people who doesn't actually listen to what he likes, but what he thinks will make people find him smart or cool. Now, I'm not saying no young people like opera. I love opera, and did even before I reached the Anastasia Steele benchmark for geriatric hopelessness, otherwise known as "thirty." However, Christian always smirks when he's discussing music, and it's always some song that echoes what's going on in their relationship. Or it's a piece that Ana isn't familiar with, so she has to ask him about it, and he gets to look super smart. "Oh, you've never heard Thomas Tallis? He's only the greatest Tudor-era composer. I can't believe you've never heard him."

This is my favorite hipster macro EVER.

Because Chedward is such a fucking pretentious hipster about his musical choices, it makes it that much funnier when Ana scrolls through his iPod and finds Britney fucking Spears, "Toxic," on there. I'm sure it's just there ironically. Because Ana and Christian can't talk like normal humans, she assumes his choice of La Traviata (which spellcheck keeps trying to change to La Travolta, which is an entirely different opera altogether, wherein Danny marries Sandy as his beard and gets thrice weekly massages from young men desperate to break into Hollywood) is a comment on their relationship, and chooses "Toxic" as her comment on it. Talking is too mainstream.
He turns the music down a little more, and inside I am hugging myself. My inner goddess is standing on the podium awaiting her gold medal. He turned the music down.
Victory!
You probably could have just turned the music down, yourself. There's a little knob on the car stereo that does that. If it was too difficult to pull off, you could have just asked.
"I didn't put that song on my iPod," he says casually, and puts his foot down so that I am thrown back into my seat as the car accelerates along the freeway.
Oooh, he's all mad because you found his secret, decidedly unhipster Britney cache! Are you new here, Chedward? Just say you only put it on there "ironically" or to test people who use your iPod. That will show her for making you feel uncool.
What? He knows what he's doing, the bastard. Who did? And I have to listen to Britney going on and on. Who... who?
Is there some reason you can't change the song, Ana? Seriously, for two people in their twenties, they're acting like middle schoolers. The next song that comes on is Damien Rice, so we know that we've downshifted into serious time.
"It was Leila," he answers my unspoken thoughts. How does he do that?
"Leila?"
"An ex, who put the song on my iPod."
Here is another thing that bothers me about this book. Needless dialogue. If Ana already knows the question in her head, why does she ask, "'Leila?'" like she has no idea what he's referring to? Save the reader some damn time. All of us, Ana, Christian, the reader, we all know that he's saying Leila put the song on his iPod.

As it turns out, Leila was a former submissive who wanted more from Christian, so he broke up with her. He tells Ana that he's never wanted more with a sub, except for her, and then Ana's inner goddess does more spastic shit. Ana asks what happened to the rest of his subs, and he tells her that he's only been in four long-term relationships, not counting Mrs. Robinson, whose real name is Elena.
Elena! Holy Fuck. The evil one has a name and its all-foreign sounding. A vision of a glorious, pale skinned vamp with raven hair and ruby-red lips comes to mind, and I know that she's beautiful. I must not dwell. I must not dwell.
How is that working for you, Ana? I love that she thinks "Elena" is a foreign name. Ana is so bizarrely xenophobic. At dinner with Christian's parents, she uses "European" as an insulting way to describe their housekeeper. Now she's thinking "Elena" sounds foreign. Elena doesn't sound blonde, though, thank God. I wonder if this isn't a little bit of the stereotypical "I'm not a part of Europe!" attitude you hear from some British people leaking into the text. I mean, Ana even shoots down the idea of going to Paris because she would rather go to London. The pieces are suddenly falling into place here. The funny thing is, people in the United States don't think of England as a piece separate from Europe, we think of it as a European country, so that attitude is all wrong on an American heroine. Unless she's one of those obnoxious Anglophiles who prances around with a fake accent and talks about how they only watch British television.


Okay, I have a little of that, but it extends only to Top Gear, and that's because our version of Top Gear is balls awful.

