Go To These Places!

Sunday, April 29, 2012

A break in 50 Shades recapping to clarify some points.

Thanks to the miracle of GoodReads.com, I realize I have to clarify that I have read the entire book. My recaps give the impression that I started out reading the book with the intent to criticize it, a chapter at a time. That makes me seem like a bullheaded weirdo who sets out to dislike something. When I started the recaps, of course I knew I had read the whole thing and was presenting it as a read-a-long for comedic effect, but I failed to realize that you didn't know that. So, yes, I have read the entire book. I found it a surprisingly fast and easy read, so it has that going for it.

Furthermore, another author, Jennifer L. Armentrout, is experiencing some backlash because people are confusing the two of us. So, people who are angry at me are, for some inexplicable reason, deleting her books from their GoodReads.com libraries. Don't do that. She's not me. She's not my pen name, as some have theorized. Come on, guys. If I was going to go deep stealth, do you think I would do it by changing one of the eighteen letters of my name and figure the other seventeen were good to go?

Also, what the hell. Don't use GoodReads.com as a weapon, especially if you don't know if you're directing it towards the right person.

I feel like at this point, I need to take a few days off from recapping. I don't want to destroy anyone's reputation (except for my own... I am the sole architect of my own destruction). And I need to think seriously about whether or not I should continue. If it were just a few people grumbling about me being mean and they're never going to read my books because I'm so mean, I would keep going just to spite them. Because fuck 'em, I'm not on this planet to make everyone like me, and I really resent the implication that I should need or want everyone to like me. But some nimrods are actively attacking a writer who isn't even me. It's not fair if she gets caught in the crossfire.

This puts me in a really weird place. If I stop, I'm rewarding the bad behavior of a few people and telling them that they are entitled to dictate author behavior with their system of star giving. That's not what I'm saying at all. I'm not considering giving up the recaps because I'm afraid of down votes or bad reviews or hate mail. I can handle all those things. What I'm saying is, I don't want to harm an innocent bystander with my actions. It also reinforces the notion that female writers are unwillingly drafted into the Sunshine Sisterhood of Always Being Nice, and if you speak up about someone's at least partially plagiarized book, you're not living up to reader expectations of said niceness. Never, in my entire career, have I ever been asked by a publisher to sign a niceness clause, so I really don't get where that expectation comes from. 

Now, I'm not a fan of "freedom of speech... without consequences." If you don't like what I have to say, by all means, let me know. Let everyone know. Don't buy my book. Actively discourage others from buying my books. That's your right to react to my opinion, and I would never dream of controlling your reaction to my opinion. But do it with honesty, and for fuck's sake, be sure you're saying it about the right author.

I'll be back Wednesday with a decision, either way. If I choose to continue the recaps, I'll continue the recaps. If I don't, I'll just post something else, probably as acidic and misanthropic as everything else that I post, but hopefully unlikely to fuck with the career of someone who just has a similar name as mine.

Which probably means I owe her an apology for all the times I've talked about weed on Twitter.

22 comments:

  1. Please continue! Your recaps are great and really a high light of my day. I have encouraged people to come read your recaps because they are great.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love you, girlie. I hope you continue because your recaps light up my day but I understand if you don't continue in order to help out OtherJennifer. Let's face it... people suck. You've been telling the absolute truth about this book and the only reason people are rabid about 50 Shades is because the Twihards are behind it. Honestly, it makes me ashamed to be a Twilight fan.

    Hang in there!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really hope that you continue the recaps. I've sent a couple people your way and we're all hugely amused (and nodding frantically along) by your recaps.

    I understand the inclination not to, for the other author's sake. I just hope the fangirl hivemind hasn't put you off voicing your opinion with your own, well, voice.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I hope you continue! I just stumbled upon your blog today and it is so funny. I don't understand why people can't have a sense of humor about stuff like this. I'm a fan of Twilight and I find myself laughing at all the similarities and ridiculousness of this book. I haven't read 50 Shades, but I have read the kindle sample and wasn't impressed. I'd mush rather read your recap! But, as a writer, I would understand if your discontinued it for the sake of the other party involved.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Awwwww, hell.

    This just sucks bigtime. I hope you don't let other people blackmail you into stopping. If you stop, the terrorists win. Just sayin'.

    I don't know if this helps, but I have introduced many people to your wonderful blog and more than one has asked me, "So...what does Jennifer Armintrout write? Which one of her books should I read first?" These are people who had never heard of you before, but fell in love with you via your 50 Shades recaps.

    Just want you to know that you're making a lot of people happy.

    Especially me.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You should continue. I'm about sick of this whole "You can't criticize, you must only say good things about..." mentality I’m seeing on GR and Amazon as of late. Negative reviews can save me time and money, especially if something is mentioned that I know is a…hard limit (see what I just did there?) for me.

    I've been enjoying your commentary. It's fun and it makes me laugh. Not in a mean way, mind you, but in a "man, my day was kind of crappy, and that giggle you just gave me? Yeah, it made up for my awful boss/coworkers/trek through traffic."

    Also: how petty have we become that we downvote/remove, etc. books just because of someone’s opinion? Not to mention that some people are obviously too trigger-happy to do their research before they start a smear campaign. Honestly, folks. Take a chill pill. Oh, and you—you keep on what you’re doing, please. Never mind the babies, some of us appreciate it for what it is.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is what is wrong with our society! Everyone is hyper sensitive and on a mission to rid the world of any opinion that differs from their own!
    Your recaps are AMAZING! I don't think they are mean, you are using direct quotes!! Someone else actually wrote this garbage and silly confused women like it! I'm ashamed to be a woman right now. These women wouldn't know what to do with a real man if they found one.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really hope you continue. Your blog posts have made me laugh out loud, cringe because I too read the whole book, and feel all smug since I hated the same things you're hilariously holding up to ridicule.

