Go To These Places!

Friday, June 1, 2012

50 Shades of Grey chapter 18 recap or "Fifty Shades of Fucked-Up"

Full disclosure? I'm eating an insane amount of candy right now.

Yesterday, this blog got 13,000 hits. I remember when I used to get excited to get fifty hits. So, thank you, whoever posted the link to reddit, which is yet another internet thing I do not understand.

On the other hand, now I know that many people are looking at this blog, and that means I'm under enormous pressure to perform. All this pressure, on the lady who can't even self promote correctly. Oy.

Also, my dogs are really going to town on each other right now. The humping. Dear god, the humping.

So, with that image in mind, onto the recap.

Chapter eighteen begins with another evil blonde:
Dr. Greene is tall, blond, and immaculate, dressed in a royal blue suit. I'm reminded o the women who work in Christian's office. She's like an identikit model - another Stepford blond.
At this point, I'm not sure E.L. James isn't an elaborate double life for Laurell K. Hamilton, because Ana hates on blondes the way Anita Blake hates on blondes. I'm waiting for Ana to say she doesn't need to wear base, it's getting to that point with the blonde comments. Look, we get it, Anata. Blondes are evil. Let's move on.
We shake hands, and I know she's one of those women who doesn't tolerate fools gladly. Like Kate. I like her immediately.
I'm having a hard time with the prose here. Is Ana saying that Kate is a fool? Or that the doctor is like Kate? I'd believe the former before I'd believe the latter, because Ana doesn't seem to like Kate much.  Doctor Greene examines her and gives her a prescription for the pill.
I love her no-nonsense attitude - she has lectured me until she's as blue as her dress about taking it at the same time every day. And I can tell she's burning with curiosity about my so-called relationship with Mr. Grey.
Or, she's burning with curiosity as to how a woman gets to be twenty-one without ever seeing a gynecologist. Seriously, Ana, people are not as obsessed with your relationship as you are. They go downstairs to find Christian sitting in his living room, listening to an aria with his eyes closed. I bet Christian only does that shit when people are around, and when he's by himself, he listens to Hot Chelle Rae.
"Are you done?" he asks as if he's genuinely interested.
Why would he ask if he wasn't interested?
 "Yes, Mr. Grey. Look after her; she's a beautiful, bright young woman." Christian is taken aback - as am I. What an inappropriate thing for a doctor to say.
Yes, that is an inappropriate thing for a doctor to say. It's left me wondering what kind of spectacular vagina Ana must have, if the doctor could tell she was bright just from examining it. Is it full of brains and MENSA literature? Does a light bulb come on automatically when she uncrosses her legs?
Taylor appears from nowhere to escort her through the double doors and out to the elevator. How does he do that? Where does he lurk?
This brings up something I've been meaning to address for some time. I have the same questions about Taylor. Here's the thing, Ana has walked around Christian's house and cooked him bottomless breakfast. Christian intends to make Ana his sex slave, which I assume will entail some degree of sexual activity outside of the bedroom, possibly walking her on a leash, hell, I don't know what he's into. But I think I would be super uncomfortable if there was just some creepy Matrix guy who stepped out of seemingly no where at any time. What if Ana is getting rammed over a pool table, is he going to surreptitiously take a shot at the corner pocket? That's not a sex euphemism, I'm just genuinely wondering how much of Christian's sex life he watches, and possibly films.

That sex room was dancing with me.

Ana tells Christian that the doctor told her to abstain from sex for a month, as a joke.
He narrows his eyes, and I immediately stop laughing. In fact, he looks rather forbidding. Oh shit. My subconscious quails in the corner as all the blood drains from my face, and I imagine him putting me across his knee again.
"Gotcha!" he says and smirks.
Oh ho, what a jolly jape that fellow is having with a sex partner who fears his temper! La, what cheek, to jest with the lady about threats of physical violence! Encore! Encore!