They talk a little bit more about his past girlfriends, and Ana brings up that someday she wants kids, which doesn't sit great with Christian. They are driving to an airfield, where Christian wants to show her his second favorite pastime, gliding. They get to the airfield, and Taylor is there, and so is the tow pilot, who Ana can tell is British from his accent. If you're South African, Australian, Irish, Kiwi, or Scottish, you are probably laughing your ass off right now, because you know that most Americans default to "British" upon hearing any kind of even remotely similar accent.

I'm going to skip most of the scene with the gliding, because it reads like a procedural straight from How To Go on a Glider. Basically, Christian likes strapping Ana into her parachute, and then into her seat harness (because he's into BDSM, get it?!), and then they get up in the air.
The light is extraordinary, diffuse and warm in hue, and I remember Jose rambling on about 'magic hour', a time of day that photographers adore - this is it... just after dawn, and I'm in it, with Christian.
Abruptly, I'm reminded of Jose's show. Hmm. I need to tell Christian.
I think you should definitely do that while he's piloting an engineless light aircraft that could easily have some kind of accident. Tell him right now.
The plane banks and turns as the wing dips, and we spiral toward the sun. Icarus. This is it. I am flying close to the sun, but he's with me, leading me. I gasp at the realization.
First of all, Ana:


Second, you just realized he was there?

Christian lets Ana pilot the glider, and then when they land, he asks her:
"Was it more?" he asks, his voice tinged with hope.
"Much more," I breathe, and he grins.
But it wasn't, was it? It wasn't emotional trust or true intimacy. It was piloting a glider.

After their gliding adventure, they go to IHOP. Yes. International House of Pancakes. And proximity to greasy, overpriced menu items gets both of them all hot.
Oh, I want to run my hands through that hair. I pick up a menu and examine it. I realize I'm starving.
"I know what I want," he breathes, his voice low and husky.
I glance up at him, and he's staring at me in that way that tightens all the muscles in my belly and takes my breath away, his eyes dark and smoldering. Holy shit. I gaze at him, my blood singing in my veins answering his call.
"I want what you want," I whisper.
He inhales sharply.
"Here?" he asks suggestively, raising an eyebrow at me, smiling wickedly, his teeth trapping the tip of his tongue. 
Oh please. Stop. I'm not sure if I can take the unbridled eroticism of this moment. Seriously, I cannot wait to see the promotional tie-in for this one. "The Rooty Tooty Fresh n' Fruity Buttermilk Ben Wa Pancake Stack?" With "Lingering Gaze" ligon berry sauce? You wouldn't even have to change the name of the stuffed french toast, that already sounds dirty enough. Of course, it's French, so we'd have to probably change that, or it will steal Ana's boyfriend.

 Kids and Adults with child-like sexuality eat free!

Their waitress shows up, and she flushes just as much as Ana does when she sees Christian. She's a redhead, and Ana shows surprising neutrality toward her. I guess she only cares when blondes and people with black hair and foreign names flirt with him, gingers are G2G. Then Ana and Christian talk to each other about how they both disarm each other, and Ana asks if that's why Christian has changed his mind about their arrangement.
"I don't think I've changed my mind per se. We just need to re-define our parameters, re-draw our battle lines, if you will. We can make this work, I'm sure. I want you submissive in my playroom. I will punish you if you digress from the rules. Other than that... well, I think it's all up for discussion. Those are my requirements, Miss Steele. What say you to that?"
We all know what Ana is going to say to that. Their breakfast arrives, and then they have this charming exchange:
"Can I treat you?" I ask Christian.
"Treat me how?"
"Pay for this meal."
Christian snorts.
"I don't think so," he scoffs.
"Please. I want to."
He frowns at me.
"Are you trying to completely emasculate me?"
This. Fucking. Guy.

I'm not even going to get into how awful that statement is, because either you recognize what is wrong with it, or you're a time traveler from the 1950's who stumbled, confused, upon my blog and are probably wondering why my husband allows me to read.

Christian takes Ana back to her mother's house - without asking for directions, because he already knows where she lives. I'm not kidding, Ana even says as much:
Of course he doesn't ask me for my mother's address. He knows it already, stalker that he is. When he pulls up outside the house, I don't comment. What's the point?
That' right, Ana! You march straight into that relationship in which your feelings don't matter. At least you're doing it with somewhat open eyes. Ana asks him to come in. I half expect him to say, "I've already been there, while you were sleeping," but instead he turns her down:
"I need to work, Anastasia, but I'll be back this evening. What time?" I ignore the unwelcome stab of disappointment. Why do I want to spend every single minute with this controlling sex god? Oh yes, I've fallen in love with him, and he can fly.
He can't really fly, though, can he? He has to use a vehicle.