    Do what you have to do, but please don't let the stupid win!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Please don't stop writing the recaps. like many others I have sent people to your blog becausr its funny and nice to see someone be honest.

    If these numptys are being, lets face it bullies, then do you and otherjennifer want them to be fans? I agree that it is rabbid twilight fans that are doing this. I recently stopped going on some threads due to the same mentality towards my differing opinion of the BDB series by J R Ward.

    My view? They will move on to something else.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I just wanted to let you know I came to your blog today because I got linked to your absolutely hilarious recaps on Goodreads. I understand your position, but honestly, don't be afraid to say what you feel, especially if it's hilarious :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. If it helps, I'd never heard of you before all this, and now, you're absolutely on my 'to buy' list. Maybe the old 'no publicity is bad publicity' is true!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I've been reading your blog for awhile now and enjoyed your sense of humor and style.

    I really hope you continue the recaps of 50 Shades. Holy freaking hilarious. And it's about time that established authors joined regular readers in calling someone out on shitty writing.

    You are at the top of my TBR list.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Please don't stop the recaps! I loved Fifty Shades of Grey, but I love your recaps even more. I was in the shower yesterday cracking up over the anthromorphic tie!

    Also, the recaps are what brought me to your blog, which introduced me to you as an author, which has made me want to read your books! So it's helping sales too!!

    ReplyDelete
  14. a) please dont' stop, they are the highlight of 'watercooler' talk at my job (I work in a predominantly female office, with coworkers who are very vocal about things, so these recaps are a fun delight. Also its fun to educate people about stuff)

    b) I saw that over at the other Jennifer's blog--I admit in the past I've gotten you both mixed up, (including in an interview :sigh: I'll never live that down) but I've learned and really why should people care so much? These aren't great works of literature--hell they're not even decent reads of literature.

    But this is so much like the Twilight fandom--people were hating on Cleolinda when she did her Twilight book recaps much the same way they're hating on you. its ridiculous.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I don't know who you are, having only discovered you through the whole Good Reads pearl-clutching, fainting-couch uproar, but I'm now going to buy your books. Not Fifty Shades of Beige. Or whatever.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Your recaps are freaking HILARIOUS. They've been cracking me up like whoa. Please don't quit.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Please continue! These recaps are responsible for all my laughter the past day.

    I've gotten farther into the books by reading your recaps, than I did reading the book on my own. I just couldn't take another passage about Ana's inner goddess.

    I need this.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I was ready totally ready to give up on my fellow womens after reading that book. I felt all alone in the world but then you came along and rescued me. Please please please don't stop.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I saw a referral to your blog on someone else's blog. I just wanted to say that I find you incredibly funny and I love that you seem so real, upfront and pretty honest. I'm going to keep reading what you got here. I have never read any of your books and had never even heard of you until now. I might even read one of your books. Can't guarantee I'll like it, but I'll keep reading your blog here. Even if I do find something I don't like or disagree with (which I haven't yet) because hey, who wants to have the same opinion on everything anyway? That's not any fun at all.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I just wanted to add my encouragement. I LOVE your recaps. I read a couple of test chapters of FSOG to see what the fuss was about and wanted to rip my eyeballs out. But your recaps ARE something I want to read.

    I am definitely reading your books after this.

    ReplyDelete
  21. The underlying point you are making in the middle of all the humor (and you are really funny), is too important not to say. Yes, I know you've written an essay spelling out your thoughts on the equation of emotional abuse and romance in this book, but humor gets through to a different kind of audience. I think you have to balance the reputation of a fellow writer who is perfectly able to stand up for herself (especially with you affirming her protests) and the possibility that you may save some college student's life. I wish that last statement were melodrama, but I think we both know it isn't.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I came to this party really late. Someone posted a link to your blog on a message board thread about these books and I came and I loved it and I passed it along, but that was maybe a month ago (if that).

    I am a writer (no books published yet, but mostly because I am too self-critical and therefore keep starting things over instead of finishing them). I worked in journalism and not I do technical writing, which is boring, but I'm using my English degree so go me? Anyway, as a writer, I think these books NEED criticism and in exactly the way you're doing it. They're terrible and the fact that so many women love them shows a cultural decay, I think. That they were published by an actual publisher scares me.

    What I don't understand, what's just so weird to me, is that so many women are so ANGRY at any criticism. I have two Facebook friends who have posted statuses about how if people don't like these books, keep it to themselves, that no one should say anything negative about them and who are you to think you're some kind if literary critic???!!!!!

    If you don't want a book you like criticized, then stop reading. I loved The Help. LOVED.IT. But I know more than one person who hated it. Same with Harry Potter. I don't take it personally that some people hated something I loved. I didn't write any of those books. These people didn't write 50 Shades. We have a right to not like them and to say so and to say why (and there are myriad reasons to not like them).

    I'm glad you didn't stop. I enjoy every update. I love your commentary and I laugh maniacally over the excerpts you post. Because they are just ... so ... TERRIBLE!

    In short (ha! ha!), I love your recaps and you're doing a great service to the world. And an author's opinion of another author's work doesn't make the first author's work good or bad. It should stand on its own.

    ReplyDelete

I'm super psyched that you're leaving a comment! I might not respond to each and every one, but I read them all. You guys rock!