Chedward decides that Ana needs to eat, because the reader isn't yet tired of listening to them argue about whether or not she's eaten enough. This happens often enough in the book that I'm pretty sure women aren't actually fantasizing about the sex. I think it's more like:

I step off the digital scale slowly. Jeez, my subconscious thinks, quite consciously. He looks so terrifyingly angry. Is it because I'm so much fatter and unfortunate looking than my roommate, Barbie? It must be, for I am so unworthy of this shimmering Adonis. Gazing at him, I open my mouth to apologize, when he picks up the scale and smashes it into the wall, breaking it. Holy crap! He walks over to me and kisses me, hard. Breathless in his arms, I hear his voice as if from far away. "I have ordered pizza for you, the cheese-and-meatiest my considerable fortune could procure. It is being flown directly from Chicago via Charlie Tango, my helicopter which you may have forgotten about. You don't eat enough. I should know. I can drive a helicopter."

Yeah, that's pretty much the fantasy I think these books are inspiring. RPattz railing some woman as she's bent over a kitchen counter strewn with pizza boxes, stuffing her face.

Christian gets out a salad and Ana admires his grace as he moves around the kitchen. Of course, grace is really in the eye of the beholder. I'm sure Ana finds anyone who can walk three consecutive steps without tripping "graceful". Christian also gets out the wine, because it's five o'clock somewhere, literally every hour of the day for these people. Christian asks what birth control method Ana opted for, and when she tells him, he frowns.
"And will you remember to take it regularly, at the right time, every day?" Jeez... of course I will. How does he know? I blush at the thought, probably from one or more of the fifteen.
Setting aside the massive amounts of clunk in that sentence, I'm actually surprised that Christian is okay with this method of birth control. A guy like this, with this amount of money, it seems like he'd wrap it the fuck up to avoid paying child support. He's such a control freak, I'd think he'd want to know for sure and certain that he's not going to be spawning any little Greys.

They eat their salads, and Christian asks Ana if she really wants to do this. When she points out that she hasn't signed anything, he tells her it's okay, because he's breaking a lot of rules lately.
"Are you going to hit me?"
"Yes, but it won't be to hurt you. I don't want to punish you right now. If you'd caught me yesterday evening, well, that would have been a different story." Holy cow. He
wants to hurt me... how do I deal with this? I can't hide the horror on my face.
"Don't let anyone try and convince you otherwise, Anastasia. One of the reasons people like me do this is because we either like to give or receive pain. It's very simple. You don't, so I spent a great deal of time yesterday thinking about that." He pulls me against him, and his erection presses into my belly. I should run, but I can't. I'm drawn to him on some deep, elemental level, that I can't begin to understand.
It's "battered woman syndrome" according a commenter (thanks, commenter!) a few entries back. That's the deep, elemental pull. Notice, she's still saying "hit" instead of "spank" or "punish" or another one of those fun, tingly in the pants region BDSM words. And I take issue with Christian's assessment that people involved in BDSM are in it for the pain. I hate pain, but I like being tied up and told what to do. Where is your God now, Christian Grey? WHERE IS YOUR GOD NOW?

So, of course, he's thought about the fact that she doesn't like pain, but he hasn't reached a conclusion either way about whether or not their relationship will include those elements. But there's no time to talk about such trivial things now, for he must fuck her!
My heart starts pounding. This is it. I'm really going to do this. My inner goddess is spinning like a world-class ballerina, pirouette after pirouette. He opens the door to his playroom, standing back for me to walk through, and I am once more in the Red Room of Pain. It's the same, the smell of leather, citrus, polish and dark wood, all very sensual. My blood is running heated and scared through my system - adrenaline mixed with lust and longing. It's a heady, potent cocktail. Christian's stance has changed completely, subtly altered, harder and meaner. He gazes down at me and his eyes are heated, lustful... hypnotic.
If this is not a BPAL perfume collection within six months, I'll eat a vegetable. This would be a perfect excerpt to use as the description. It would just be followed by something like, "Lustful notes of leather, crisp citrus, feral musk and rich mahogany, blended together in an hypnotic, sensual dance." There, BPAL, I just made you another $35 bucks, at least.