 Say what you will about Supes, but he doesn't need a helicopter. And his ice cream is fantastic.

Ana goes inside to find her mom cleaning obsessively, and Ana offers to cook dinner, which her mom turns down.
Perhaps she's improved since she moved to Savannah with Bob. There was a time I wouldn't subject anyone to her cooking... even - who do I hate? Oh yes - Mrs. Robinson - Elena. Well, maybe he. Will I ever meet this damned woman?
Back up there, Ana. You've known Christian for all of what, three weeks? And you're impatient because he hasn't introduced you to his ex-girlfriends? Now who's a controlling stalker?

Ana emails Christian (because they have been apart maybe ten minutes) and during the exchange he tells her that she talks in her sleep.
Supposing I've said I hate him, or worse still, that I love him, in my sleep. Oh, I hope not. I am not ready to tell him that, and I'm sure he's not ready to hear it, if he ever wants to hear it.
That actually happened to me, once. I was occasionally sleeping with this guy, totally casual, and one night when I stayed over I had a dream that I got to meet Paul McCartney. Apparently I sat up and yelled, "I love you!" and then went back to sleep. That... took some explaining.

Greatest hits: "Hey Jude," "Live and Let Die," "Ruining Jen's sex life"

Ana goes to the supermarket with her mom, where she gets a phone call from SIP, offering her an assistant's job to Mr. Jack Hyde.

I need you to be fucking honest with me here, readers. I wasn't going to read the second book. But I have this feeling there is going to be some kind of sexual tension between her and Jack Hyde, based on her meeting with him in this book. If there is, if you've read book two, let me know, and I'll fucking read it. But if you lie to me, I will find you like the goddamned Repo Man and I will gut you. Also like the Repo Man.

This one, not Jude Law. That is the Rip Off man.

Ana's mom is thrilled that her daughter is an employed college grad. Too thrilled, for Ana's tastes:
"Congratulations, darling! We have to buy some champagne!" She's clapping her hands and jumping up and down. Is she forty-two or twelve?
Maybe she's your inner goddess, Ana.


Ana sees a missed call on her phone from Christian. Ana calls him back, and he tells her that a situation has come up and he has to fly back to Seattle immediately. He won't be able to have dinner.
Oh no. The last 'situation' he had was my virginity. Jeez I hope it's nothing like that.
Yup, that's exactly what it is, Ana. Your hymen grew back. Only, something went... wrong. And now it has engulfed all of Seattle.

Later that night, she remembers that Christian had dinner with Elena. I call bullshit, as I'm sure that has been on her mind all damn day. They email back and forth again, he still doesn't tell her what she said in her sleep (Spoiler alert: it was "I love you, Paul McCartney") and the chapter ends.

68 comments:

  1. There is a lot of Jack Hyde sexual tension in book #2

    ReplyDelete
  2. The talking during sleep thing is actually kinda funny. I do that. One night I woke up and told my (now ex) boyfriend that I wanted to go to panera bread for lunch. And then I rolled over and went back to sleep. Whew, glad I didn't say anything too much of substance.

    I haven't read the second book but I have my fingers crossed it does!!! What type of name is Jack Hyde... Like Jekyll and Hyde? Idk

    ReplyDelete
  3. How do I know you're not Mean!Anon trying to trick me, Anon?!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Did you book two yet?? There is sexual tension caused by Jack Hyde. Please read it and blog about it. You are hilarious. Oh and if you haven't seen it yet, Google the 50 shades board game.

      Delete
  4. Thank you so much for the extra post, I love them! And I'd just like to apologise, on behalf of the British people, for unleashing this rubbish (the book that is, not your blog, which is wonderful!) on the world. But then, in our defence, you did give Stephanie Myers to the world. So I guess we're even! I looked up EL whosit in wikipedia, hoping she'd turn out to be an Aussie or something. But sadly no.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is true, there is Jack Hyde tension/triangle in book #2. Also, a lot more Mrs. Robinson. So, what is that a love rectangle? Plus Jose = a love hexagon.