Christian reiterates that Ana is there for his enjoyment, to do whatever he wants. He gets her undressed, and tells her that her body is "a joy to behold." If a dude said that to me, I would immediately take the awkward phrasing as a sign that he was being totally sarcastic. He wants Ana to be unembarrassed by her nakedness, which is easier said than done, when a fully dressed guy is just standing there, staring at you. She isn't allowed to make a sound, unless he asks her to, and she has to call him "Sir". She's also supposed to keep her hair braided, and wear just her panties when she's in the Red Room.
"Good girl." His eyes burn into mine. "When I tell you to come in here, I expect you to kneel over there." He points to a spot beside the door. "Do it now." I blink processing his words, turn, and rather clumsily kneel as directed.
"You can sit back on your heels."
I sit back.
"Place your hands and forearms flat on your thighs. Good. Now part your knees. Wider. Wider. Perfect. Look down at the floor."
Not many people know this, but Chedward used to be a photographer at the Sears portrait studio.
Now let's take a look at your pictures from this week's BDSM shoot.

After he gets Ana just the way he likes her, he leaves. Ana waits, wondering where he's gone, and in the next paragraph, he's back! Yay! He's wearing ripped jeans (like the ones she dreamed about), and he wants to chain her up.
"I'm going to chain you now, Anastasia. Give me your right hand." I give him my hand. He turns it palm up, and before I know it, he swats the center with a riding crop I hadn't even noticed is in his right hand. It happens so quickly that the surprise hardly registers. Even more astonishing - it doesn't hurt. Well, not much, just a slight ringing sting.
This is one of those things that drives me crazy about this book. We're supposed to believe that Ana notices his pants before she notices that he's carrying a freaking riding crop? She's so keyed up and fearful about being in the Red Room of Pain, she's not going to notice when he's holding an implement? The very implement she had a sex dream about? But she'll notice, in no less than four adjectives, that his jeans are "older, ripped, soft, and over-washed"? I'm not buying it.

Christian tells her that what they're going to do won't hurt. I don't know, being hit with a riding crop seems like it would hurt, but what do I know? He shackles Ana to the metal grid on the ceiling, and explains that he can move her around the room. I guess it's like those tracks they put curtains on in the hospital, then.
I oblige immediately, feeling like I'm exiting my body - a casual observer of events as they unfold around me. This is beyond fascinating, beyond erotic. It's singularly the most exciting and scary thing I've ever done. I'm entrusting myself to a beautiful man who, by his own admission, is fifty shades of fucked-up. I suppress the brief thrill of fear. Kate and Elliot, they know I'm here.
Nothing says "erotic" quite like, "My roommate knows my whereabouts, so if he murders me, at least he'll get caught." I'm surprised they didn't just title the book "Fifty Shades of Fucked-Up," since it fits a lot better.
Standing in front of me again, he hooks his fingers into my panties, and at a most unhurried pace, peels them down my legs, stripping me agonizingly slowly, so that he ends up kneeling in front of me. Not taking his eyes off mine, he scrunches my panties in his hand, holds them up to his nose, and inhales deeply. Holy fuck. Did he just do that? He grins wickedly at me and tucks them into the pocket of his jeans.
Keep in mind, she's just had a gynecological exam. So, enjoy that whiff of KY and latex you're getting, man.  I'm not sure why this shocks Ana. He sucked on her toes after she had gone running and sat around in her sweaty socks for literally hours. It's not like he isn't into her bodily aromas. Then, he starts hitting her in the vagina with the riding crop, and she loves it.
He comes to a stop... but I can no longer see him. My eyes are closed as I try to absorb the myriad of sensations coursing through my body. Very slowly, he rains small, biting licks of the crop down my belly, heading south. I know where this is leading, and I try and psyche myself up for it - but when he hits my clitoris, I cry out loudly.
 Jesus Christo, I would, too. Unfortunately, she's not crying out the safe word, so the scene keeps going.
"See how wet you are for this, Anastasia. Open your eyes and your mouth." I do as I'm told, completely seduced. He pushes the tip of the crop into my mouth, like my dream. Holy shit.
So, Ana finally acknowledges that this is exactly like the dream she had,  and Christian makes her come by twacking her in the clit with the riding crop. Then he pushes her up against the wooden cross on the wall and fucks her.
I feel so weak, but I do as he asks as he wraps my legs around his hips and positions himself beneath me. With one thrust, he's inside me, and I cry out again, listening to his muffled moan at my ear. My arms are resting on his shoulders as he thrusts into me. Jeez, it's deep this way. He thrusts again and again, his face at my neck, his harsh breathing at my throat. I feel the build up again. Jeeze no... not again... I don't think my body will with-stand another earth-shattering moment. But I have no choice... and with an inevitability that's becoming familiar, I let go and come again, and it's sweet and agonizing and intense.
I think Ana might be the only person alive who doesn't like orgasms. Seriously? "Jeez no... not again...?" It's like, orgasm #2. I wonder if this is some symptom of our messed up culture, we can show the heroine of an erotic novel having orgasms, just so long as they're portrayed as mildly unpleasant? I suppose only dirty, dirty sluts like Kate enjoy multiple orgasms.