    Fantastic recap, as always!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Is Jack Hyde patterned after E. Edward Grey in Secretary and bends her over his desk and spanks her when she makes too many typos?

    Because duelling doms would be totally hilarous!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jack Hyde tension turns into Jack Hyde towering inferno.

    Ana and Christian become far more likeable characters by the end of book 2. Yes, really.

    Book 3 is meandering and so horribly written that it was very difficult to follow. Constantly switching between flashbacks and present with zero warning. A nightmare.

    ReplyDelete
  8. "La Travolta, which is an entirely different opera altogether, wherein Danny marries Sandy as his beard and gets thrice weekly massages from young men desperate to break into Hollywood."

    WRITE. THIS. NOW.

    ReplyDelete
  9. As another Brit, I'd like to add that Elena is not a foreign name, however it is pronounced (either like Eleanor as in Eleanor Rigby or Elaina, like... someone called Elaina). The spelling is more south/ east European but you wouldn't know that if it was said out loud. Add Robinson and well...

    I'm so glad I found you reading this. It has been very cathartic. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Two things:

    1) I love you so much more now that we share a strange obsession with British Top Gear - the only true Top Gear.

    2) Why does Giles look so angry!?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Do book two, pleaaaaase please do book two. PRETTY PRETTY PLEASE!

    ReplyDelete
  12. There have been so many spit takes as I read your recaps that I have to keep my drink on another table. Thank you so much for doing this. The world loves you.

    ReplyDelete
  13. A Scottish accent is a type of British accent. I think you meant to say 'English' there. Some Northern Irish accents would count as British too. Sorry, but it's irritating when British and English are treated as synonyms.

    Apart from that, your reviews are hilarious and make the existence of this godawful book more bearable.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "so is the tow pilot, who Ana can tell is British from his accent. If you're South African, Australian, Irish, Kiwi, or Scottish, you are probably laughing your ass off right now, because you know that most Americans default to "British" upon hearing any kind of even remotely similar accent."

      Yes, that shit was annoying me. Beginning to wonder if you've got some sort of xenophobic thing going on actually.

      Scottish = British
      N Irish = British
      Welsh = British
      English = British

      Delete
  14. I actually pride myself on being able to tell the difference between the accents of English-speaking countries. I think people from Australia sound completely different from people from New Zealand, and so on and so forth. Perhaps I just pay more attention....

    ReplyDelete
  15. I just read all your chapter reviews (and have been reading with friends, sending awesome quotes back and forth to one another).

    There is definitely only one true Top Gear. The Aussie one sucks balls too.

    And Anthony Stewart Head as the Repo Man is awesome. I must watch that tonight now.

    I can't wait for the conclusion to this! But unfortunately, I've also decided I really need to read the book, because you've convinced my I probably wont like it but I have a whole "You need to actually have read/done something so you can comment on it accurately"

    Looking forward to the conclusion, not so much looking forwards to actually reading the books them self.

    ReplyDelete
  16. "Wearing his soft, ripped jeans, his chest and feet are mouthwateringly naked, and he's staring at me. His private-joke smile etched on his beautiful face and his eyes a molten grey."

    His chest and feet are simultaneously wearing the jeans AND naked? E.L. has time for multiple adjectives per noun, but not for a verb?

    Now, I understand that everyone hates a Monday morning quarterback...but REALLY? I sincerely hope the "editor" of this book finds a special place in purgatory where he has to read this book over and over and over while the syntax worsens each time.

    Thank you for giving me a safe place where I can vent and find sanity. My "friends" drank the kool-aid and cannot hear criticism of Grey.

    (Oh and props for suggesting "ridiculously photogenic guy for Grey. Save the Thor!)