Ana is all wore out from the sexing, but Christian has no refractory period, apparently, because he's "not finished with you yet."
Not finished with me yet. Holy Moses. There's no way I can do any more. I am utterly spent and fighting an overwhelming desire to sleep. I'm leaning against his chest, my eyes are closed, and he's wrapped around me - arms and legs - and I feel... safe, and oh so comfortable. Will he let me sleep, perchance to dream?
Will he murder you? Because that line is about dying, specifically, about whether or not you should kill yourself before your uncle-dad gets a crack at you. I have this crazy feeling that this does not apply to Ana's situation.

If thou couldst twack mine lady garden sharply with a riding crop, t'wouldst be great.

I'm stuck on the part in that last excerpt where she says his his arms and legs are wrapped around her. They're standing. So, is he riding on her like a baby monkey? What is going on here?

No time to explain, because Ana touches his chest and he tells her to not to, leading to big revelation of what he's hiding with his constant shirtfulness:
I flush and look back at his chest in longing. I want to run my tongue through the hair, kiss him, and for the first time, I notice he has a few random and faint small, round scars dotted around his chest. Chicken pox? Measles? I think absently.
So, there you go. Christian has scars. He takes off the shackles and has her kneel by the door. Ana is so tired, her inner goddess has gone to sleep. I know you were dying to know what Ana's inner goddess was doing. He ties Ana's hands together with a cable tie.
Jeez... the plastic cable ties. Restocking at Clayton's! It all becomes clear.
How was it unclear from the moment you found out about the BDSM? He's a millionaire! Do you really think he's going to do his own remodel? Are you serious with this? Christian tells her that he wants more (more cable ties?) but that he'll make it quick, because he knows she's tired. Where have heard this exchange before?



Because Ana's business hours are over, Chedward settles for fucking her from behind while she holds onto the bed with wrists ziptied together.
I grip harder round the post and push back against him as he continues his merciless onslaught, again and again, his fingers digging into my hip. My arms are aching, my legs feel uncertain, my scalp is getting sore from his tugging on my hair... and I can feel a gathering deep inside me. Oh no... and for the first time, I fear my orgasm... if I come...
Are you kidding me? "For the first time?" Didn't we already establish that WORDS MEAN THINGS? You feared the last one, you were all, "Oh jeezy crap, I'm going to come again," and now suddenly it's the first time you dread having an orgasm?
My body is responding... how? I feel a quickening.
 Yeesh, no wonder you dread your orgasms. I don't blame you, that movie was terrible.

Of course Chedward's magic dick ("Buster Hymen" as we know and love him) makes her come again, and she blacks out or something, because the next thing she knows, she's on top of him on the floor. They have a weird conversation about her giggle, and then playtime is over.
He stoops to help me to my feet and leads me to the door, on the back of which hangs a grey waffle robe. He patiently dresses me as if I'm a small child.

And then Christian takes her to her bedroom and gets in bed with her, instead of going to his own room, because, you know, she's healing him with her love or something. And the chapter ends.

Now, in an act of shameless self promotion, allow me to remind you that you still have a few hours to enter the Sex Saturday contest, which closes at 6pm EST: You could win a book.

45 comments:

  1. "Gazing at him, I open my mouth to apologize, when he picks up the scale and smashes it into the wall, breaking it. Holy crap! He walks over to me and kisses me, hard. Breathless in his arms, I hear his voice as if from far away. 'I have ordered pizza for you, the cheese-and-meatiest my considerable fortune could procure. It is being flown directly from Chicago via Charlie Tango, my helicopter which you may have forgotten about. You don't eat enough. I should know. I can drive a helicopter.'"

    My man is like this. Except for the helicopter part. And the considerable fortune.

    Also, um, I thought the point of BDSM wasn't to punish? That if a person were in the mood to actually punish, play needed to stop? So Christian being in it for the fun = not squicky, but mentioning that he would've given her the what-for another time = get it away from me, personally.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If thou couldst twack mine lady garden sharply with a riding crop, t'wouldst be great.

    Oh dear lord, I actually snorted my drink up my nose at that. Bravo!

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Keep in mind, she's just had a gynecological exam. So, enjoy that whiff of KY and latex you're getting, man."

    Oh, good golly, this book! Nothing in it makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  4. She... there was a condom involved, right? These people don't think that birth control works by popping a pill and immediately you're covered, right? They know it takes at least two weeks, right?

    Right?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm glad to hear you're getting so many view now. You totally deserve it. I always look forward to reading your posts. I haven't commented in a while, but I'm just loving these recaps. I had read the first two books before they exploded in popularity and it's almost as if we've read totally different books. You're making it so incredibly funny. If you could sign on to work on the movie script and make it a comedy... oh man.

    I almost want you to do the whole trilogy, but I won't ask you to subject yourself to that haha.

    I'll end with my favorite quote from this post.
    "It is being flown directly from Chicago via Charlie Tango, my helicopter which you may have forgotten about. You don't eat enough. I should know. I can drive a helicopter'"

    Is 'I drive a helicopter' the new 'I'm on a boat' ? I think so.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm glad to hear you're getting so many view now. You totally deserve it. I always look forward to reading your posts. I haven't commented in a while, but I'm just loving these recaps. I had read the first two books before they exploded in popularity and it's almost as if we've read totally different books. You're making it so incredibly funny. If you could sign on to work on the movie script and make it a comedy... oh man.

    I almost want you to do the whole trilogy, but I won't ask you to subject yourself to that haha.

    I'll end with my favorite quote from this post.
    "It is being flown directly from Chicago via Charlie Tango, my helicopter which you may have forgotten about. You don't eat enough. I should know. I can drive a helicopter'"

    Is 'I drive a helicopter' the new 'I'm on a boat' ? I think so.

    ReplyDelete
  7. My first thought, like another commenter, was about the first birth control pill/no condom thing as well. I was like, uh, they totally just made a baby Chedannabell.

    ReplyDelete
  8. "Jeez, it's deep this way."

    There's just nothing sexier than "jeez" (or crap!) in the middle of an account of a hot fuck. I mean, for a minute there, Ana was actually thinking the F Word in her mind! And now that she's actually fucking someone, she's back to "jeez"?

    Also, Nim might not want to ask you to subject yourself to the rest of the trilogy so you can recap it for us, but I DO! PLEASE! You're simply brilliant and I need your blog like medicine, especially your recaps.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I get the sense that the author is rather inexperienced, shall we say. Your extracts remind me of a lot of fanfiction from inexperienced teens (and older). Rather breathless, badly written etc. I could slap the publishers. There are so many really good writers just begging for a chance and they waste it on this rubbish? *sigh* Well, thank you for reading it so I don't have to. You deserve a medal!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hiya, "Battered Person Syndrome" commenter here...

    Just to key you in with the whole thing about not having been to a gynecologist... Being British, just like the author, I can assure you that we just don't go, unless we have to. A woman, who is not sexually active and who has nothing obviously wrong with her glory hole, is unlikely to get a speculum slid into her sideways smile until she reaches 25, when our health service will summon her for a smear test for cervical cancer - we get routine pap tests from 25 onwards, but prior to that the test result is likely to through out false results (apparently)

    So IF Ana had been written British, this 'no gyne' thing would have made a lot more sense.