    ReplyDelete
  17. The second book is better...alot more romantic and Christian is less crazy.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Not only is there major Jack Hyde sexual tension in book 2, it continues into book 3 where shit really hits the fan and gets all kinds of fucked up.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Also, don't listen to the Anon. poster above me. There's nothing at all romantic about Chedward in the last two books. It's just more manipulation and less whips and chains.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I read book one and admittedly I am a skimmer. I get the jist without the meat; so to speak. Then I read your blog. I started reading book 2 and I've never noticed so much abusive innuendo in my life. I've gotten to the point I have to read a few chapters and then read a decent book as a palate cleanser. I love your writing style but more than that, thank you for showing me what utter shit these books are.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I promise you, book 2 is definitely more bearable than book 1. Though that might not be saying much...

    ReplyDelete
  22. "Yup, that's exactly what it is, Ana. Your hymen grew back. Only, something went... wrong. And now it has engulfed all of Seattle." made me snort some water over my keyboard.

    Now I feel bad for not having read any of these books, otherwise I'd totally tell you there was a lot of sexual tension going on between Jack Hyde and Ana in book two. Totally.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That was my favorite part! Then I started wondering what a galactic wily he'd need to destroy that and the realization hit me why the story was originally called Master of the Universe...

      Delete
  23. James missed her calling. Should have entered that Bullwer-Lytton contest. But perhaps there were so many sentences to choose from she just couldn't select one?

    ReplyDelete
  24. James missed her calling. She should have entered the Bullwer-Lytton contest for the worst written sentence of the year. But I suppose there were so many sentences to choose from she just couldn't make up her mind which one to, uh, submit.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I have not read book 2. I've only skimmed it, but my inner goddess does solemnly swear that whatever you want to be in book 2 is in book 2 and so, you should start reading it IMMEDIATELY.  

    "This guy. This fucking guy." - I shall never tire of this ever. I lawl every single time, because seriously you guys. Seriously. You guys. Seriously. This fucking guy. 

    All my "friends" are obsessed with this godforsaken POS "series". I've unsubscribed from many of them on FB, because if I see one more status or picture worshipping that fucking guy, I am gonna flip my shit and burn some bridges.

    I've especially been having a hard time coming to terms with the fact that my most beloved BFF has read and enjoyed all 3 books.. I just. I dunno. It's like the magic is gone and she just doesn't dazzle me as she once did.

    This blog is my silent support group and so, should you not continue on to books 2 & 3 (which you totally should, cuz whatever you want in them is so totally in them I bet), thanks for the comic relief. 

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Personally, I posted links to several articles tearing these books to shreds along with comments like "You need to re-evaluate your life choices if you read this book and want a Christian Grey of your own". That's done a pretty good job at keeping the crazy off my timeline, lol.

      Delete
  26. This amuses me! http://www.sinfest.net/archive_page.php?comicID=4307

    How to make Fifty Shades a MUCH better book!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hi, your blog really touches me, have been reading it for a while... Just wanted you to know about a website i started ReadYourBiblesChurch.com... It's a place for Bible study guides.. I also put a forum in that can be viewed from a mobile device.. I couldn't find where to contact you privately so I'm commenting, hope that is okay. :) God Bless! Jenn.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I just started the third book and it's Making me ill. Sorry to spoil but their relationship is more serious yet Ched is treating her worse and she's loving it even more. There is actually a part where he tells her to not pee before sex. It seems some sex trick that the author heard about and decided to randomly include in their relationship in the third book. After being together for how long? He's only now not letting her pee before sex.

    ReplyDelete
  29. :( My name is Lela and now there's a Leila!? I bet she's blonde, too. My feelings are hurt. Now this shit is PERSONAL

    ReplyDelete
  30. Although I wish you would recap books 2 & 3 (i'm struggling through the third), I do find myself laughing out loud at confusingly wordy sentences or sentences that accidentally personify inanimate objects. (sorry, that was a wordy sentence right there). Thanks for setting an example to all of us who started the series and are now pissed that we have to finish it! We can now continue to read while finding humor in it too! Although I still feel rage while readin most of it..

    ReplyDelete
  31. Oh hell yeah ... go for it. If you can stomach book 1, then you gotta read book 2 and 3. After all, this shit isn't getting any better ... and the other two are just as silly.

    I'm in the somewhat middle of book 3 and I actually just had to close it and walk away. He has bullied her into taking his name and I just can't swallow anymore today.