    Plus - your use of "Chedward" is genius... over here we have an aweful pop duo called Jedward... Please google... you'll be glad you did :oD Chedward will never look the same again!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I got linked to your blog through my friend, and I just want to let you know that you are hilarious! I read the 50 shades trilogy as if I were watching a carwreck - I knew it was wrong (and boring), but I couldn't stop, because I had to try and find out why everyone else loved it.

    I think you are doing good work and please do not stop. Do the triology, because as I am reading some of your comments, I am thinking, JUST. YOU. WAIT. All the horrible things you can think of do come true.

    P.S. Because of your blog, I'm going to check out your Blood ties series!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I try to always read your blog when no one's around, so I'm not interrupted by queries of "wth is so funny?". Also, I 3rd(?) that motion that you pleeease do the whole trilogy. I can't get enough of you. Jeezy crap, I can't quit you. More twacking pls.

    ReplyDelete
  13. it almost makes me sad that I left Fetlife as I can guarentee the new profiles are hysterical!

    The annoying thing about a lot of the Budsum stuff is she is almost there - not my kinks, but YMANMYBTOK (you kinks are not my kinks but thats ok) - as almost there as a newbie whos read too much bondage.com posts anyway. BUt she is SO off on the (dangerous, abusive, horrifically manipulative) realtionship.

    FYI - if you like pain its a good idea not to have insaine giggling as the endorphic response.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I just wanted you to know, the 'baby monkey' comment had a whole room full of people rolling around with laughter. Good show.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I wandered on to your blog in my attempt to decide whether or not these books were worth a looksy. I have now finished all three, but I have got to say, I keep reading your commentary. You are without a doubt one of the most hilarious individuals I have ever come across. The analysis of the writing is on point! I often have to physically stifle my laughter so others don't stare at that crazy lady (me) in hysterics at her computer. You have a new loyal fan! Thanks for the ha-has :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. I picture the 'ceiling grid' as one of those things at the dry-cleaners that brings the clothes around.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Honestly, one of the things that would drive me NUTS reading this series is her saying "Jeez". I literally can't think of the last time someone said "Jeez" in my presence. I want to slap her for that alone...

    ReplyDelete
  18. "Didn't we already establish that WORDS MEAN THINGS? " - hahahaha! People everywhere should read your version of that horrid book instead!

    ReplyDelete
  19. "He patiently dressed me as if I'm a small child."
    ....
    Every time I see that picture, I just laugh hysterically.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Nothing says "erotic" quite like, "My roommate knows my whereabouts, so if he murders me, at least he'll get caught."

    I can't help wondering if this is a long con, and a sequel to this book will have abuse revealed for what it is.


    I'm stuck on the part in that last excerpt where she says his his arms and legs are wrapped around her. They're standing.

    Going by previous text, her legs are wrapped around him as well, and she's still chained to the ceiling. They must be swinging like a pendulum.

    ReplyDelete
  21. So her first real BDSM scene and they go right for the riding crop to the clit (ow!) even though Ana previously expressed fear and uncomfortableness at the idea of pain, and of course she immediately loves it and has multiple orgasms.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That bothered me too.
      So far, she'd only been tied with a necktie previously (in the "delightful" context of him raping her after a pretend break-up). Just before this chapter, they were talking about the fact that she's really not at all into pain play and that it scares her and makes her feel awful, etc. That was after a simple over the knee spanking with a hand.
      Next scene, without any other conversation/negotiation on the matter, he chains her to the ceiling and hits her clit with a riding crop? Isn't that a bit of a jump? (And quite non-consensual too.)
      So many things are too much for her level of experience (and lack of genuine interest) in BDSM. Her first experience with an impact implement has to be with a riding crop, and directly on the clit. While being chained to the ceiling (chain-on-skin directly, no cuffs are mentioned at all), in suspension, and later he puts his weight on her too.
      Somehow she doesn't have wrist or blood flow problems from that, and the huge level-up in pain she went through brought her an instantaneous orgasm?
      Is the author aware that a clit is wayyyy more sensitive than a butt? (How can someone not know that?) Does she know about basic bondage safety? Or impact play, or overall CONSENT, or... So many things. She probably just googled a couple of kinky pictures out of context (and images from the Twilight movies) and considered it "research".