    Question ... I just found your blog and I LURVE it ... so this maybe have already been discussed in a previous post. So, this book was originally a Twilight FanFiction, right? And in order to publish it she changed the names and a few details.

    But is anybody else reading this seeing conversations or situations that you KNOW she meant for Edward/Bella? I mean from the get go with the whole "Call me Ana" thing ... that's a direct nod to the "Call me Bella" thing. And Jose is obviously Jacob ... even uses the same initial. Kate I'm assuming is Rosalie? Tall and beautiful? Mia would be Alice? I mean it's like you could make a flow chart that would EXACTLY match characters. Ugh ...

    In any case ... yes. Read it. Jack Hyde is never a "threat" to Christian's stalker love ... but he certainly tries.

    ReplyDelete
  32. this is beautiful. I'm so happy I don't really have to read the book now!

    ReplyDelete
  33. I love that she thinks "Elena" is a foreign name.

    I wonder if it's a coincidence that the evill one has the same name as Bella's superior counterpart in the Vampire Diaries.

    ReplyDelete
  34. (Somewhat spoilerific) About your question regarding Jack Hyde I can only say that his "original" Master of the universe name was James, so if you know who James was in Twilight, that's all you need to deduce what function plot-wise he'll have in book 2 and 3.
    And if Elena sounds foreign, that's because her "original" twilight universe name was Irina.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for that! I had been wondering who Mrs. Robinson was supposed to be and Irina (sort of) makes sense.
      I still can imagine how is it that Rosalie and Bella are BFF (of sorts) when Rosalie hates Bella with all her heart.

      Delete
  35. "Of course, it's French, so we'd have to probably change that, or it will steal Ana's boyfriend."

    Pow!

    Perfect.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Just a note: Since it's in Savannah (and really anywhere in Georgia as well as most of the Deep South), they're going to be at a Waffle House and not an IHOP.

    Granted, there are a few IHOPs scattered hither and yon (including apparently a couple in Savannah).

    But Waffle House is so freaking ubiquitous across the South that it's almost like Starbucks in major cities - where you have them across the freeway from one another.

    Anyway, if she was going for authenticity, she'd have plopped them into a Waffle House.

    ReplyDelete
  37. I will never look at an IHOP commercial the same way ever again! I nearly choked on my sandwich reading that part! Brilliant!

    ~Roni Lynne

    ReplyDelete
  38. Well, let me join those confirming that yes, there will be more of Jack Hyde in the sequels.

    Let's just say that his name is very obvious.

    *SPOILER*



    AKA he turns into anmoustache-twirling villain. And a very crappy one at that. Whose motives get altered as it suits the plot.

    Sexual tension, though, is one-sided and then completely dismissed.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Does anyone else not consider the name "Elena" to be exotic? My RA in college has French parents and they named her Lourdes and she eventually had to go by her middle name Elena because Lourdes was too confusing in elementary school or something. So to me Elena is totes not "exotic." And come on, Anastasia?!? Not "exotic" at all..

    Also, yes! There is Mr. Hyde (from what I've read on Jezebel comments) And at one point pregnancy is involved but not sure if its book 2 or 3 since I'm relying on you to read these things for me.

    ReplyDelete
  40. i cried out with joy over your Repo/Jude Law ripoff comment because I so agree!

    also i am so in love with you for these recaps, oh my gosh.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Ahh! I've been reading all of these and I love them so much. I finally could no longer resist commenting!

    I'm still laughing at The Rooty Tooty Fresh n' Fruity Buttermilk Ben Wa Pancake Stack

    PS - I wish there were more Dark Knight references so I could see more pics of Abed!

    ReplyDelete
  42. Lots of Jack Hyde in book 2 and 3!!!! Read both and do reviews!!!!!! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  43. "Your hymen grew back. Only, something went... wrong. And now it has engulfed all of Seattle."

    Oh my God, now I have this image of Chedward standing on top of the Space Needle taking off his shirt and saying "I'll handle this!"

    Also, there's some sort of pulsing golden light in his pants that's only partially contained by the fly.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I can't remember who Irina is in Twilight. Shows just how much I LOVED Twilight. I don't remember characters.

    Jack Hyde is in the last two novels more and more. He's a major part of the last book and the big action at the end; although, it seems like James just kind of throws him around like she wants to, never thinking about how anything would actually make sense. I kept thinking something would wrap everything up in a neat little package at the end, but it was a totally messily wrapped package, with bits falling out at the sides. I was unimpressed.

    ReplyDelete
  45. "Maybe she's your inner goddess, Ana."

    Touché. God I hate her inner goddess and I haven't even read the book.

    Also I know everyone including Wikipedia is insisting that she's British but ever since I read that she named a character Anastasia, dresses her up in tight Eastern European outfits and seems to believe that macho oligarcs who has private plans and hits women is some kind of ideal, I can't escape my original notion of her being Russian (sorry normal Russian people!). That would also make her a non English native (like me) and perhaps explain the constant need to overcompensate with a Thesaurus...

    ReplyDelete
  46. Is she forty-two or twelve?

    Maybe she's your inner goddess, Ana.


    And with this you win the internet.

    ReplyDelete
  47. @JennyJen: "I've especially been having a hard time coming to terms with the fact that my most beloved BFF has read and enjoyed all 3 books.. I just. I dunno. It's like the magic is gone and she just doesn't dazzle me as she once did."

    I am going through the exact same thing. My best friend of the last 25 years LOVES these books. I am trying to come to terms with it. It may have tainted our friendship forever.

    ReplyDelete
  48. LOL Jen, Mrs. Robinson is actually blonde!!

    I wouldn't say there's sexual chemistry between Jack Hyde and Ana. I would say it's more like Jack Hyde wants to nail her, while Ana only thinks about Christian and ignoring her instincts that this Jack guy is more of a creeper than Chedward. At least Chedward was open about his creepiness lol!

    ReplyDelete
  49. There's lots of Jack Hyde in books 2 & 3. Hyde's character is just as creepy as Chedward but because he doesn't make Ana pool "down there" he is no competition for our favourite megalomaniac.
    His character and motivation is so badly thought out (I'm assuming that there was at least some thought involved) it's ridiculous.

    ReplyDelete
  50. "Eat," he says, his tongue caressing the front of his palate as he enunciates the 't'."

    Am I the only one standing in front of the mirror trying to caress the front of my palate with my tongue while saying "eat" and enunciating the "t"?

    And sounding like I have a speech impediment?

    ReplyDelete
  51. 'There was a time I wouldn't subject anyone to her cooking... even - who do I hate?' Why KATE, of course!

    Great recap, as ever! I have enjoyed reading these. Just wanted to say that I'm British and have never met any Brit who got defensive about the idea of being in Europe. However we do (in a weird cultural quirk) refer to 'Europeans' in a separate way, which probably sounds weird to Americans, but all it really means is 'mainland Europeans'. I suspect it comes of not being joined on. Anyway, it's not a slur against Europe or anything. I do agree that E.L.James is constantly making the fact that she's British obvious. There is apparently a parody novel coming out called '50 Shades of Earl Grey' and I'm really hoping the author chose that title because he plans to make fun of how British all the American characters in this book are.

    ReplyDelete
  52. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  53. I really enjoy your recaps and agree with much of what you say. However, I don't think your critique of his music choices are fair. Christian's love of classical music may not necessarily be that far fetched considering that he has had piano formal lessons since childhood and still loves to play. In fact, the book gives the impression that he is practically a classically trained concert level pianist. In that context, his love of classical music and opera does actually make sense to me. I think the constant references to certain expensive wines scream "pretentious asshole" way more than the choices in music do.

    ReplyDelete
  54. "Of course, it's French, so we'd have to probably change that, or it will steal Ana's boyfriend."

    LOL!!

    Please, please, please, PLEASE do book two!!!

    ReplyDelete
  55. "Yup, that's exactly what it is, Ana. Your hymen grew back. Only, something went... wrong. And now it has engulfed all of Seattle."

    At that point, I did such a strong literal LOL that I doubled over and drooled on myself. I don't think I've ever done that before.

    ReplyDelete
  56. When I hear the name 'Elena', I think Final Fantasy 7. Where the character named Elena IS blonde. So therefore it's okay for Ana to hate her.