      Delete
  22. I was pointed toward your blog by a friend, and I told myself I wasn't going to start commenting until I had caught up; but when I read the following line, I just had to offer my two cents ... such as they are:

    "I wonder if this is some symptom of our messed up culture, we can show the heroine of an erotic novel having orgasms, just so long as they're portrayed as mildly unpleasant? I suppose only dirty, dirty sluts like Kate enjoy multiple orgasms."

    Sadly, I believe you've hit the nail right on the head. One of the many complaints brought up in the documentary "This Film Not Yet Rated" is that a movie featuring female pleasure during sex inevetably gets a higher and harsher rating than a movie that features male pleasure, or worse, female pain.

    The prime example was the movie "Boys Don't Cry". The anal rape scene was acceptable in the eyes of the Censors, but the scene where the leads make love and an orgasm is implied by the look on the girl's face? That got them an NC-17 rating.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Funny how she dreads and hates her orgasms, but thoroughly enjoys being whacked in the clit with a riding crop.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I'm into pain. I've had my clit tortured with various implements and loved it. That said, if Ana couldn't handle a bare hand spanking, a riding crop to the clit would have left her screaming "Red!" If she could talk at all. Crops are much more intense than hands.

    Also, was that a Gorean slave pose he put her in?

    ReplyDelete
  25. "As if I'm a small child"

    STOP!!!

    ReplyDelete
  26. For what it's worth, it takes 3 full months of being on the pill before it hits the 98% and you can't start it until after your period. Bravo to the author for mis-educating readers about an important topic...

    ReplyDelete
  27. Confession time here: I didn't see a gynecologist for the first time until I was 31 years old. I was a virgin, I'd never had any problems, and I was overly modest and embarrassed. Not the smartest thing to wait so long, but it's not unheard of.

    Btw, I just found these recaps tonight, and they make me depressed for humanity.

    (I rarely if ever post anonymously, but this comment is a little personal.)

    ReplyDelete
  28. Has anyone seen the South Park episode when Chris Hanson stops by? Every time I see his pic on this blog I have to say it...Chris Haaaaaaanson. Chris Hansoooon. Yes I believe they are in the Matrix cause only an Agent can manipulate someone's mind to let them think all this fuccery is ok. I'm just saying.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I would like to comment on the whole orgasm thing.
    Firstly though, love your blog, has me laughing every time, and as others have said - please please do the other 2!!!

    Anyway, the orgasm thing. I do see the point you are making about women potentially being made to feel 'dirty' for experiencing pleasure. However, I can very much relate to the "oh no not again" response. For me and I am sure many others, having an orgasm is pretty damn intense - physically and emotionally. I think some men feel some sort of accomplishment for how many times they can make a girl come in one 'session'. It can leave you drained, spent, exhausted etc. And dreading more. Overstimulation is not generally that pleasant. It all comes down to how individuals cope, and some are a lot more sensitive than others.

    I know this is a critique, and it would really defeat the purpose of the recaps if you made a bunch of exceptions, but I do feel you could be more flexible on some of your points.
    Anywho, that's my rant, and I'll keep reading because you are rather spot on the majority of the time =)

    ReplyDelete
  30. Love the Chris Hansen pics whenever young children are mentioned! A friend told me about this blog and I'm very glad for it. I dislike how this book suggests that you have to be "fifty shades of fucked up" to be into BDSM.

    ReplyDelete
  31. @Anonymous, I thought I was the only one who noticed the Gorean slave pose thing! That made me think, what with his whole "total submission I will follow you to Alaska" business, Christian is actually just using this farce of BDSM to get Ana involved, and what he's really aiming for is full-time Gorean slavery. It fights right in with the abusive threatening behavior.

    And Jennifer, thank you SO much for writing these. They get at so much of what I find problematic about these books (and frankly, to a lesser extent, Twilight.) I prefer my romantic heroes free of threatening abusive behavior, thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I'm confused by him pulling off her underwear....maybe I missed something, but didn't he have her strip naked a little bit before that? Does she sprout a new set of underwear seconds after another pair has been removed?