    ReplyDelete
  57. I swear my organ payment is in the mail! I sent it Saturday check the postmark!

    ReplyDelete
  58. "Congratulations, darling! We have to buy some champagne!" She's clapping her hands and jumping up and down. Is she forty-two or twelve?

    Maybe she's your inner goddess, Ana.


    My thoughts exactly.

    Also, I have the greatest respect for you for reading this terrible, terrible book and continuing to post. A weaker soul would have long since set that waste of paper on fire and/or have run for the hills, screaming.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Just: I agree with everything.

    What worries me is that this book is popular, and that there actually are people who like it (different from merely reading it because everyone else does). I didn't think anyone liked it. But they do.

    The other thing was about the meal, Ana paying for it and this emasculating Christian (or threatening to, since she doesn't pay, and therefore he retains his balls which would disappear otherwise). I actually read on one of those 'how not to lose your man' or whatever they're called, self-help guides to relationships, that you must never, ever pay for a meal, and you must always, always let him pay for everything because if you don't, he thinks he is only a friend and not a romantic prospect, and also that 'men like to be men' and find any kind of sign of women's emancipation or equality terribly threatening and you have to underplay these things or you will lose him. I found that odd, and I found the whole guide really odd too - I wish I could remember what it was now, as you'd have a hell of a time with it, Jennifer. You weren't allowed to be unhappy, either, however you felt, you always had to be cheerful. 'Men like nothing worse than female pain.' It reminded me of those enforced brothels in the death camps where you got beaten to death for not smiling while you were being raped. All self-help books are like that. So before I start saying, it's not about 'emasculating Christian' it's actually about 'emasculating CHRISTIANITY' (which it is, figuratively, from the point of view of an inhabitant of Joy Division, another reason I have trouble with this book because it is, while a few steps removed I grant you, a kind of justification for the Holocaust - I will prove this at some point), let us move on. Point being, and this fits with my earlier point, that lots of people like this book - a LOT of people believe that this sort of moral, mental and physical subjugation to nothing but the pointless ego of a petty tyrant (whom by the way I would just be disgustingly rude to, however good-looking, which is why I don't have a boyfriend, and no opportunity to 'pay for a meal') is something that women must do, or risk disfavour, because it is the male ego that means everything, and female emotion or expression of no value (well, not if you want 'a relationship' (sic.)), and there are even books to tell you how to do it, and they chime in with society at large, which is why Fifty Shades (the novel) represents the status quo and Fifty Shades (the critique) represents a small, marginalistic, subversive faction.

    Until those positions are reversed, I remain terribly unhappy. I can't even be happy looking at a tree any more. I don't know what to do.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Oh noo why didn't you talk about the how much they disarm each other thing? I read that part and I was laughing so much - BECAUSE IT WAS STRAIGHT OUTTA TWILIGHT. It was basically the scene where Bella tells Edward that he dazzles people and he frequently dazzles her.

    But anyway, GREAT RECAPS. You have made the top 3 of my Most Favourite Comedic People EVER list. Keep it up!!! :D:D:D:D

    ReplyDelete
  61. Holy. Fucking. Shit. (Get it? Get it? Get it? Christian talk par excellance!)

    You just referenced "Repo"! And I am officially in love with you. (So, you know... expect me at your doorstep within an hour. I'll just go "fire up" my private jet.)

    Loads of Jack Hyde in book two, a little less (though his presence LINGERS) in book three. Personally, I found book two better than book one. (Unlike "Twilight", where book two was appalling in its horrendous-ness for me. Twilight got progressively worse. This is more of a Gaussian curve.) This first one traumatized me. Think of the second one as more... cyber stalking. And no beating unless she begs him to, that's a fresh approach to battered woman syndrome. Sigh.

    But the Repo reference... SooooOOOOOOooooo much psycho-freaky love coming your way! :)

    ReplyDelete
  62. Just so you know, and don't sound completely clueless in the future...

    Scottish = British
    N. Irish = British
    Welsh = British
    English = British

    ReplyDelete

I'm super psyched that you're leaving a comment! I might not respond to each and every one, but I read them all. You guys rock!