    ReplyDelete
  33. I know I am way late with this, but the Gor-slave-pose thing boggled me. "put your hands and forearms flat on your thighs." I was like "wut" and then I tried to do it and it's not really sexy if you're hunched over like Quasimodo.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Am I missing something? Ana keeps referring to her utter clumsiness, but I could only find 2 instances of said issue. She pratfalls into his office & walks into traffic & then...what else?

    I only mention it because you've talked about it.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Wow, it's super healthy to always talk about painplay in terms of being actually angry and attempting to really punish someone. I know I've always been disappointed that my partners who have smacked me around in bed weren't pissed off at me when they did so and in fact seemed both appreciative that they were sleeping with me and eager to give me something that I wanted. I guess they're just no Christian Greys.

    ReplyDelete
  36. I also thought I'd hold my comments to the end (thank you so much for doing this!!), but needed to pipe up about the birth control bit.
    A couple chapters ago I thought: wait, she's not on the pill, and you should wait at least until after your next period, and ideally 3 months before it's guaranteed to be working properly. I drove my bf insane with that bit, but it's worth it.
    So when Ana jokes about not being able to have sex for a month, I'm like, YES! that would be a smart idea! And oh, she has to get bloodwork done (also smart), but he doesn't? Bull shit!
    While I appreciate there being mentions of "safe" sex, get your fucking facts straight first!
    I will save the rest of my ranting for later, but my deepest thanks for the humanitarian effort you are undertaking.

    ReplyDelete
  37. I went to a gynecologist (actually I think it was health services at my all-female college, but close enough) when I was 18 and they told me to come back when I was sexually active or preparing to become so. So it might not be totally insane for her to not have seen a doctor. Admittedly I had a partially-intact hymen at the time, which may or may not have made a difference.

    Thanks for recapping these books - really enjoying it.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Re. the birth control issues... Waiting period for full efficacy of the pill aside, I was kind of impressed that ELJ made such a point of consistently including details of their condom use. Seriously, there were so many descriptions of the tearing foil wrapper I almost wondered if it was some sort of Pavlovian thing to get Ana primed. (And do condoms come wrapped in foil in the UK? Because I've only ever encountered plastic-wrapped condoms...)

    Hilarious recap, as always!

    ReplyDelete
  39. she didn't have access to a computer or know how to use wiki
    she was amazed at power steering
    she didn't have a black berry/ smart phone
    she never went to a gynecologist...

    one would think she was from a third world country

    also thank you for pointing out she hasn't said anything intelligent or bright in the whole book. she is as boring as bella if not worse.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey man, speaking as a person that lives in a third-world country, we have/do/are unimpressed by all that shit. This chick is from the 18th century at least.

      Delete
  40. I crack up every time you wordlessly provide the picture of the dude in the suit. Hilarious.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I love your summaries! It saves me the pain of actually paying money and wasting time reading these atrocities people call books. That Hamlet bit had me laughing so hard I couldn't breath. Just a question, did you purposely choose a picture of John Wilkes Booth as Hamlet or was that just a happy coincidence?

    ReplyDelete
  42. I'm a bit late to this party, my wife found this and told me to read it. I have to say first that I just read the most heinous blasphemy in the history of ever in this recap, so bad it made me think you kick puppies for fun ...... Highlander 2 wasn't that bad.

    Joking aside. My wife was given the book by a friend of hers and I spent the next week hearing about how hilarious it was. I thought it was a comedy the way she went on (my wife rarely takes things seriously). She then asked me why I can't be like the Grey fella. I asked her if she wants me to tie her up and she said no but it would be great if I was rich and she only had to see me on weekends.

    My wife folks, proving romance isn't dead.

    ReplyDelete
  43. First Abed/Batman, then Tobias the nevernude, and now Flight of the Concords..? Are you my inner subconcious goddess giddily jumping up and down clapping like a child about to taste ice cream for the first time? I think yes. Love you.

    ReplyDelete

I'm super psyched that you're leaving a comment! I might not respond to each and every one, but I read them all. You guys rock!